Proxy in Command (Creepypasta X Reader)

Chapter 26

"I love it when you're this submissive," he whispered before nuzzling his nose on my neck.

I felt tears dropping on the sides of my cheeks. I couldn't yell nor move. I wanted him to get off since he made me remember what happened on my mission with Derek. I wanted to forget it but now it seemed impossible. Without a doubt, he was going to torture me like this.

Zalgo took notice of my tears since he kept kissing them away.

"It's not as bad it seems love, you just gotta enjoy it."

I kept telling myself this was only a nightmare and it wasn't real but I knew it was real. I couldn't control my fear.

A knock on my door made Zalgo growl as he turned around. I felt relieved and silently hoped they would open the door.

"Y/N, dinner is ready!" I heard Splendor announce.

Zalgo turned around to look at me before covering my mouth with his hand. With his other, he touched my forehead and I finally regained control of my body except for my wrists.

"If you make it obvious that I'm here, I won't hesitate to kill him." He threatened.

"Y/N? Are you there?"

Zalgo uncovered my mouth to allow me to talk. I could either obey Zalgo or yell out for help.

"I'll join in a few minutes!" I raised my voice as I tried to keep it steady. I couldn't risk his life or the others. I had to protect them from Zalgo. Zen would also be in danger seeing as Zalgo is capable of informing Slenderman that I've been meeting up with him.

"Alright, we're just waiting for you and E.J."

Zalgo and I stood frozen for a few seconds waiting to see if he would walk away. After a while, we both figured he had teleported away. Zalgo covered my mouth again as he smirked.

"Good girl. I can't wait to make you mine soon. I can just imagine how submissive you'll be to protect them." I felt his other hand raise my hoodie as I felt his cold hands touching my stomach.

I tried kicking him away but he was too heavy. Although he wasn't pinning my arms, I still couldn't move them. Desperation took over as I realized what he wanted to do. I couldn't scream to get help or do anything to get away from him. I kept on thrashing around until he said something to make my blood run cold.

"Is this giving you flashbacks from your mission with Derek?" He laughed.

I widen my eyes after he said that. I still didn't know how he knew about Derek.

"I enjoy going through your memories to find your weak spots, little one. But perhaps this is the best one of them all."

I felt him pull the waistband of my sweatpants down. More tears began to fall. Instead of him looking down, he kept his gaze at me. He was more interested in my reaction. I immediately kept thrashing around. It seemed to work since he seemed to get annoyed. He rolled his eyes before putting them back up.

"It seems men touching you is your weakness especially after Derek's incident ." He chuckled. "Heck, you flinched when that elf boy grabbed your wrist."

Zalgo moved his hand to caress my face while the other still covered my mouth.

"Or maybe you remember that special night you woke up and disobeyed my orders. Do you remember when you woke up the Slender brothers and told them about your nightmares? Do you remember your punishment?" He whispered the last sentence.

I moved my head to the side as I closed my eyes and remembered.

Offenderman was stubborn to find out if I was alright or not after I screamed in my sleep back when I was seven. I had confessed to him I had a nightmare but obviously, I lied about the details. Zalgo was in the room listening and when Offenderman finally left my room, Zalgo revealed his presence. All I remember was him getting closer and eventually, he pulled the waistband of my pants down. I couldn't remember what happened next but it wasn't hard to figure out what he had done.