She was Jennifer
He was James
In the teenage world full of crushes, drama, fun, and tears, Jen and James thought they've seen it all. Since birth they've been inseparable. Now, it's the ending of summer and the beginning of their senior year at Heav...
Hearing the door open, Jen stops breathing and I immediately know why.
This is all a part of the plan.
As I begin to remove my blindfold and open my eyes, the presence beside me is suddenly gone and replaced with a slut named Peyton.
She grabs my arm, dragging me out of the closet where I just had the time of my life.
Only a few minutes ago, I was kissing Jen with everything I had and she was doing it back. I'm honestly shocked that Jen let me go further than kissing her when only seconds before the kiss, she said this whole speech and set her boundaries.
Just thinking of how I made her moan gets me hard again. You best believe that the whole time I was in there I had to hold myself back from doing more...
Coming back to reality, I see that everyone left. I guess they all left while we were in there. From the corner of my eye, I see the camera I told Kyra to set up. Next, I see one straight ahead of me, sitting on a movie rack that I left Cora in charge of.
Yes, everyone but Jen knew about the plan. Even the people playing the game. It was a setup.
Everything is going as planned, now I just hope that Jen got home safe and that I can officially get Peyton off my dick.
"Baby who were you in that closet kissing?" Peyton asked calmly. From the tone of her voice, I could tell she already knew who it was.
"Why does it matter? You and I aren't together anymore!" I began to get upset. Why won't this bitch leave me alone?
"Come on baby, I know that you love me."
"Stop playing games Peyton. I saw you making out with that jock a few days before I broke up with you. Shit, you probably slept with him too, huh?" I was talking about her ex-boyfriend.
She bowed her head and nodded shamefully.
The one rule I had when we first got together was to stay faithful the entire time. I knew she wouldn't be able to keep her word but I really wanted to know how long she could last.
It was true, I did see her getting it on with him.
I just ignored them because I didn't have the energy to argue with her. It was also the perfect excuse to end things with her finally. Honestly, she was super annoying and a little too clingy for me.
"If you can't even be loyal to me, what makes you think that I would love you?! The only, and I mean only, person that deserves my love is Jen. She has been there for me since we were still in diapers and has helped me through everything. The good, the bad, and the ugly. So please do tell me what makes you think that I would want to be with a cheater?!"
"I'm sorry James, but we had a deal! I was going to make my ex jealous and you were gonna distract yourself from Jen with me!"
"That all ended the moment you decided to go behind my back and cheat on me. I'm done with you and your fake ass attitude...If you want your ex back so bad then maybe stop being such a bitch and learn how to stay loyal for more than a month."
"You know what, you're right. I will go and get my ex back because he's the only man that'll ever love!"
"Good! Have fun while you're at it!"
"I sure as hell will!"
The room fell silent after she said that.
I don't like being a dick so I decided to apologize.
"Listen, Peyton, thank you for trying to help me. I'm sorry that everything had to end like this but I do hope you accomplish your goal and get your boyfriend back. Are we be good? I really don't want any drama right now."
In response, she did a small nod and left the room.
Once she left, everyone from before entered and I couldn't help but laugh. Of course, they were listening to the little argument.
Alex went and stopped all the cameras. I honestly don't know why we decided to record the whole thing. It was Kyra's idea and I guess I was too caught up in my head to realize what she said so I just agreed.
I couldn't help but think of Jen again.
Is she ok?
"Guys, where's my baby? Did she get home safe?"
Shae spoke up.
"Yea, I followed her home in my car and made sure she got in her house."
"Why didn't you just drive her home?"
"Because of the way she fled from the party, it looked like she needed to be alone for a little bit and running is one of the best ways that anyone clears their head."
I shook my head at Shae's answer.
"Welp, thank you, everyone, for helping me get an amazing moment with Jen and hopefully after all of this, I'll get the balls to make her mine and stop all this confusing shit."
"Yea, you should. She loves you a lot man." Cayden spoke up.
I nodded my head in reply and shouted goodbye to everyone before leaving for Jen's house.
Well, here goes nothing...
Oops! This image does not follow our content guidelines. To continue publishing, please remove it or upload a different image.
Hey Guys, I really hope y'all enjoyed this chapter. It was more of a fuller on James and Peyton's relationship. Please vote, comment, and follow me! I always follow back!
