Proxy in Command (Creepypasta X Reader)

Chapter 46

Slenderman glanced at Y/N, who had an arm wrapped by Puppeteer's strings.

"If we break the spell she becomes immune to your power, doesn't she?"

"The hell did you hear that from!" Zalgo growled. "She's not under my spell!"

"That has yet to be determined. I have faith the pastas will figure out a way to break it."

Zalgo chuckled. "The spell is unbreakable, old man. There is no way to bring her back."

"So she is under your spell?" Slenderman caught his lie.

Zalgo stood still before secretly hitting him with a fireball behind him. Slenderman fell to the ground as he felt his back was on fire.

"This is giving us déjà vu, isn't it, Slenderman?"

Y/N was trapped in E.J's chokehold until she stepped on his foot and stabbed him in the shoulder. Toby stood there twitching as he witnessed her attacking his friends. She ignored him knowing he wouldn't hurt her.

She turned around, surveying the area until her eyes spotted L.J who was hiding someone on his back. It wasn't hard to tell who it was based on the small legs and pink dress.

"Is that Sally?" She smiled evilly as she slowly walked toward them.

"Stay away from her," L.J warned her, using his body to shield Sally.

"I wasn't asking," she smirked.

Strings wrapped her wrists from behind while another set was wrapped around her ankles, causing her to fall to her knees.

She groaned in annoyance before turning around to glare at Puppeteer.

"What's the matter, doll?" He teased her as he walked in front of her. "Is this still kinky enough for you?"

She yelled in annoyance as she used her magic to break free from her retrains. Puppeteer fell in pain before being lifted in the air by Y/N with her magic.

"You're the annoying one so I'll give you the privilege of dying first!" 

Wires were wrapped on her wrists again causing Puppeteer to fall to the ground.

She snapped her head towards Ben, who was standing in front of L.J. She glared at him as fire came out of her hands, causing the wires to burn. Ben made his wires disappear before they caught on fire. Dark Link stood by Ben, aiming his sword toward her.

"It's a shame you decided to betray us Dark Link because now I have to kill you too."

"Y/N, snap out of it! You were the one who told me to get them to prevent the spell from happening, remember? You deeply care about them!"

Y/N ignored him as her gaze was on L.J. The pastas got up and used themselves as shields to protect L.J and the girl.

"My patience is running thin." She whispered before raising her hands. The pastas all dropped their weapons as they were raised in the air, choking.

She glanced back at L.J, who was standing on the ground as she threw the pastas behind her.

"Let her death be the symbol of a new beginning."

She raised L.J in the air before turning her gaze to Sally. Once their eyes met, Y/N's smirk had disappeared.

"Sally," she whispered as her memories with the child flooded in. She couldn't believe she was about to kill the one she was bound to protect. As if she was in a trance, she didn't move her gaze away from her, causing one of her eyes to turn back E/C. She subconsciously dropped L.J down before she felt a stinging sensation on her stomach.

"Y/N!" She heard the child scream.

She slowly looked down and saw she had been stabbed with a knife. Her mouth was open as she tried to process what had happened.

Jeff realized too late what he had done. She was back to her usual self and he had just stabbed her.

"Y/N," he whispered as he stepped back, the knife still inside her stomach. "I-I didn't know you were-" he stopped as he saw the red blood coming out, something he had only seen with his victims. "Y-You're actually mortal?"

The proxies glanced at each other as they got reminded of the time Y/N took a bullet for Toby. She had almost died when that occurred.

Y/N ignored Jeff as she turned her attention towards Zalgo and Slenderman. Slenderman was on the floor on his knees, facing down. 

Zalgo stood a few feet away from him as he was summoning a ball of energy in his hands.

"Don't worry, this is going to hurt," he yelled.

Y/N closed her eyes as a random memory flooded in.

The almost seven-year-old stood by the door as she watched the horrible sight outside of the mansion in the middle of the night. Zalgo had attacked Slenderman, his brothers, and Zen. Currently, Zalgo was aiming a ball of energy in his hand directly toward Slenderman.

Y/N widened her eyes as she realized what Zalgo was about to do. She had promised herself she would protect him no matter what. 

It was the only way to prove herself to him.

She threw the door open and sprinted where Zalgo was. Zen who could barely lift himself, screamed at the top of his lungs, "Y/N no!"

"Don't worry, this is going to hurt," Zalgo chuckled before throwing the energy ball at Slenderman.

"No!" Y/N screamed, taking the hit for Slenderman.

"I swore to protect him," she whispered before she furrowed her eyebrows in anger. "To prove my loyalty."

With the remaining power she had left, she teleported in front of Slenderman. As Zalgo threw the ball, she attempted to throw another one out. Her power was completely gone, resulting in her getting the hit.

Slenderman was helpless on the floor as he stood there in shock. It took him a few seconds to realize history was repeating itself.

Sally tried to run towards her, but L.J carried her before she got the chance.

The pastas were horrified by the sight. Their friend laid lifeless on the floor with a knife still inside her stomach.

Slenderman was about to teleport to her but Zalgo beat him first. "Y/N!" He yelled as he inspected the wound.

Y/N paid no attention to him as she searched for Slenderman. Once she noticed him, she whispered, "Go, take Dark."

Slenderman nodded before teleporting to the others, using an independent tendril to grab each of the pastas including Dark Link.

"Remember that you're completely immune to his powers. They will no longer work on you. I'll be back for you."

A small smile formed on Y/N's lips not only because Dark was going to escape, but because the pastas were safe.  Her eyes slowly closed as her head dropped to the side.

"YOU WILL ALL PAY FOR THIS!" Zalgo fumed as he got up to form the biggest energy orb he had ever made.

Slenderman teleported away with the others before Zalgo's orb could hit them, resulting in the glass-stained windows shattering into pieces.

He tried to catch his breath before remembering Y/N's life was at stake. He got down at his knees to feel her weak pulse.

"I'm not letting you die, at least not now."