Proxy in Command (Creepypasta X Reader)

Chapter 20

"Y/N! You're alive!" Sally exclaimed with pure happiness.

She was about to get off her chair but Slenderman teleported in front of me while harshly grabbing my arm with his tentacle.

"In my office, NOW!" He then teleported away which I assume to his office.

I gulped as I took a glance at the pastas' shocked faces before turning around to leave. I gently closed the door behind me before letting out a sigh.

I had to decide now whether I should lie to him or not. Am I seriously about to betray him? For a stranger? For years I was taught I had to be loyal to him especially because he spared my life and I was repaying it. Why would this be an exception?

I gently knocked on the door before opening it. Slenderman was sitting on his chair as he looked through a folder. I slowly walked up in front of his desk as if everything was okay.

"I told you to arrive in the morning yesterday. Apparently, there was a bomb explosion in the building. Care to explain everything?"

I nodded my head, "Sir, I was told to kill three people. Derek had five associates, so in the end, I had to kill six. I was the one who set the bomb seeing as Derek was going to use it to bomb the forest and I was running out of time, so killing them all at once seemed like the best option," I explained.

"The bomb exploded yesterday at midnight. Why didn't you return early in the morning? Due to the time difference, you had enough time."

I nodded my head before making my final decision.

"Due to the bomb, flights were delayed. I didn't return to the mansion until this morning when everyone was asleep." I noticed he was writing what I stated on the document. There were times he filed a report or I had to from my missions.

"What about your phone? Why didn't you communicate with us!"

"My phone died," I answered. Knowing that I wasn't lying, I felt more comfortable answering him that. He took a minute to finish up writing before he placed the pen down and closed the folder.

"You will be assisting the proxies in their mission later on today. Apparently, their presence is known and we need to exterminate that threat. They had failed to accomplish their mission multiples time so do not fail me."

Before I had the chance to reply, he teleported away. He was pissed and if he discovered I was lying, I would be adding more fuel to the flames.

I gulped as I stared at his chair. I realized I indeed had lied to him for the first time. This was so out of character for me. I decided the stranger had to give me the answers I sought the next time I saw him or else I would confess Slenderman everything.

I took my time to head back to the dining room to collect my thoughts once again. The feeling of hiding something from him made me unease. I had the urge to tell him the truth but the feeling of protecting that stranger's presence was somehow stronger. It didn't make sense.

I cleared my thoughts out as I went inside the dining room and silently sat on my seat next to Sally. She gave me a warm hug as I felt the stares of the pastas. Slenderman wasn't in the room which surprised me.

After a few seconds of feeling uncomfortable, I sighed before looking up to meet their gazes.

"You guys look as if you saw a ghost," I spoke out. If Sally wasn't in the room, I would have definitely cussed.

"How are you alive?" Ben whispered as he sat in front of me.

I raised my eyebrows in confusion. "what do you mean? I accomplished my mission and came back."

"Ben told us you were caught in an explosion," Masky explained.

I narrowed my eyes at Ben. "Did it ever occur to you that I was the one that purposely set the bomb?" I had a feeling what his answer would be.

"Last time I saw you through security cameras, you were still in the hotel. I went on a killing spree and when I came back, the connection was lost."

 I stood up and slammed my fists onto the table as I glared at him. "You idiot! I told you I didn't want you stalking me through the cameras. Your task was just to delete the evidence of my kill, which I appreciate you did, but this is exactly the reason why I didn't want you lurking!"

In the corner of my eye, I saw Offenderman get up from his seat and pulled Ben up by his shirt.

"YOU WERE FUCKING STALKING HER?!!" He yelled out with fury.

I would have defended Ben but since he disobeyed my orders, I didn't care.

"I thought it was my fault why you didn't come," Sally spoke out with a sad tone. I turned around to look at her with sympathy in my eyes. "I kinda told them about your birthday," she muttered.

Before I had the chance to reply, Slenderman popped up in the room with a plate in his hand.

"What is going on here?" He asked.

Offenderman growled before setting Ben down. "Nothing that you should worry about."

Slenderman placed my plate in front of me which caused my stomach to growl. Now that I recall, I haven't eaten a meal in a day.

"Are you sure?" He asked Ben.

Ben nodded his head before looking away from him. "Yeah, everything is alright Slender."

Slender? Since when did they start calling him that? Slender wasn't formal.

"Slendy, can I have more (food choice) please!"

Slenderman nodded his head before he grabbed Sally's plate to refill it.

What the actual fuck happened while I was gone?