Adopted by Heathers Cast

By chaoticgeek

65.5K 2.3K 3.9K

Catlynn Reeve is no stranger to abuse. Her father and older brother have abused her since the day she was bor... More

Intro
Aw Look, Catlynn's Gonna Whine
So I'll Build A Dream That I Can Live In
Somebody Hug Me, Somebody Fix Me!
The Tiniest Lifeboat...
...Full of People I Know
It's Just You And Me, And The Castmates Who Love You
This Could Be Beautiful
I Can't Promise No More Hospitals
She Was Sweet, She Said That I Was Smart
You're Welcome
Catlynn, Sure You're Scared, I've Been There
No One Sees The Me Inside Of Me
Wanna Fight For Me?
Dreadful Etiquette, I Know
We Always Knew You Were a Winner
Who Knew I Had This Thirst?
If She Had Your Shot
You Need The Strength To Pretend It's No Big Deal
Honey, Whatcha Waiting For?
At The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee...
Guilt, Regret, Anxiety, Fears We Dare Not Name
You're The One I Choose
Let Us Be Thirteen
Storms Are Approaching, There's Nowhere to Hide
Catlynn, I'm So Sorry...
Why Do I Cry Myself To Sleep?
This Could Be Our Final Chance
Greetings and Salutations
Think, Long and Hard
Are We On For Movie Night?
I've Been Thinking, Praying, Reading Some Magazines
Are There Any Happy Endings?
It's Time For Big Fun
Holy Crap! This Is Awesome!
So Let The Speakers Blow
Catlynn's Chandler Nightmare
Maybe Prom Night, Maybe Dancing
What's Your Damage?
Fine, We're Damaged, Really Damaged
That Freak's Not Your Friend, I Can Tell In The End
Time For You To Prove You're Not A Loser Anymore
Hold Me Tighter, Even Closer
They Made You Cry, But That Will End Tonight
Whine, Whine, Whine All Night
But We Let Go, Take A Deep Breath
We Can Start and Finish Wars
Life Is Random and Unfair
Catlynn, What's Going On?
Brand New Sheriff's Come To Town
People Hurt Us...
Hey, Mr. No-Name-Kid
Don't You Want A Life With Me?
Hope You'll Miss Me, Wish You'd Kiss Me
You Heard The Man, It's Time To Rage!
Got No Time To Talk
My Best Friend Seemed To Have It All Together
My Friend, You Will Be Missed
The Folks Are Gone, It's Time For Big Fun!
I Might Be Beautiful
It's My Favorite Moment Of The Bee
Are We Going To Have A Problem?
But Just Underneath Was A Terrified Girl...
Let's Be Normal, See Bad Movies
Blame It On Your Daddily and Mammily
When Are You Returning? I Know We Agreed
Chaos is What Killed The Dinosaurs, Darling
How I Wish You Were Home...
It's Possible, Anything's Possible
Oh, The Thinks You Can Think!
Dear Mom and Dad, I'm Thinking of You...
I Saved A Chair For My Mom...
Are You A Heather? No, I'm A Catlynn
I'm Hugging My Knees
I'm Alone in the Universe
I'll Be Home With You
Solla Sollew...
My Future's In Your Hands
I Am Damaged
Shut Up, Violet!
My Own Planets and Stars Are Glowing
I'm A Thinker, And I Think Thinks!
Give Me Some Hope Here
We're The Asteroid That's Overdue
My Problems Were Myriad, I Just Started My Period
Why Rehash A Nasty Crash?
One True Friend In The Universe
Set Your Sights, I Am On A Mission!
Regrets and Goodnight
Mama, Mama, Mama!
I'm Drifting Through Space And Cannot Steer!
I'm Going Home, And That, Sir, Is That!
Stick Around Here, Make Things Better
Baking Cookies, Eating Paste
Look Who's With Her, Oh My God
Joy Never Comes For Free
Try Not To Think, Try To Behave
My Philosophy Is Simply, Things Could Be Worse!
Don't Worry, I'm Not Nervous
I Think Dad Is Angry, Ma
...And I Do Not Know What To Do
But We Are Equals, Ma, Where Neither Condescends!
I'd Rather Have Christmas Than War, Wouldn't You?
In These Lights, Can You Feel Our Pain?
Tell Yourself How Lucky You Are
Why Do They Hate Me? Why Don't I Fight Back?
Brains In My Head and Feet In My Shoes
And Will You Succeed? You Will, Yes Indeed!
Our Perfect Little Girl...
Save Our Dust, Sir!
Breaking The Peace, Creating A Fuss
You're On Your Own, You Know What You Know
Think And Wonder And Dream
Welcome to My School, This Ain't No High School
There's A Faraway Land So The Stories All Tell
Catlynn's Trying To Keep Him Out Now...
...Too Late! He Got In
We Were Kind Before, We Can Be Kind Once More
Here Comes The Cootie Squad!
I Was Meant To Be Yours
And You Feel Almost Normal...
Yo Girl, Keep It Together
You Were The Perfect Child
Wake From This Coma
And In This Case I Say The Shoe Fits
We Have Rights! That's Why We Complain
Mama, I Made A Friend
You Were Good But Not Good Enough
Doesn't Anyone Else Care About The Rules?
And I'll Sing You A Lullaby...
You Are The Only Thing That's Right About This Broken World
If I Go To Washington, Will I Be On My Own?
Life is Pandemonium!
I Try Not To Disappoint
Mama, I Love You
Woe is Me
Troubles There Are Few
That's The Reason We Despair
Please Let Me Say It One Time Louder
You're Planning Your Future, Catlynn McLemore
Who Will Be My Chaperone?
I'll Make It Happen, And Not As Previously Reckoned...
...Cause I Will Not Come In Second!
Kids Are Mean, Kids'll Talk
All For You
Your Love's Too Good To Lose
Not One Person Is Listening
When The News Is All Bad
I Believe In Ethical Conduct
A Very Nice, Very Very Nice, Very Nice Beginning
I'd Trade My Life For Yours
But You Didn't React...
Tell Me What You're Learning
I Had Quietly Packed
Winner's Destination: Washington, D.C.
Could You Be Seen With Me And Still Act Proud?
You're Right, That Really Blows
Maybe We Won't Grow Up
My Letter To Catlynn
A Special Thank You

