Helplessly falling in love (Creepypasta x Neko!Reader)

Chapter 3

"I-I..."

Raven slightly choked on her own sobs,looking at you with her teary eyes.

"G-G-Go w-w-with t-them."

You stared wide eyed at your frightened little sister.
Is she really just...sacrificing herself for you?

"Wh-What?"

"Y-You mean allot more t-to the world t-thank you t-t-think.A-And besides,you d-deserve more than me." She choked out,

The twitchy teen chuckled and pressed the hatchet even tighter around her little neck.
He wanted to end her life.
Wanting to see her blood pour out everywhere.
Only for his pleasure.

"Well,well,well~ Looks like even your sister agrees that you should be coming with us." Jeff softly cooed in your ear.

A sigh escaped your lips as you dropped your tail and ears low.

"If i go,you'll let her live...r-right?"

Jeff chuckled,grabbed your chin and turned your head to him,making you stare into his eyes.

"Why would i ever lie to you,dear?"

You stared down at the ground as the twitchy boy spoke up.

"F-For fucks s-sake,kitty.C-Choose your d-d-damn decision." He growled.

You sighed and tilted your head up to Jeff.

"Fine.I'll go with you..." You snarled.

Jeff smirked making his carved smile larger.

"Excellent choice."

Jeff snapped his fingers one more time and the two masked teens from before held you back.

"H-Hey,what the-?!"

"Toby." Jeff nodded to the twitchy teen named 'Toby'.

He nodded with a smirk and in a split second,he slit your sisters neck.

"NO!"

She fell onto the ground,crimson liquid pouring from her neck.
She tried to speak,but instead of words,gurgles and chokes came out.
Tears flooded out of your eyes like a river as you watched her life slowly disappearing.

"R-Ra-Raven..." You choked out.

"I'm sorry,i'm so sorry...i'm sorry..." You kept on softly chanting to yourself.

"D-Did i d-d-do g-good?" Toby asked excitedly.

Jeff groaned and nodded.

"Yes,Toby.You did good." He murmured,rolling his eyes.

You hung your head low as the two masked teens held you tighter,not letting you escape.
Jeff stepped infront of you,lightly tilting your head up.

"Aw,don't be sad,babe.Cheer up,will ya?" He chuckled.

"How the fuck would i cheer up if you fucking murdered my only family!?" You choked out.

He growled and smacked you once more.
Hard.

"Don't fucking use that tone with me." He snarled.

He then looked over at the two masked boys holding you.

"Masky,Hoodie,take her away."

The...you guessed the white masked one groaned and pulled on your arm,taking you away to god knows where.

"Fucking Joker,thinking he's our damn boss." The white masked one groaned.

"...Dude,don't you think killing her sister went a little too far?" The hooded one said.

Alright,alright.
Let's just call the hooded one 'Hoodie' and the other masked one 'Masky'.
Masky shrugged and continued walking.
(Quick note: Masky is pulling you in the front and Hoodie in the back.)
Hoodie kept eyeing your ears and tail,inspecting them from close.
A small sob once again escaped your mouth as Masky let out a sigh.

"I...I feel strange." Hoodie murmurs.

Masky gave out a 'Hm?' sound.

"As if...something in me isn't right."

Masky tilts his eyebrow,still pulling you.

"You mean...You feel bad or something?" Masky asks.

"Y-Yeah.I mean,didn't Jeff make a deal or something? He basically broke it." Hoodie says.

Masky lets out another sigh as he stops mid-track.

"We're fucking murderers,dude.And murderers don't follow the damn rules." Masky growls and continues walking.

You,out of curiosity,say nothing and just listen to their conversation,small sniffs escaping from you.

"But we were once...'normal',remember...?"

Masky froze in his place as another soft growl escaped his mouth.

"Don't even fucking mention that."

...Silence.

"I'm actually surprised this one is kind of...calm." Hoodie says,his voice full of shock/surprise.

"...She just witnessed her sister dying.What do you expect?"