Critiques [CLOSED]

By xanabanana66x

9.1K 917 1.4K

CLOSED due to full Please go to Critiques 2 for a critique. More

WELCOME!
Rules/Guidelines
Payment
Warning PLEASE READ
Form
Critiques #1-100
#1 The Witches' Sacrifice
#2 Strange Love
#3 Coffee For The Heart
#4 The Mind Reader
#5 D.I.C.K
#6 Being Vanessa Jane
#7 Blissfully Ever After
#8 G.AM.E
#9 An Enchantment of Time
#10 Always the Bad Girl
#11 Heart Sound
#12 Legend Of The Wildfires
#13 Goin' Through The Motions
#14 poetry, courtesy of the late nights
#15 The Colloquy
#16 XALVANDOR
#17 Athena Wolfborn
CHANGE IN SYSTEM
#18 The Faerie Forest
#19 Day Walker
#20 Love Is Blind
#21 Little Steps
#22 Little Steps
NOTICE
#23 Dirty Little Secrets
#24 Athena Wolfborn
#25 The Wild Moon
#26 The Queen Of Loregams
#27 The Hidden
#28 The Queen Of Loregams
#29 If The World Were Magic
#30
#31 The Cure Of Darkness
#32 Queen Of Atlantis
#33 The Faerie Forest
#34 The Dead Remain Silent
#35 A New Hello
#36 How Can We Live Like This?
#37 Steps To Loving A Killer
#38 Restless Thoughts
#39 Ignorance Is A Bliss
#40 Kidnapped Besties
#41 Willing Her To Love Me
#42 Sweet Vengeance
TAG FEST!
#43 Intrigued By Chocolate
#44 His Majesty's Ballerina
#45 Taken By A Bear
#46 Happy Everly After
#47 About That Sunday
#48 The Faerie Forest
#49 Belladonna
#50 Hunter's Shadow
#51 Alpha
#52 The Art Of Retribution
#53 Demonic
#54 While Her Lips Are Still Red
#55 The Tangled Princess
#56 Hunter's Shadow
#57 No Heartbeat, No Breathing
#58 The Tangled Princess
#59 Restless Thoughts
#60 Shadow And Lighting
#61 We Didn't Start The Fire
#62 Mafia Girls
#63 Hunter's Shadow
#64 The Tangled Princess
#65 Failures
#66 Hunter's Shadow
#67 Little Steps
#68 Beginning To End
#69 The Faerie Forest
#70 The Revenant
NOTICE
PLEASE READ
#71 Somewhere Inbetween
#72 The Battle Within An Angel
#73 Dawn Of A Tale
#74 Little Steps
#75 Hunter's Shadow
#76 The Forgotten Planet
#77 One Summer
#78 The Missing Princess
#79 Little Steps
#80 Little Steps
#81 Faceless
#82 Ten
#83 Hunter's Shadow
#84 Dangerous Billionaire
#85 The Tangled Princess
#86 Elemorts
#87 Solipsistic Heartbreaker
#88 Perfect 10
#89 Dangerous Billionaire
#90 Those Angry Blonde Curls
#91 Phobia
#92 The Crazy Side Of Love
#93 Forget Me
#94 Elemorts
#95 Henry's Paradise
#96 TCAO - The Bewitching Hour
#97 Instant Disconnection
#98 Pinewood Academy
#99 Weekend Getaway
#100 Perfect 10
Critiques #101-200
#101 15 Carats
#102 The Wolf And The Raven
#103 The Undesirables
#104 Hunter's Shadow
#105 The Shoes Left Behind
#106 Garden Of Flowers
#107 The Depths Of My Heart
#108 Tales Of Magic: A Sorceress' Return
#109 Dangerous Billionaire
#110 TheFallenAngels
#111 The Demon In Disguise
#112 Pandora High
#113 Elemorts
#114 Working Woman
#115 Judgement
#116 Enemies Forever
#117 SOCIETY
#118 Future Virgin
#119 Wielders: Protectors Of The Realms
#120 Kiss Or Kill
#121 His Girl
#122 Hunter's Shadow
#123 A Tale Of Blood & Bone
#124 Killer Queen: A Disasterpiece
#125 The Bad Boy's Reason
#126 The Novice Detectives Of Morgan Valley
#127 Alike
#128 The Witching Hour
#129 What We Left Behind
#130 Starseeds: The Broken-Winged
#131 Kidnapped By The King
#132 Undying
#133 That Of A Nostalgic Future
#134 Accidental Addiction
#135 Hunter's Shadow
#136 Sands And Sparrow
#137 Fight For Her
#138 Where We Find The World
#139 Actions Speak Louder Than Words
Announcement
#140 Blade Of Mercy
Announcement #2
#141 Don't Flirt With Me! I'm A Reformed Manwhore
#142 The Girl From Biringan - Arc 1: Intertwined Stars
#143 Infection
#144 Soulful Whispers
#145 A Hint Of Love
#146 The Moon Is Our Sun
#147 Juliet And Juliet
#148 Thief Of Stolen Hearts
#149 Aftertaste
#150 The Swirls | War of The Witches
#151 My Best Friend's Lover
#152 A Dangerous Woman
#153 When The Lights Go Out
#154 New And Badass
#155 Falling For The Gang Leader
#156 Seven Dates A Weekend
#158 It Had To Be You
#159 It Had To Be You
#160 Trace
#161 Every Second Counts... The Surprise Is Yet To Come This New
#162 It Had To Be You
#163 Always Never
#164 Where Worlds Collide
#165 Not The Fairest
#166 The Book Of Trials
#167 New And Badass
#168 Winning Her Heart
#169 The Book Of Trials
#170 Poems About Life
#171 Kids Playing Soldiers
#172 Just Dreaming
#173 Greaser Queen
#174 Crystal Blue
#175 Chaotic Nights
#176 Life's Seasons: A Poetry Collection
#177 His Love
#178 A Tale Of Two Brothers
#179 Lover: A Book Of Heartbreaks
#180 411
#181 Bad Atttractions
#182 Agent 10
#183 Floating Stars
#184 Lover: A Book Of Heartbreaks
ANNOUNCEMENT
CLOSED

