Alright. You asked and I deliver. Here's an extra chapter for all you thirsty people
I was too when I wrote this tho lol not judging 😌
Hiii. New chapter :) there'll also be one tomorrow 😌 so 4 chapters total this week yay!
I'm seeing giant rooks with my girl Tschelzii this weekend and I can't wait ♥️🥹
Anyways, let's just dive in! Not much to say except y'all reaaaally loving these chapters haha, thank you for so many likes in one day!! Means the world and y'all earned an extra surprise chapter 😌♥️
Please enjoy, would love to hear your thoughts, see you tomorrow ♥️ don't forget to like so I know you've all been able to read this before tomorrow!
Word count: 4784
~~
As they again chose mostly dares, there were quite some spicy ones too. Josh was still wondering how he ever got into that situation, Lucas had stayed with Josh well past the third round, Tyler was hoping for the spiciest dares, and Steve was all just enjoying it.
"Alright, J. Here's your next dare", Steve said. "...oh I don't know who's gonna like this one more, either Josh or Ty", Steve said. "Oh! That's promising. Spill, c'mon", Tyler grinned as he sat up. "Oh God", Josh mumbled. He didn't know how many more spicy dares he could handle before he was gonna explode - in more ways than one.
"Sit on a chair, then let the person on your right tie your hands behind your back and kiss every part of your bare torso", Steve read aloud. Tyler gasped. "Oh you're absolutely right I'm gonna like this", he said. "I'll go get a chair", Steve chuckled as he got up and walked inside.
Josh wondered if he was really gonna do this, and if it was wise doing so, but he had asked the guys not to ask him if he was okay with a dare anymore; so they didn't. Josh hated that he had said so; he could've prevented a lot of dares. But also... did he really want to prevent them? Honestly, not at all. Not even a little. He wanted to make stupid decisions and have the best night of his life and maybe have a few regrets tomorrow but he was alive, he was living, he was doing things he never thought he would, with Steve, Lucas, with Tyler, and right now they felt like the best goddamn things in the world. Josh wanted these things just as much as the other guys; he just wasn't gonna admit it as easily as they did.
"Alright J, your turn to shine", Lucas said as Steve came back with the chair and Lucas gently pushed Josh up so he would actually get up, as he definitely had trouble being the one to initiate any of the dares. Tyler came to the rescue; he jumped up, pulling Josh up to his feet as he did so. "Have a seat", Tyler hummed with a soft grin, and Josh blushed as he did as he was told. "Here you go", Lucas handed Tyler the scarf from his blindfolded dare earlier. Tyler grabbed it, but he put it on Josh's lap. "Arms up, love", Tyler said as he crouched down in front of him and he grabbed the hem of Josh's shirt. "...do I have to- to take it off?" Josh asked as he hesitantly lifted his arms a little bit. "Oh yeah baby, you got no other choice", Tyler said as he pushed Josh's arms up a bit higher before Josh lifted them up himself, and Tyler pulled his shirt up and off of him.
When Tyler tossed it to the couch where they were sitting a minute earlier and he looked back at Josh, he saw him avert his gaze and Tyler's eyes landed on some faint lines on Josh's side. For a moment, Tyler panicked; had he made Josh take his shirt off without him being okay with that? But Josh promised to tell them if he didn't want to do something... Lucas even told him the safe word. He had to trust that Josh would be honest with them. Maybe Josh had been hesitating, but Tyler couldn't have pushed him too far.
Tyler gently trailed his fingertips over the lines on Josh's side, giving his skin goosebumps. He looked up to see if Josh looked at him and he caught his gaze; he smiled softly at him. "You look hot", he said. Josh blushed as he let out a soft laugh and he rolled his eyes a little bit. "So do you", Josh replied. Tyler laughed softly at that. He moved to kiss Josh's cheek, his lips lingering for a moment; Tyler needed to know it was about the scars, that they weren't scaring Tyler off. Josh closed his eyes softly as he felt the kiss on his cheek; he loved feeling Tyler's love. It was the most special to Josh.