Act Like We're All Still Kids

1.2K 32 109
By chaoticgeek

Even though I've only known Elle, Katie, Barrett, Ryan, Alice, and Jessica for about a week, I loved them. They were my family. And the New World Stages was my home.

I was sitting on a couch in the theater, wearing my worn-out Converse, and playing on my phone. Out of the corner of my eye, I saw an envelope on the floor. I kneeled down, and opened the card that was in it.

"Hey, Ms. No-Name Kid, we have a scavenger hunt for you. Go to my dressing room." the card read.

Ryan. Ryan was the one who called me Ms. No-Name Kid. I ran to his dressing room and there was another card.

"Hey. Go to the place that took you to where you love the most." I knew exactly where that was. The brick wall outside of the theater. That's where Elle found me the first time. I ran out of the theater and found a card in the street.

"Go find the clothes you took to the hospital! Now!" the card read. I didn't know where those were, so I went back to Elle's dressing room and checked if they were there. They weren't. I checked Katie's dressing room, and there they were, in a old grocery bag. Taped to the bag was another card.

"Last clue! Go to where all the magic happens" I ran back into New World Stages and went on the stage.

"SURPRISE!" the cast screamed as I walked in.

"What is this?" I laughed. "My birthday's not for another month!" Elle hugged me, and said, "We just wanted to make you smile. You deserve it!" Elle picked me up and spun me around. I noticed that there were a few presents on the stage. I smiled like an idiot and Ryan said, "You have more coming for your birthday, kid."