#157 The Penderghast Prophecy

15 2 1
By xanabanana66x

The Penderghast Prophecy by @Pushppa177

Numbers spelled out completely look more formal.

There were places where you needed better word choices, and where the phrasing was a little off but I commented some recommendations. Apart from that, a good start.

Dialogue not formatted right. Use this as an example:

"I'm going to take nap," said Linda. Her lips split into a huge yawn. "Don't text me until I wake."

I found colloquial language just spoiled the mood. Saffron can still be witty and funny but you don't have to bring it right up to the reader's face.

Tense jumps! Keep the whole thing in past.

Too many ellipses I found (they should only be 3 dots anyway.)

Try to adhere to the rules of basic grammar as much as you can, unless you absolutely have a reason not to.

Comma splices can be fixed with a full stop or semi colon.

Commas before names.

It's/its

Overall, I found the plot weirdly intriguing. I can tell this is going to be a great fantasy. Just work on grammar and characterisation a little more.

Remember that this is a critique, NOT a criticism. Please spread the word!

If you would like a critique, please read the guidelines, fill out the form, and complete the payment, all which can be found at the beginning of this book. :)

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

171K 3.9K 63
imagines as taylor swift as your mom and travis kelce as your dad
107K 1.4K 51
𝐈𝐭𝐬 𝐭𝐑𝐞 𝐟𝐒𝐫𝐬𝐭 𝐝𝐚𝐲 π›πšπœπ€ 𝐭𝐨 𝐬𝐜𝐑𝐨𝐨π₯ , π€πšπ₯𝐒𝐲𝐚𝐑 𝐒𝐬 𝐧𝐨𝐰 𝐒𝐧 𝟏𝟎𝐭𝐑 𝐠𝐫𝐚𝐝𝐞, 𝐰𝐑𝐒π₯𝐞 𝐬𝐑𝐞𝐬 𝐭𝐑𝐞𝐫𝐞 𝐬𝐑...
263K 8.1K 186
What if a PokΓ©mon Trainer found herself in the world of One Piece? What if she found herself with the Strawhat Pirates? What if she finds herself get...
82.8K 2.1K 31
A little AU where Lucifer and Alastor secretly loves eachother and doesn't tell anyone about it, and also Alastor has a secret identity no one else k...