"Now let me tie you up", Tyler grinned as he got up and he grabbed the scarf. He walked around Josh to tie his wrists behind him, and Josh's chest was beating heavily. He began to tie them, making sure they were secure but not too tight so it would hurt Josh. "Is this okay?" Tyler asked. "A little-", Josh started, and Tyler was about to loosen them, when he actually heard what josh said. "-tighter."
Tyler froze for a second, before he regained himself. "Uh... Yeah, sure, uhm... you say stop", he said as he tightened the fabric around Josh's wrist carefully, gently, going tighter and tighter and how the hell was Josh not saying stop?
"Stop", Josh then said. Tyler did, right away. "Are- are you sure that's not too tight?" He asked, seeing the scarf slightly digging into Josh's skin. "S'fine, thank you", Josh replied. Tyler was about to lose his mind. He always thought Josh was so sweet, so careful, so adorable, so innocent; how did he get so kinky? Surely that wasn't a regular thing for Josh... He had been struggling when they started this game 'cause he was so nervous about those dares. Even answering questions even slightly related to sex were making him blush and stutter and shift nervously. Now Josh wanted him to tie him up so tightly that the fabric was already digging into his skin. Tyler didn't know what the fuck happened, if Josh was always like that, or if he just found out that he was into that, but one thing he surely did know; Tyler was definitely enjoying it.
"That's surely nice and tight", Tyler said, slightly in disbelief still, as he gently tugged at the tie around Josh's wrists. He couldn't even fit a finger between Josh's wrist and the fabric.
Tyler walked around Josh again to the other side, and he crouched in front of Josh once more. He pushed Josh's legs apart, and it made Josh's breath hitch as he did so. Tyler got in between them, then he smirked up at Josh, before he leaned closer and he did as the dare said, plus he gave it a little bit of his own too; he didn't just kiss, but he licked and sucked the skin too. Josh had closed his eyes, first having his head down, but then he changed it to letting it fall back as he tried to breathe steadily. He was definitely failing as his breath was hitching all over the place by what Tyler was doing to his torso; he had goosebumps all over, he felt Tyler's hands grip his hips, he felt like he was on cloud nine.
Josh was dreaming; there was no other way to explain this. He was dreaming, he was imagining this, and he was so horny and head over heels in love with Tyler that he was just coming up with these things in his head. That was the only explanation Josh could give himself for these things that were happening.
Suddenly, after quite a while - but not quite long enough for Josh - Tyler's contact with Josh's skin disappeared, and Josh couldn't stop the soft whine slipping from his lips. He could hear Tyler's pants, and Josh couldn't bring himself to open his eyes or look at him.
"Sorry", Tyler then spoke, clearing his throat. "...got carried away a little bit", he said. Only then, Josh opened his eyes and he looked down, his jaw slightly dropping as he saw three hickeys in different spots on his torso. Oh.
"Oh", Josh softly said.
"...sorry", Tyler said again. "I- n-no s'fine, it- it's fine", Josh said, the blush appearing on his lips again. "It's... nice", Josh said. It made Tyler smile softly. He didn't move or say anything right away, they just sat there for a moment. "...I'll untie you now", Tyler said. "Don't have to", Josh muttered, then he blushed deeper. "...pretend I didn't say that", he said, when he realized he'd said it out loud. Tyler laughed softly. "Okay", he said as he got up and he ruffled Josh's hair a little, then he pressed a kiss on top of his head. He untied Josh's wrists, seeing the red lines around his wrists and he gently caressed them with his thumb for a moment. "Was it really not too tight?" He asked, a little worried. "No it was fine, really", Josh said, only then retrieving his wrists and he saw the red marks. he blushed a little. "Uhm..." he trailed. "I- I know you guys didn't put your shirts back on but... I am", Josh blushed. "Of course love", Tyler said as he grabbed it for Josh, then he opened it so Josh only needed to put his arms up and Tyler slid it right over his head and arms. "Thanks", Josh blushed.
