Proxy in Command (Creepypasta X Reader)

Chapter 5

"Y/N do you think he's there," Hoodie said while pointing at something. I followed his gaze and saw a black and white tent at the end. There wasn't anything surrounding it since it looked abandoned at the end of the carnival.

I let go of my hold and started to walk towards it. "Only one way to find out."

As we were getting closer we heard faint screams. One might have guessed it could have been kids from the rides but I knew better.

A boy around  8 ran outside the tent and stopped in front of us. "Please you have to help me. This black and white clown is hurting my sister!" He yelled at us with tears in his eyes.

I furrowed my eyebrows. "Lead the way"

The kid nodded and held my hand while we walked to the tent. The proxies and Jeff were behind me and prepared for anything.

Immediately as we stepped inside the tent, I saw Laughing Jack poking a dead girl with his nails. It could startle anyone especially a kid but it made me smirk.

"Laughing Jack I think you're missing one," I said while carrying the kid. He tried to get out of my hold but was too weak.

Laughing Jack turned around to look at me while smirking. I gave him the child in which made him smirk wider.

"Let me go!" The kid screamed, knowing well what Laughing Jack was going to do to him.

When Laughing Jack was about to kill the boy, Toby yelled out, "Y/N w-what are you d-doing?"

I turned to look at the Proxies who were waiting at the entrance. The child stopped screaming which made me realize I missed out on his death. I saw that the kid had gotten his heart ripped out by Laughing Jack and laid on the floor lifeless.

"Toby you made me miss out on the fun," I groaned.

Laughing Jack brought my right hand between his hands while staring at me with a creepy smile. "And who are you, my dear?" He asked. "Why would you return my victim and enjoy my wonderful show?"

I sighed knowing well what he will respond to my answer. "I'm Y/N L/N. You probably heard of me already," I answered while taking my hand away and crossing my arms in front of my chest.

He raised his right hand on his chin and nodded. "It does sound familiar but I can't seem to place my mind into it"

"Perhaps this could help you. I'm in the urban legend with Slenderman. You know the tall, bald, faceless creature who has tentacles and will kill you in the forest," I said while rolling my eyes.

He wickedly laughed and nodded. "Haha, you expect me to believe that when you're a cosplayer?"

I sighed. "If you think we're cosplayers do you think this is real? Toby show him your check"

Toby hesitated but nodded. He took out his mouthguard and showed him his gash.

Laughing Jack shook his head. "Cosplayers do crazy things with makeup"

I facepalmed myself and looked at Jeff. "Jeff take your hood off."

"What? You said I'm going to look like a clown."

I looked at the proxies and moved my head to the left, signaling them to put his hood down. Toby and Hoodie both grabbed him by his shoulders and Masky pulled his hood down from behind.

Laughing Jack took a step behind and cursed, "Holy shit! What the actual fuck is that?"

I smirked. "This is the famous Jeff The Killer! So, now do you believe us?" I asked

Laughing Jack nodded. "Alright if that's true why are you guys here?"

"Slenderman wants to form an army filled with serial killers so that we can kill this demon called Zalgo. If you accept you get to live in this mansion with us and will be provided with food. If you don't then we have no choice but to kill you because no one must know about our existence," I explained.

"Fine, I accept." He snapped his fingers which made the dead bodies disappear. "So do I have to follow you or what?"

I nodded. I turned around and started to walk away knowing well he was going to attack me from behind.

"Y/N watch out!" Toby yelled

I bend down and grabbed his arm that was about to punch me and pulled him close to me. I turned around, twisted his arm, and held his neck. I then placed my leg between his and dropped him.

"What is up with you guys trying to attack me from behind?" I asked, remembering my encounter with Masky and Hoodie.

"Alright, I believe you," Laughing Jack said while groaning with pain.

(...)

After gathering Laughing Jack, we made our way back to the mansion. He told us more about himself and his abilities. I now understood why Slenderman would want to recruit him. Surprisingly Laughing Jack relied on us and didn't try anything else against us.

I knocked on the wooden door and waited for Slenderman's reply. I opened the door for the guys to go in. We walked in front of his desk with Laughing Jack in front of us.

"Good job my proxies and Jeff. You are dismissed besides you Y/N. Laughing Jack, please take a seat. We need to discuss something"

The guys nodded left the office which left the 3 of us inside.

"Our next Creepypasta will be Eyeless Jack. I do recommend reading his file seeing as we'll be dealing with a cannibal." Slenderman informed me.

I nodded and bowed down. I then left his office, eager to know what we were going to deal with. I couldn't help but think how would a cannibal help us in the battle with Zalgo?

I got shivers down my spine when I thought about Zalgo but soon relaxed. I kept assuring myself I wasn't the same person from 10 years ago. I grew stronger and prepared for the upcoming battle.

As soon as I went inside my room, I headed towards my cork bulletin board. I got the red marker and marked X on Laughing Jack's picture. As I closed the cap I looked at Eyeless Jack's picture and looked at his blue mask with black eye sockets. I looked down his picture and read Cannibalistic Murderer.

As soon as I finished reading all his information, I couldn't help but look at the other 4 future creepypastas. I saw a guy who had a white mask with a smile on his face. His name was Helen Ortis also known as The Bloody Painter.  A guy with yellow eyes and yellow strings was called Jonathan Blake, also known as The Puppeteer. A guy that looked like Link was called Benjamin Lawman but was referred to as Ben Drowned The last one didn't have a picture but his name was Liu Woods. I didn't bother to read their information seeing as it wasn't their turn yet.

A knock from my door interrupted my thoughts. I quickly went towards the door and opened it.

"It's time for lunch," Masky said.

I nodded. I took a glance at the board before heading towards the dining room.