Proxy in Command (Creepypasta X Reader)

Chapter 6

"Don't worry about me I'm fine. Anyways did you find Eyeless Jack?" I asked.

"Yes. Hoodie and Toby are on their way. I already sent the address to the group chat."

Masky's town was the furthest comparing to Toby and Hoodie's. It would take me 30 minutes minimum for me to arrive while the others could make it way sooner.

"Start the mission without me. I have important issues to solve."

"What! You're the head proxy, you're more advanced with training than the three of us combined!" He exclaimed.

The 2 figures had now gotten up. With my other hand, I held my dagger that was in my pocket.

"Great to know, you're in charge," I said before ending the call.

"What are you doing here all alone in the dark, doll?" The one with the beanie asked with a smirk.

"Just saying, this doll can still beat your asses," I snarled but calmed myself. "Anyways do you know who Slenderman is?" I asked in which they both nodded. "Well, believe it or not, I'm Y/N L/N"

The one with the mask looked towards the one with the beanie. "Dude we got a feisty and psycho one"

I groaned knowing well they wouldn't believe me. I looked towards them while trying to remember their names. I looked at the masked man but couldn't help but to stare at his bloody painted smile.

Wait...

Bloody painted smile... The Bloody Painter!

"I was on a mission to find someone else. I wasn't supposed to look for you guys until a few days later. I believe you're The Bloody Painter and you're..." I trailed off while looking at his features. I couldn't remember his name but I couldn't help to stare at his eyes.

Wait, I remember one had puppet inside his name. What was it again?

I kept staring at his eyes for a few seconds until it hit me.

"The Puppeteer," I finished with a smirk.

"Anyone could easily search up our names," Painter said while taking a step forward. "You could have searched us up or saw it on the news"

I smirked again. "From what I know, the news only states your real names seeing as you guys went missing. Painter you use "BP" in your written quote, you guys haven't revealed your killer names."

Puppeteer opened his mouth in shock but quickly closed it. "How can you prove to us you're not lying?"

I shrugged. "Have you guys heard of Jeff The Killer? He's on our team. What about the missing children in carnivals? The murderer is also on our side. If luck is on our side, the killer that has been taking his victim's kidneys will also join us. If you guys don't agree, Slenderman or the Proxies and I will have to kill you because we can't let anyone know we exist besides the Creepypastas." I explained.

"How about a deal then? We have a duel, no weapons allowed. Us two against you. If we win we will kill you. Painter is running low on his paint so we could use your blood," Puppeteer suggested.

I raised my eyebrow. "Easy. But if I win, which will happen, you guys have to follow me to the forest. Slenderman will inform you of the expectations and you will have the choice to join or die," I said.

"Deal"

Painter threw his weapon on the grass while I threw my dagger. I noticed that Puppeteer didn't throw anything.

"Aren't you going to drop your weapon?" I asked him.

He smirked. "I don't have any weapons doll."