Helplessly falling in love (Creepypasta x Neko!Reader)

Chapter 2

Raven charged at Jeff,pushing him down with all her strength.

"What the fuck?!" Jeff hissed.

You took your chance and kicked the two guys that were holding you on their knees,making them fall down.
Jeff growled as cornered your little sister,his knife raising up.
You immediately took action and quickly grabbed your little sister as Jeff missed his shot and stabbed onto the wall.
You held onto your little sister tightly,running downstairs,heading to the door.

"Masky,Hoodie,don't let them escape,dammit!"

The two teens just sat there on the ground,groaning about how their...knees 'hurt'.

"Damn,dude.That chick is a fucking killing machine." The hooded one groaned.

"No fucking shit.She's a goddamn...cat!" The other one exclaimed.

Jeff growled,and jumped past the two masked teens.

"Next time,tell Slendick i work alone."

By the time you said that,you were already outside taking Raven onto a safe place.
You quickly ran to your neighbour's house,bonking the shit out of their door.
The door soon opened,revealing your annoyed neighbour.

"What?" He grunted.

"Ca-Can you please let us i-in?! There are-"

You stopped mid-sentence when your neighbour let out a painful screech and dropping onto the ground.
He looked like he was electrified to death.
You looked up to see a blonde male with a Pikachu hoodie on,smirking.
He put his finger onto his lips,attempting to quiet you down.
You yelped,and quickly ran to the opposite side of your neighbours house.
Raven silently started sobbing onto your shoulder as you held her tighter,telling her it's gonna be alright.
You,without thinking,ran deep into the dark woods,losing track of everything.
After a good few miles of running,you panted and set your sister down onto the ground.
The poor girl was now sobbing and shaking.
You got onto your knees,reaching her height.

"I-It's gonna be alright,okay?" You softly mumbled.

"Bu-But t-that boy,h-he wanted to hurt m-me!" She sobbed out.

She embraced you into a hug which you gladly returned.
You softly stroked her smooth hair,attempting to calm her down.

"Sh,sh,It's okay now..." You cooed.

Her sobs soon died down.
Out of nowhere,rustling out of the bushes were heard.
Your ears perked up,looking around the forest.
Being dark,you could see clearly because of your...Well,'powers'.
Which weren't so special at all.
You looked over to the tree you were under and had an idea.
You picked up your sister,and put her on the highest,safest branch.

"Stay here and hold on tight.If you don't make any noise,you're gonna be fine.If something does happen,just warn me." You softly whisper.

"Wha-What about you?"

"I'm gonna be fine.Just stay quiet,and you'll be safe.Remember,i love you." You gently pecked her forehead.

A small,frightened smile appeared on her lips.

"Lo-Love y-you too."

You gently patted her head and jumped out of the tree,following the rustles.
As you almost reach where the sounds were coming from,it becomes quiet.
Too quiet.
You growl and keep walking,only to find the famous killer leaning against a tree,with a smirk on his face.
His carved smile became slightly bigger.

"Thought you could get away,hm?" He chuckled,flipping his knife in his hands.

You growled,your ears dropping back down as your tail flopped down as well.

"What the fuck do you want?" You hissed,your small,yet sharp teeth showing.

He softly laughed walking over to you.
You didn't move.
You didn't want to show fright to him.
He smirked,putting the tip of his knife under your chin,gently lifting your face up.

"You." He softly committed.

You?
What the hell does he mean?

"What?" You growled,removing your face from his knife.

"I've decided to spare you,mortal.Be fucking happy about that."

You scoffed and rolled your eyes.

"Anyways,back to the damn subject.We've seen that you're 'different'..." He said,eyeing your ears and tail.

"No fucking shit,Joker." You smirked.

He growled,but quickly held his calm.

"And we want you to come with us."

Your ears perked up once again at the words that came out of the killers' mouth.
Why did he want you,exactly?
And where?

"Yeahhh,no."

He then laughed.
His psychotic laugh that made shivers go down your spine.

"You're such a funny girl,hun.Nobody says 'no' to this guy."

"Well,guess what i just did?"

He then smirked,as your tail slightly twitched in confusion.

"You see,we will bring you with us.Either the easy or the hard way."

You tilted an eyebrow at him.

"I think i'll take the hard way." You smirked.

"As you wish." He smirked.

He snapped his fingers and quickly after,screams were heard.
Screams from Raven.
You slightly gasped,looking wide-eyed at Jeff.

"If you would safe your precious sister,i think you should go find her." He laughed his psychotic laugh.

Before you could even react,you found yourself running.
Your legs were moving non-stop,in hopes of saving your sister.
By the time you reached her screams,you found yourself frozen.
Once again,one of those creepy teens were holding her.
No,no,not the ones you saw.
This was another one.
His neck was cracking and twitching non-stop while holding a hatchet onto your sister's throat.
Small whimpers escaped from her mouth as tears flooded down to her red cheeks.
You wanted to run over to her,until a cold hand grabbed your shoulder.

"Ah,ah,ah.One more step and her head is gone."

Small tears started to fall out of your eyes as well.
The guy holding your sister smirked,his mouthguard slightly tilting up.
He pressed the hatchet harder onto her neck,making sobs escape her mouth.

"Now,this was not my choice.It was yours.I will repeat this one more time..."

"Are you coming with us?"