"Now let's see what my dare's gonna be", Tyler grinned as he grabbed Josh's hand and he pulled him up from the chair. Lucas had now moved back to the couch with Steve, where Lucas was laying against Steve while Steve had his arm around Lucas. "You two look hot together", Lucas commented. "'Course, there's no way I couldn't with Josh next to me", Tyler said as they sat back down. "Oh don't say that", Josh said with a soft laugh. "It's really not because of me." Tyler shrugged. "I think it is."
"Alright, Ty, your next dare: lick chocolate sauce or whip cream off the chest of the person on your right", Steve read aloud. "Man, what's up with me and licking chests today", he laughed. "Be right back. Luke, shirt off", he said. "Here I thought I was the only one lucky enough not to have to take my shirt off tonight", Lucas chuckled as he took his shirt off, laying down on the couch with his head in Steve's lap. Tyler returned with whip cream. "No one can avoid taking their shirt off at least once tonight, it seems", he grinned. He piped the whip cream on Lucas' skin, then he licked it all off. "That sure was a tasty dare", Tyler chuckled, and Lucas let out a laugh. "Get your butt back over there", he chuckled as he sat back up and he, like Josh, did put his shirt back on.
"Luke, truth or dare?" "Dare", Lucas replied. "Hmmm... Ah. Spin a bottle, whoever it lands on, you must kiss", Steve said. "Huh. Let's see who I get to kiss", Lucas said as he put a bottle on its side, then he spinned it. "That's very obviously pointing at Josh", Tyler said. "Don't think you and him kissed yet right?", Steve said. "Nope. It says kiss, right? Not make out?" Lucas asked. "Yeah, it says kiss. So, no tongue", Steve replied.
Lucas was glad about that. Not that he thought that Josh wasn't worthy of being made out with; he just felt that while he didn't really see an issue with Josh making out with Tyler or Steve, he thought that he and Josh shouldn't cross that line. They had a comfortable type of relationship that a kiss wouldn't change, but a make out session potentially could. Because of that, he was happy it was just a kiss. He didn't want to risk that it might change anything between them.
He got up and walked to Josh. He just went for it; he connected their lips, sharing a soft kiss with Josh, but he didn't let it last too long and it didn't get nearly as steamy as the kisses Josh had shared with Tyler and Steve. "Done", Lucas said after they'd pulled back. Josh smiled softly at Lucas, who returned it; it felt like Josh was glad it didn't go further than what it did either. He wasn't very blushy or nervous to look at Lucas; it was still easy, and Lucas knew that they had done the right thing.
"Steve, truth or dare?" Tyler hummed as Lucas made his way back to his seat. "Dare", Steve replied. "Surprise surprise", Lucas chuckled. "Ahh I'm pretty sure you and Ty did this one during another truth or dare too! Do push-ups above someone and kiss them in between", Lucas read the sentence. "So we're gonna randomize", Lucas said. "Why not just spin the bottle instead?" Tyler asked. "Oh, good idea, let's do that", Lucas replied, and he spun the bottle.
"...okay that's very obviously Josh again", Tyler said. "Are you jealous?" Lucas hummed. "Yes", Tyler replied bluntly. "Well J, you're the victim again", Steve said as he got up and he grabbed Josh's hand, pulling him up from the couch. "Lay down on your back", he said. Josh's wondered if he'd have to go to the hospital because of his irregular heartbeat caused by this night. He lowered himself down to the ground so he was sitting first, before he got on his back and Steve got on his knees next to him. "Pretty sure I did this with Tyler when Josh was here too", Steve said. "Ohh right! I think so too", Tyler said. "Yeah I- you did", Josh nodded with a blush. He could remember that very clearly.
"Well now I get to do it with you", Steve said. He got himself into position right above Josh, whose heart was pounding in his chest as Steve got above him. "How many push ups do I need to do, by the way?" Steve asked. "I don't know, twenty?" Lucas suggested. "Twenty?!" Tyler said. "Oh you are jealous", Lucas said. "Shut up", Tyler said. "Fine, do twenty", he said as he lit a cigarette. Josh's eyes looked in Tyler's direction, and Tyler looked back at him before he averted his gaze. Josh did so too, turning his head to look at Steve again, and he blushed softly.
