🌹Love Or Lust? - OT4 (Part 2)

1.3K 54 3
                                    

""Lips so good I forget my name,
I swear I could give you everything."

~~~

Rye's POV

Andy brought me to his bedroom.

"So, what did you want to talk about?" I asked nervously. He chuckled.

"Don't be so nervous. It's nothing bad. It's just about Sonny."

"I am so sorry for kissing him. I know we-"

"It's fine, Rye. To be honest, it kinda turned me on." He smirked. I raised an eyebrow.

"Really?"

He grabbed my hand and placed it against his hard dick, the smirk never leaving his face.

"You tell me." He winked, making me blush.

"So, now what?"

"Well, we obviously are in love. You have chemistry with Sonny, and so do I."

I looked at him questioningly.

"You aren't the only one who's ever fooled around with that man. He's the guy who took my virginity."

My eyes widened in shock. I did not see that coming.

"Woah, really?"

He nodded. "Back when we were in Overload. I thought he was fit, so one day I told him that. I had never classified myself as straight, so nothing really changed when he kissed me. He told me he was gay himself. We started sneaking around behind the other boys backs. It was just quick make outs and a couple of blow jobs. That was until one night we were cuddled up together, and I felt something hard against my ass. It turned me on, which is how I knew I was a bottom. I turned around and saw Sonny staring at me, pupils dilated. We both knew what we wanted, so that was the night we had sex for the first time." He explained.

"Oh, so you're gay?" I asked.

He shook his head. "I prefer not to label myself. But, if I was anything, I'm probably pansexual. But, I prefer no labels."

I nodded in understanding.

"So, I'll go back to my original question. Would you want to be in a polygamous relationship with me and Sonny? Obviously we'll have to ask him, but-"

I cut him off with a kiss.

"I'd love to."

We went downstairs hand in hand and saw Sonny in the kitchen. But he wasn't alone.

Brook was on his lap, and they were just staring into each others eyes. Sonny had his hands on Brook's ass, and Brook had his arms around the older boys neck.

"What's going on here?" I smirked. They both turned to face us.

"I think the real question is what's going on there." Brook laughed, referring to us holding hands.

I shook my head, smiling as Andy asked Sonny to come with us. We went up to my room this time.

"So, I'm just gonna come right out and say it. Me and Rye are in love. You obviously have a crush on Rye. Rye likes you. And I still like you. Do you like me?"

Sonny looked at Andy and nodded sheepishly.

"Great." Andy grinned. "Well, will you be our boyfriend?"

"You mean like a polygamous relationship, right?" Sonny asked.

I nodded. "Yep, so will you?"

He smiled, kissing both me and Andy. "Of course. One other thing though..."

"What?"

"I have a crush on Brook as well. Maybe he could be in the relationship with us?"

Me and Andy looked at each other.

"Well, I've never thought about Brook like that before."

"Neither." I lied. The truth was, I had a crush on Brook at one point.

It was when we first moved into the new house. Me and Brook were in the cinema room setting up the seating area. I turned around and saw that Brook had taken off his shirt. It was normal for us boys to do that, but for some reason it turned me on. I already knew I was gay at that point, but I didn't think I was gay for Brook.

"Like what you see?" He smirked, snapping me out of my thoughts. I blushed and looked down.

"No." I mumbled.

"Tell that to Little Beaumont." He chuckled, referring to my boner. I just blushed harder. He walked up to me, placing a hand on my cheek.

"Hey, it's okay to be into guys. I'm actually bisexual myself." He admitted.

"How do you know I'm into guys?" I asked.

"I don't think straight guys get hard from seeing their mates shirtless." He laughed. I laughed along, glad that Brook knew.

I looked up and saw his eyes flicker to my lips. Mine did the same, and before I knew it, I had him pressed against the wall, kissing roughly. My lips went to his neck, making him moan. I started to grind against him, us both letting out loud moans.

We were both so caught up in the moment that we failed to hear the door open.

"What the fuck?!"

We pulled away to see a shocked, but calm, Jack stood in the doorway.

"It's not what it looks like." I rushed out, but he just laughed.

"It's fine. I'm not here to judge. Love is love. Who cares if you're gay?"

"Bi, actually." Brook corrected him.

"Whatever. You kids have fun." He smirked again, walking out the door.

I looked at Brook, and he was blushing.

"How about we never speak of this again?" I suggested.

"Probably for the best." He smiled slightly.

I pecked him on the lips, and we went back to doing what we were doing before.

"But, maybe we could spend some time with him. Try and find a spark!" Andy suggested.

I nodded. "Sure."

Sonny grinned. "Thank you!"

We all exchanged kisses, before Andy went to go find Brook. Me and Sonny decided to cuddle.

A/N
Hey guys. Time for a part three, haha.

Hope you enjoyed!

Bye guys Xx

RoadTrip boyxboy one shotsWhere stories live. Discover now