I like you, but I love her (Hope)

6.7K 122 27
                                    

Hope returns after jumping into Malivore to see you have moved on with Josie. Josie gave everyone their memories back and now you got to choose.

I laid alone in my bed for the first time in almost three months. After Josie came back from New Orleans and gave everyone their memories back I kind of just locked myself in my room.

I couldn't face either without knowing what to say.

Josie isn't just my girlfriend, she's my best friend.

But Hope... it's unbelievable that I ever forgot her after everything. Everything we've been through.

How am I supposed to make this choice? I look at the clock on my nightstand and check the time

3:30 am

I got out of bed and went to the music room. The only way I can face them is by working through these feelings. And music is the best way I know how.

When I realized I found the perfect piano riff it all just poured out of me. Hot tears rolled down my face as I try to get this song out for Josie.

It was when I wrote the first verse, I knew my choice and I knew it was going to hurt.

The sun was rising when I had finally the whole song written. I decided to see if I could play it without crying.

I started playing the piano and took a deep breath and began to sing softly.

I like your parents and they like me

They never seen you smile the way you smile when you're with me

And it's like we're in a movie, cause we're all happy families yeah       

The door to the music room opened but I was too entranced with the music to notice.

I like your parents and they like me

So, it breaks my heart that I have to break your heart

My tears started to roll down my cheeks, but I kept singing.

Cause I like you I like you, but I love her

Yeah, I like you I like you, but I love her

I don't want to hurt you, but I don't want to lie

Cause I like you I like you, but I love her

I closed my eyes to keep singing and trying not to completely break down.

I like your girlfriends and they like me

They never seen you laugh the way you laugh when you're with me

And I know they're gonna hate me, but I need to do what's right yeah

Said I like your girlfriends and they like me

So, it breaks my heart that I have to break your heart

Legacies ImaginesWhere stories live. Discover now