"Alright, twenty it is", Steve said as he started the push ups, kissing Josh in-between each one. Steve being extremely strong and easily being able to hold his own weight, he sometimes stayed down longer as they shared a longer kiss, and it was driving Tyler nuts. Did he think it was absolutely hot? Hell yeah, and he loved watching it. But did he wish he was in Steve's place? Yes, yes he did. He wasn't even gonna deny it anymore. He still blamed the alcohol, but he wasn't gonna deny it. He was extremely turned on, extremely frustrated that he couldn't get off, and as if he wasn't turned on enough, he craved more, and while he loved doing dares with Steve and Lucas; doing so with Josh was new, and so much more exciting than he had expected. He wanted all of his dares to be with Josh, and he loved that Steve and Lucas were there to watch them do each one.
The last kiss took the longest, and Tyler had to force every inch of his body to not say knock it off. He took another deep drag from his cigarette, blowing out the smoke steadily. When he saw Josh reach up for one last kiss, Tyler really thought he was gonna lose his mind.
But he couldn't blame Josh. Steve was hot, he was extremely hot; he knew what Josh was feeling. He'd felt it himself plenty of times, so it wasn't weird. And Josh was drunk too; it wasn't like he was suddenly gonna stay in Steve's room with him instead of Tyler every time now.
...right? Tyler then realized they hadn't even really talked about who was gonna sleep where, and he felt a slight panic in his chest. He had assumed that, like last time, Josh was gonna sleep in the same room as he was. But they didn't say it aloud. What if Steve and Josh wanted to do so instead after this? Tyler took another long drag from his cigarette.
Josh and Steve got back up to their feet and Josh sat down next to Tyler again, who followed Josh with his eyes, but suddenly he felt like his arms were limb and he couldn't reach out to Josh like he had wanted to do. He cleared his throat as he took another drag from his cigarette.
"Can I go to the bathroom real quick? I'll be right back", Josh said. "Of course! We'll wait for you", Lucas said. "Thanks", Josh smiled as he got up and he disappeared inside.
"Okay Ty, talk", Lucas said. "What?" Tyler asked. "You're jealous. Of Steve! Why are you jealous of Steve?" Lucas asked. "I'm not", Tyler said. "Sure. You literally just said you are", Lucas replied. "C'mon, you love Steve. You can't be jealous of him", Lucas said. "Ty, I'm just completing my dares. That's all", Steve said. "You're sure having a lot of fun doing so", Tyler said. "Aren't we all?" Steve asked.
"...Yeah, you're right", Tyler then said. He let out a sigh as he rubbed his forehead. "Sorry." "Nah, don't be", Steve said. "I'm not touching or kissing Josh unless the dare says so. Unlike you", Steve chuckled as he got up to sit down next to Tyler, who blushed just slightly. He wrapped his arm around Tyler. "Are you into him?" Tyler asked. "No, I'm not", Steve said. "He's great, he's sweet, he's hot; but no, we're just having fun playing this game", Steve said. "Are you? Into him?" Steve asked. Tyler shook his head. "No, no just... extremely horny and frustrated because of it and Josh's... well, he's really good at turning a guy on", Tyler chuckled. "It's the alcohol, it's making me jealous of something I really don't need to be jealous of", Tyler sighed softly.
"Just think he's... he's hot", he said with a soft laugh. "He's... unfamiliar, it's fun to figure him out, what he's into, to see how he responds... it's new, I guess that's what's making me like this", Tyler said.
"Hey, if Josh is down and willing to have fun the way you want to do with him, by all means, go ahead. You don't have to be jealous of me, okay? I'm just doing my dares and that's it", Steve said as he gave Tyler a tight hug. "Yeah, thanks", Tyler smiled. "Wouldn't do anything Josh doesn't want, or use him for anything... you know that", Tyler said. "'Course we do baby, we're not worried about that", Lucas smiled. "Just don't want to see tension between you and Steve for something that's really not needed. Glad you talked about it", he said. "Me too", Tyler smiled, then he kissed Steve's cheek. "Love you baby", he said. "Love you loads Ty, always", Steve replied. He stole a drag from Tyler's cigarette, before he kissed his temple and he got back to his spot.
