Luke - The weather was freezing and even with the fire and heater on the house was still icy. Luke wore a heavy sweater and socks and he felt fine but your teeth still chattered. "You're still cold, babe? Here," he unfolded a blanket and covered you with it yet he could still see goosebumps on your exposed neck, "I'll be right back." and after two minutes he was. He brought back hot chocolate and wrapped you in his arms while the liquid settled. "I'll keep you warm."
Michael - Even years later you could still remember the first night you and Michael slept in the same bed. It was exciting and nerve wrecking but it remained one of your favorite memories. The way you both laid next to each other without saying a word, him trailing a finger up and down your arm seeing the goosebumps come and go with each unexpected tender touch. You could see the happiness in his eyes as he noticed your body reacting to him. Michael could actually see the effect he had on you and nothing beat that.
Calum - Watching a scary movie worked every time for Calum. It was the only time you would be quiet during a movie but his favorite part wasn't that, it was that you clung to him like a barnacle. He loved feeling needed and as if he could protect you from the supernatural. All of a sudden a bloody doll appeared and you screamed. Calum even felt your skin contract goosebumps so he rubbed your arms and kissed your forehead, "It'll be okay Y/N." you nodded but that same night you and Calum had a hard time falling asleep.
Ashton- Ashton took his headphones off, and handed them to you, "Listen to this," you adjusted the headphones to fit on your head and pressed play. Ashton looked at you expectantly which you soon realized why. It was his voice singing a song of his own creation. It started slowly but the beat increasingly got stronger. The song was about you. It was so good that when you handed him his headphones back he grabbed your arm, "It gave me goosebumps." Ashton smiled and kissed your arm before releasing it.
