The Choice I Regret

Sleep Tight

Rachel’s Pov

What the hell is Finn doing here? And why is he looking at me like that? I look around to see that spencer had a worried look on her face. Crap, now what? I look down and I finally realize why Finn has been staring at me, my pyjamas are more revealing then that dress spencer has. I’m killing this boy. I see him holding bags which looks like his luggage and I wonder why he has them. Was everything ok with him and Quinn? Did he leave her? Did she leave him? I have to find out, after all this could affect my plan. Spencer brings me out of my thoughts when she says

“Shall we continue the movie Rach?” she pushes past him and walks towards me

“Um I think I’m going to head to bed” I say just above a whisper

“You’re kidding me right, you came here for a sleepover and to go to bed early” she says following me as I make my way to the guest bedroom after I pushed passed Finn. I shake my head at how spencer can act like Finn being here isn’t a bad Idea. I finally reach the guess bedroom and spencer gives me the “you’re not joking are you?” look.

“Look, the word sleepover has the word sleep in in so that is exactly what I’m going to do” I say shutting the guest bedroom door in front of spencer and hop into bed. I hear Spencer’s dad start talking, probably to Finn. My mind still leads to the idea of Finn leaving Quinn. He was single and ready to mingle. Looks the plan is going to be easier than I thought. My eye lids feel heavy and the next thing I knew I was dreaming about the love of my life.

Finn’s POV

I feel the cool breeze as Rachel passes me and walks to the guest bedroom. I couldn’t help but stare at her. Lucky that brad came over shortly after the girls left because the more I think about her the more I want her.

“Finny Boy glad to see you, you look like you need to hit the sack” brad yells slapping my back.

I wince at the pain and try not to think of the stinging feeling in my back from the slap.

“Um yea, it’s been a hard day” I mumble

“I’ll take you to the guest bedroom” he picks up one of my bags and I follow him to the guest bedroom. As I walk down the hallway I see picture frames hanging on the wall. There’s one that catches my eye. I stop and look closer and I see that its spencer and none other than the cutest brunette I know, Rachel. I quickly catch up to Brad and see him standing in front of a door, but the odd thing is spencer is not letting him in. when brad looks back at me I pretend to look at some more photos but what they really don’t know is that I’m eavesdropping. After a few minutes they finally finish arguing and I hear footsteps and I know its spencer when I feel a tough pull at my shirt, I turn around and I jumped at her death glare, I was about to walk away when she pulls me down by my collar and she pulls me close.

“If you do anything to her, I swear I will make sure you can never have kids” she simply says with a harsh tone. I feel her loosen her grip and take it as my cue to leave.

I see brad come out of the guest bedroom and her gives me the signal to come over, so I do. I lean close so he can whisper in my ear.

“Ok, this is how it’s going to be she’s only here for one night, so keep it in your pants ok? Just let her be. If you do anything to her your off the team” he looks at me and I nod as I hold in my breath

I don’t even know what spencer and brad are talking about. She? Then I think for a little and soon understand what they were talking about. Rachel was in there and I would have to share a bed with her. I take a deep breath and open the door and cringe when the door squeaks.

As I walk into the room I straight away look to the bed and see a small figure and I knew she was sleeping and if I remember correctly when we were dating she told me she was a light sleeper so I had to be very quiet which is kind of hard because I’m really clumsy. I walk over to where my bags are placed and I open the bag where I know my pyjamas were. After I was dressed I saw that the guest bedroom had its own bathroom and I see that Rachel had all her things lined up near the sink and I couldn’t help but laugh at how she takes so much care in her skin and how does she even have time to apply so many things. I quickly brush my teeth and then make my way towards the bed and pull the sheets back and I see that Rachel has changed her position and now I have more view of her cleavage. I wasn’t complaining but I’m just worried I can’t handle it.

Just as I got into the bed I hear a small mumble and I look over to Rachel and I see her big chocolate eyes staring back at me.

“Finn? What are you doing in here?” she said sounding really scared

I take a deep breath and say “brad said I could stay in the guest bedroom and then you were here for a sleepover and you fell asleep in here and well there were no other rooms, but his sons and he said that it was a mess and I have to stay in here while it gets cleaned up” I see her nod and then she asks

“Why couldn’t you take the couch?” and that really hurt, I try not to show it and reply quickly

“brad didn’t want me to have a bad back before I even played my first game” she nods again and then I see her get out of bed and I ask her where she was going and she says that she forgot to do her bedtime ritual, I laugh and she lets out a soft giggle.

When she returns she hops into the bed and I make myself comfortable and so does she. I was about to fall asleep when I feel her roll over closer to me. I quickly start to get nervous, but relax when I hear her calming voice

“Finn?” she whispers

“Yea?” I mumble

“Why are you here?” ok, now I’m confused, I already told her it’s because brad’s sons room is a pigsty, but like she read my mind she continued

“I mean staying here with your bags” I swallow hard and try to think if I should tell her the truth. Rachel has never lied to me she’s always been brutally honest with me so I should do the same.

“Quinn and I are separating” I see her eyes grow wide and she sits up and I feel kind of good, because it’s the first time someone’s cared for me like this in long time, in other words ever since I’ve married Quinn.

“I’m so sorry, I had no idea” I interrupted her

“it’s fine we were never going to work out and I have finally realized that” I see her lean in closer and my heart beat goes faster and I lick my lips preparing for whatever she’s going to do to me. I close my when her face is inches away from mine and I almost die when I feel her breath on my skin I feel her lips lightly brush over mine and I smile only to be disappointed when I feel her lips on my check and she gives me a simple kiss there.

“I really am sorry” she says leaning back. She lays back down facing me and closes her eyes and says goodnight I reply with

“Sleep Tight” I feel her shift a little, I close my eyes and can’t help but imagine myself waking up with her next to me every morning for the rest of my life. I get pulled out of my thoughts when I hear her say

“Don’t let the bed bugs bite” I couldn’t help but laugh because it pure cuteness.

Vote & Comment and tell me what you think. Hope You liked it!!!