Josh then came back. "Hi, sorry", he blushed as he sat down next to Tyler again. "Don't be, you're good", Lucas smiled. "It's your turn for a dare", Tyler reminded him. "...shit", Josh said. "Right", he said with a soft laugh, and it made the rest laugh too. "Let's see", Steve said. "...send a nude pic to your ex? Let's not to that", He cringed at the dare. "Oh please no", Josh muttered. "We're skipping that. Don't worry", Tyler said, and Josh let out a soft relieved sigh. "Thank you", he said.
"Sit on the lap of the person on your right - with no clothes on - and suck on their fingers... Let's scrap the no clothes part and do it that way", Steve said. "So, just sit on Tyler's lap and suck on his fingers."
"Huh. Guess you two are gonna be truth or dare partners 'cause most of these last dares have been of you two", Lucas said. "I'm not complaining", Tyler said, and Josh blushed as he moved a little bit, not really sure how to go about it, but then Tyler reached out and he guided him to his lap. Josh's heart was racing as much as ever, and Tyler's arm wrapped around him. Their faces were fairly close to each other's, their eyes locked; Josh averted his gaze but they found their way back to Tyler's eyes. Tyler lifted his hand up, touching Josh's lips, and Josh opened his mouth slightly. Tyler then pushed his index and middle finger between Josh's lips into his mouth, and Josh looked down as he closed his lips around them, gently sucking.
Tyler was breathing steadily, watching Josh closely, waiting for Josh to look back at him. Then, their eyes met; Josh still sucking on Tyler's fingers as they looked at each other, and Tyler breathed in sharply. "Fucking hell, J", he breathed. "You're fucking killing me."
Josh gently grabbed Tyler's wrist with his hands, pulling back. "You- you've been doing that to me all night", he blushed, and the words were about to drive Tyler crazy. He lightly shook his head in disbelief at the way Josh was right now, and he shoved his fingers back into his mouth, with Josh immediately sucking on them again. Holy fucking hell, was everything that was going to Tyler's mind in that moment.
"I think that completes the dare", Steve chuckled. "I pick truth", Tyler replied. "Truth? You are picking truth? Since when?" Lucas asked. "Since Josh's in my lap and I don't wanna change that", Tyler replied. "Give me a truth."
Josh blushed, then he tilted his head a little to slightly let it rest against Tyler's. His hand was still gently around Tyler's wrist, and Tyler's fingers were still in his mouth.
"Fine", Lucas chuckled. "Here it goes. Do you prefer to be on top or on the bottom? So, it's not asking whether you're a top or bottom, just in which position you prefer to be", Lucas read. "Oh man", Tyler said. "I don't know. I thought on top... But uh..." he trailed; his mind was wandering. "being on the bottom can be great too", he said. "I guess... I'll still go with being on top", he said. "They sure both have their pros and cons. Hard question", Lucas said. "Now, I'll choose dare."
"Oh, it's between you and me", Steve said as he hit the button on his phone. "Guess today's the day of hickeys. The dare is: You and the person on your right have to give each other a hickey, in a spot of their choosing. Then make out for one minute", Steve read. "Oh man, I'm really going back to my boyfriend's with hickeys made by another man", Lucas chuckled. "I'm choosing somewhere around my collarbone I think", he said. "Luckily Rich's fine with this", Steve chuckled. "You can do my neck", he said. "Alright, I'll go first", Lucas smiled. Tyler's attention was now on Steve and Lucas giving each other hickeys - though not fully, as Josh still had his fingers in his mouth and his dick was hard - he saw Steve's eyes slipping close as Lucas gave him the hickey and Tyler grinned softly. He knew Steve was very much enjoying that.
"Good enough?" Lucas asked Josh and Tyler. "Definitely nicely visible. I approve that one", Tyler replied. "Now Steve."