"I...didn't need presents in the first place. Thank you." I said, hugging Ryan.

"Open your presents!" Katie said, smiling. At the last minute, Jessica yanked a flat box away and threw it to the side. "This is for last." I smiled, and opened a box. There was a card taped to the front of it. I opened the card up, and it said,

Sunshine,
You were, and are, the best thing to ever happen to us. I should be thanking Elle for finding you in the first place, but we wanted to thank you. We never thought that a random girl in the street, with beautiful auburn hair and big brown eyes, could be our world. But then came you. Never underestimate how great you are, Sunshine. If I went through the things you did, I would be terrified for my life. But we didn't know you were abused until Elle saw the bruises. I love you. This entire cast does. Never forget that, promise me?
Your big brother,
Ryan McCartan.

I hugged Ryan, then went to open his present. This really pretty pink dress fell out, along with a pair of black ballet flats. "Oh my God, thank you so much!" I cried. Ryan said, "You're welcome, kid. There's more."

In the envelope, there were 2 stickers. One had my name on it in pretty cursive, and the other had a sun with "Sunshine" printed in the middle. I guess Sunshine was my nickname now.

Alice and Barrett were fighting over who's present to give me next. While they weren't looking, I grabbed the nearest one. I opened the card attached to it.

Catlynn,
I don't know you as well as the others do, but you seem like the sweetest girl in the world. You have the most contagious smile, I want to see it more often. When we tell you how much we love you, believe it, ok?  You're so incredibly talented, and I can't wait to watch you grow.
Hope you like the gift.
Alice Lee

I hugged Alice and opened her gift. Inside was a set of notebooks, each with my first initial. "I really like these. Thank you."

"Ha-ha, my gift is better than yours!" Ryan said, and Alice slapped him.

"Shut up, both of you." I said, and reached over for Barrett's gift. Jessica slapped my hand away and handed me hers instead. Evan and Jon took that away and threw it backstage, and handed me theirs.

Cat,
We literally just met you the other day at the hospital, but you seem cool, and you like chocolate. Make sure to hide these from Alice and Elle.
From,
Evan Todd and Jon Eidson

In the box, there were 3 different boxes of chocolates. One was normal chocolate, one had almonds in it, and the third had 60 different truffles, all with different flavors.

On the top of the chocolate boxes, there was a paper that said, "Cat's Chocolate: Alice Don't Touch."

"Can I touch it?" Elle asked, and reached over. Evan grabbed it, and scribbled on the paper. Alice's name was crossed out and replaced with "Heathers Cast."

"Darn it." Elle said.

Jessica had come back with her gift in her hands. "Now that you opened Evan's pharmacy chocolate, here's my gift."

I ripped open the card, and it said,

Catlynn,
I know you've been through a lot, and I can't imagine how hard it is to have to deal with things like that. You're such a beautiful young woman. But when you smile, or laugh, it's so beautiful and precious, because it's rare to get moments like that with you. I hope what I got you will make you smile. We recorded it while you were getting your scan done. (Ryan, Alice, Evan, Jon, and I made their parts at the theater)
Love,
Jessica Keenan Wynn

I opened the small box, and a flash drive came out of it. Jessica pulled out her laptop and plugged the USB into it. A few minutes later, a video popped up. Jessica, Katie, and Elle were in a bathroom.

"Hi Sunshine, um, it's me. I love you so much, baby girl. Just try to stay positive." Elle said on the video. She looked down at her shoes, and said, "I hope you're doing okay in there. I miss you. See you when you wake up." Elle blew a kiss at the camera and it faded out. Jessica turned to me, and said, "Oh, we wanted to give this to you when you woke up from your scan, but I couldn't get it edited in time."

Katie came on next, and said, "I'm gonna keep this short. It's unbelievable how strong you're being right now. I admire that more than you could ever know. I look really stupid right now, giving a camera compliments in a hospital bathroom, but anything for you. Love you."

