Helplessly falling in love (Creepypasta x Neko!Reader)

Chapter 25

"I...I don't understand...What's wrong with..." You trailed off, reaching your hand to your eye.

Before you could touch it, someone grabbed your wrist.

"Don't touch it. We don't know what could happen."

You scoffed and glared at EJ.

"And why should I listen to you?!" You hissed, your tail flickering in annoyance.

"So you'll stay safe." He hissed, throwing your wrist forcefully back down.

You rubbed your wrist as you heard him mutter to you,

"I came back just to safe your sorry-ass. You're not even grateful for that." EJ huffed.

Your ears lowered down as you stared at the ground.

He did come to safe you.

But why would he?

After all that happened in the past, why would he still help you?

"I...I-I-" You stuttered.

"Look, how about we just get the fuck out of here before someone finds us?" Masky said.

Jeff grunted.

"I'm goin' out killing. Let's go, Smile."

Smile barked and followed Jeff to wherever he was going.

Silence built in for a few seconds, until BRVR spoke up.

"Let's just go back to the mansion."

The others hummed in agreement as you nodded.

The guys started walking forward with you trailing behind.

As you walked for awhile, you couldn't help but notice BEN glancing back at you.

BEN stopped walking for a few seconds to get next to you.

"Hey,"

"Hey." You muttered, continuing walking.

"So, look..." He started.

You turned your gaze to him in curiosity of what he was going to say.

"Back at the mansion...I didn't mean to shoo you away. I just snapped..."

You moved your gaze down to your feet.

"What I'm trying to say is...I'm sorry." He sighed.

"It's fine."

BEN looked over at you, slightly surprised and shocked.

"You just forgive me that quickly?"

"Sure. Everybody deserves a second chance."

You then glared at the back of Eyeless Jack.

"Except that son of a bitch. He doesn't deserve shit."

You noticed Jack stop in his tracks, his hands clenched into fists.

He turned around, making you and BEN stop in your tracks as well.

"It was a fucking ACCIDENT!" He snapped at you.

"How could it be an accident? Why the FUCK DIDN'T YOU JUST TELL ME WHAT YOU WERE GOING TO DO IN THE FIRST PLACE?! YOU KEPT EVERYTHING SECRET, YOU...YOU...!"

You had tears lining your eyes as you stormed past Jack.

Jack rolled his 'eyes', stuffing his hands in his pockets and continuing to walk.