Lucas pulled the collar of his shirt down to make room, then Steve sucked a hickey on to Lucas' collarbone. He had to put in a little more work as Lucas' skin was dark, and therefore the hickey was a little later visible than on white skin, but it didn't take much longer or much more to also be visible well. Lucas then connected his lips to Steve's and they made out for about two minutes instead of one. "Done and done", Steve said. "I'll go with truth for a change too", Steve said.
"Oh kind of a lame question, but let's just do it", Lucas said after he had hit the question button. "If you're single do you feel jealous of your friends in a relationship?" Lucas read. "Not at all", Steve said. "I'm beyond happy for them, definitely not jealous."
"Yeah that was a really easy one", Tyler said. "I won't mind doing another one", Steve said. "Alright, here's another one. When did you masturbate for the last time?" Lucas chuckled. Steve let out a laugh. "The night before you guys visited, so... two days ago", he said. "Mhm, expected that", Lucas chuckled. "Josh's turn", he said.
"Dare, right?" Tyler said. Josh blushed, then he nodded. Tyler's fingers were very much still in Josh's mouth, and he was still sucking. Lucas let out a laugh as he shook his head. Tyler had him wrapped around his finger. "Alright. You have to keep your hand on the very inner thigh of the person next to you for the next round", Lucas read aloud. "Since you're in Tyler's lap already, might as well do that for Ty too", Lucas said.
"Huh. Don't mind that", Tyler said, retrieving his fingers from Josh, then Josh moved off of Tyler's lap. He grabbed Josh's hand and he placed it on his bare thigh; like the dare said, his very inner thigh.
Josh tried to steady his breaths, but he was struggling. His hand felt like it was burning on Tyler's thigh, so close to his crotch, his mind was cloudy. "You good?" Tyler asked. "I don't know, feel like I'm dreaming half the time", Josh said with a soft chuckle. "Couldn't tell you the difference between reality and dreaming right now." "Kind of same, I've drank so much", Tyler said with a laugh as he rubbed his forehead. "But I'm pretty sure this is not a dream, but it's reality", he added.
"Guess we won't know for sure 'til we wake up", Josh said. "Guess not", Tyler replied. He rested his hand on Josh's - the one on his thigh - and he gently squeezed, so Josh did too. He breathed in deeply, then out softly, looking at his hand on Tyler's thigh. He didn't know how he was gonna feel the next day if this turned out to be reality.
"Your tattoos are gorgeous, by the way", Tyler said, his hand moving to gently trace the lines on Josh's arm, the colors, the shapes. "Finally get to have a good look at them", he smiled. "You chose a great tattoo artist." "Thanks", Josh blushed. "Was nervous to get them done but I'm really happy with them. Wondering what to get next", he said. "You wanna get more?" Tyler asked as he looked up into his eyes. Josh nodded. "You think I shouldn't?" He asked. "No, I think you should", Tyler replied. "They look amazing on you. I think you definitely should get more", he said. "...though, I'd say none on your face. Nothing against face tattoos... just think your face is pretty as-is", he said. That made Josh blush. "Wasn't planning on getting any there", he said. "Good", Tyler smiled.
"I choose truth, by the way", Tyler then said. "'Course you do", Lucas chuckled. "Have you ever fantasized about the person in front of you?" Lucas chuckled. Tyler was facing Josh more than anyone else. "You mean Josh?" Tyler asked. "Yep", Lucas decided. "Huh. Didn't before. Do now", Tyler chuckled. That made Josh blush as he looked away. He still couldn't handle those sexual comments by Tyler no matter how drunk he was.
Tyler was gonna be the death of him.
~~
And that still wasn't the end of it. 😌
I'd loooove to hear your thoughts. I've enjoyed writing these chapters and the next ones so much, I hope you enjoy reading them just as much ♥️
Sexually frustrated Josh and ty can't stop enjoying each other lol
Can't wait to hear your thoughts ♥️ I'll be back with a chapter tomorrow. Much love ♥️
Another great song from the new album - Nobody Likes Hospitals by Giant Rooks ✨