I smiled at the actual Katie, and then Jessica came on. She was walking with the camera.

"Hi. I have to go on stage pretty soon, so I'm recording this on the way there. Stay strong for me, okay? You're the best. See you soon."

Then Alice came on. She had her camera set up in Elle's dressing room.

"Hey, Catlynn. Don't tell Elle I'm trespassing." She giggled, and continued her speech. "I really hope you're okay. Elle texted me and told me what happened...just don't get scared, okay? We all love you and we're all here for you. See you after the show, I promise I'll be there."

Ryan was set up, holding a cup.

"Hey, squirt. I owe you a slushie soon, remind me.  I don't really know what else to say here...so see ya later, I guess?" Ryan turned off the camera, and Evan and Jon came on.

"Hey. You don't know us, really, but we've heard of you. You seem cool. Hope you like chocolate."

Then the video ended. I hugged Jessica and said, "Thank you, thank you, thank you!"

"You're welcome!" Jessica said.

"My turn!" Barrett said, and Katie started protesting. Barrett handed me 2 boxes and said, "This is from the entire cast, but we branded it as 'my' gift because I forgot to get you something. I didn't put a card, sorry."

I opened it up, and it was a brand-new iPhone 6, plus a laptop. "Oh my God, thank you so much!" I hugged Barrett, and went to open Katie's gift. There was a card attached to it as well.

Sunshine,
They made you cry, but that will end tonight. You are the only thing that's right about this broken world.
Sorry, it's from the show. Ryan should put that in his card. It's his line, after all! In all seriousness, thank you for being the amazing girl you are. I love you, Sunshine. You're smart, and pretty, and funny. Thanks for being you.
Love,
Katie Ladner

I tore open Katie's gift. Inside were some school supplies, some pencils, some pens, some notebooks, some highlighters, and a new phone case.

"Hope you like it!" Katie cried, and I hugged her.

"I love it!"

Elle moved over to me, and said, "Before this last gift, I wanted to say that you are the most beautiful girl ever, Sunshine. You are my sunshine, that's why it's your nickname. Go ahead, open it."

I tore open the card, which read,

Sunshine,
When I met you, you were broken. I didn't know how to help. But seeing how well you adjusted  and how happy you are here makes me happy too. You're my beautiful sunshine girl, always stay that way. I love when we play Go Fish together, and eat chocolate, and eat sushi late at night in my dressing room. Promise me you'll never change. You're amazing just the way you are.
Love,
Elle McLemore

"Elle!" I cried, hugging her. She held me tightly and said, "This gift's an important one. Open it."

I opened the box, and inside was a manila folder. I opened the folder, and inside, there was something I never thought I would see.

Adoption papers.

"Oh my God. Is this real? I'm getting adopted?" I squealed and hugged Elle. "Thank you, thank you, thank you!"

"It's also a joint birthday present, too. The court date's on June 30th. Your birthday." Katie said.

I squealed and hugged each cast member one at a time. Then, Elle said, "There's a second part of the surprise. I got your middle name legally changed. Your last name's getting changed too."

I took out the paper that was behind my adoption papers, and read it in shock.

"Welcome home, Catlynn Sunshine McLemore."

AN: I told you Catlynn was gonna get some good news! I really hope you enjoyed the story. Sweet little Catlynn has kind of taken over my life at this point. Catch ya later!

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

447K 19.7K 141
The everlasting cycle of being thrown from one foster home to another is enough to destroy a girls self love and ability to see the world as beautifu...
522 28 15
What happens when you bump into your greatest inspiration? Amber, a 22 year old loves musical theatre, and is biased over some actors. She auditioned...
119K 2.8K 36
Macey is a girl who has been straight up bullied in an orphanage for years. But one day, someone comes along to adopt her. What could go wrong? Insp...
9.1K 639 68
The year is 2016, and Catlynn McLemore has everything she could ever want. A loving family, a group of supportive friends, and a beautiful girlfriend...