Forgotten (Toby x Reader)  by Mr_CookiesAndMilk
Forgotten (Toby x Reader) by Cookie
Let her go. She's scared of me She wasn't ever suppose to meet me. Okay... If it makes her life better...I'll let her go. But...At the back of my head One small tiny voi...
  • toby
  • humor
  • romance
+15 more
Mad House (Jeff the Killer X reader) by SuicidalFallenAngel
Mad House (Jeff the Killer X Fallen Angel
Jeff the killer x reader Is it possible for you to fall in love with an insane killer?
  • creepypasta
  • madhouse
  • wattys2017
+4 more
Make You Beautiful - [Jeff the Killer x reader] by IceT3a
Make You Beautiful - [Jeff the IceT3a .
(Y/N) didn't have an easy life. But she only realized how happy she actually was after she had lost it all to a bipolar maniac who wanted her all to himself. DISCLAIMER...
  • romance
  • murder
  • yandere
+17 more
Forget Me Not by CheyenneScissorHands
Forget Me Notby CheyenneScissorHands
>Part of the Creepypasta childhood memories series< Thanks to Ben, Jeff is forced to walk down memory lane. He doesn't mind but you on the other hand still hold a...
  • jeffthekillerfanfiction
  • creepypastafanfiction
  • jeffthekillerlovestory
+3 more
Jeff the Killer X blind reader  by J_THE_K
Jeff the Killer X blind reader by J_THE_K
so this is written on deviantart and the author does not have a wattpad I AM NOT THE AUTHOR! but this book is to good not to share on wattpad. it was on here for a while...
  • jeffthekiller
  • hoodie
  • romance
+5 more
Creepypastas Little Neko by AimyBear
Creepypastas Little Nekoby AimyBear
"Strange little girl, she looks skinny" "Are you sure you're not a pet?" "Honey, did you eat his hamster?" "No rats, clean. Thanks l...
  • sallywilliams
  • homicidalliu
  • jeffthekiller
+9 more
Taken. Jeff The Killer X Reader. Dark Story By RoverRose by rhianna_williamson13
Taken. Jeff The Killer X Reader. Rhianna Mae Williamson
After a mentally deranged killer had entered your house, and you had to hide for your life, your friends all started to be taken one by one while this killer began to gr...
  • jeffthekiller
  • insanity
  • slenderman
+8 more
Sins [Jeff the killer x reader] (being rewritten) by meomwi
Sins [Jeff the killer x reader] ( chris
Jeff attempts to kill you, but you almost kill him instead. [updated as often as possible]
  • jeffthekiller
  • killers
  • sins
+7 more
Creepypasta x Reader Oneshots (REQUESTS APPRECIATED) by IrishLady_28
Creepypasta x Reader Oneshots ( Aisling
As in the title I will be taking requests for this and it's only creepypasta. I will write each of your requests. But please no smut or lemon. I refuse to write those.
  • romance
  • jeffthekiller
  • thepuppeteer
+6 more
Long sleeves hide scars ** Hoodie x reader by Untitled_hearts
Long sleeves hide scars ** Rumour
All I can really say is Long sleeves hide scars @uselesstwink for the cover tysm 💜
  • slenderman
  • killer
  • eyelessjack
+13 more
Jeff the killer x Child reader by FlawlessMistake7
Jeff the killer x Child readerby FlawlessMistake7
There aren't many stories like this, so I decided why not? this story is about a child named Y/N who gets adopted by the creepypastas. (No photos are mine, unless said o...
  • lj
  • slenderman
  • ticcitoby
+13 more
Savior 》Ticci Toby x Reader {EDITING} by hatsu-senpai
Savior 》Ticci Toby x Reader { X Dead Account X
~"The wind tugged at your hair as you sat on a bench and read your book. You had an uneasy feeling, like you were being watched, but you ignored it. You didn't know...
  • jeffthekiller
  • completed
  • fanfic
+8 more
Obey My Words ( yandere Jeff the killer X reader) (under construction) by smileingXD
Obey My Words ( yandere Jeff the Minx the murderer
(Y/n) just moved out of her parents house, after turning 18 and then having her parents give her the final nudge out of the best she hit hard, bills, money, food..... An...
  • smilesgoformiles
  • creepypasta
  • xreader
+2 more
~Don't let me drown~ BEN Drowned x Reader [COMPLETED] by theboy_inthe_woods
~Don't let me drown~ BEN Drowned theboy_inthe_woods
(Y/n) went swimming one day after a long day at school. She had always wondered what it was like to swim on a spring day without anything but her bathing suit and a few...
  • ben
  • drowned
  • xreader
+8 more
Jeff the killer x reader by zinniowl
Jeff the killer x readerby Zinni Owl
y/n was a not a normal girl. she would always get beaten by her father because he would always get drunk. one night she heard a big crash downstairs. what will happen ne...
  • fanfiction
  • jeffthekillerxreader
  • wattpad
+4 more
Killer Protector (Jeff the Killer story) by EternalLaughter
Killer Protector (Jeff the #ENDviolence
Elizabeth always knew she was a special sort. Her family and friends knew too. She's an introvert and feels like a weirdo wherever she goes, even in her own home. But wh...
  • romance
  • jeffthekiller
  • gore
+5 more
Don't Make A Sound (Laughing Jack X Reader) by JRich_2832
Don't Make A Sound (Laughing Jocelyn Richardson
After witnessing the horrible murders of your parents at the age of 7, you haven't been the same since. You become a mute, shutting yourself out from the world, not doin...
  • creepypasta
  • sexualoffenderman
  • slenderman
+7 more
Voice of the Demon [Creepypasta X Reader] by Kiruma_Haruka
Voice of the Demon [Creepypasta CreepyPastaPsychoGirl
Y/N is the daughter of the Underground demon. Her father was Zalgo and her little sister was Lazari. Y/N was happy she have a family even if they're demons. At the age o...
  • eyelessjack
  • bendrowned
  • mystery
+8 more
I fell in Love with a killer (Jeff the Killer x reader) by hana_to_akuma
I fell in Love with a killer ( Hana🌺
You're just an ordinary teenager. But there is one thing that sets you apart from the others. Where others fear the creepypasta's you actually like them. They intrigue y...
  • love
  • weird
  • jeffthekiller
+2 more
I Found You {Jeff The Killer X Reader} by XxTheFairyQueenxX
I Found You {Jeff The Killer X ♥︎ Kate Quintanar ♥︎
『 #13 ɪɴ ᴊᴇғғ ᴛʜᴇ ᴋɪʟʟᴇʀ 』 The blood rushed over my body, heart beating, world spinning. It was a whole new world, I never knew something so bad could feel so good. The...
  • creepy
  • love
  • horror
+18 more