Imagines with Ben Fankhauser (REQUESTS OPEN AND REALLY NEEDED!)

Truth or Dare

This chapter is dedicated to Mikefaistisawsome ! They requested this a long time ago and im just now getting around to finishing it lol. I hope I don't disappoint! Also, that thing about me posting regularly probably wont happen bc a bunch of shit hit me recently and im trying my best to handle it but ya know 🤷‍♀️. Ok on to the story!

"Hey, thanks for coming guys, it means a lot." Josh said as he brought out plates of food for everyone. His housewarming party was a lot of fun so far, mostly just the cast talking and drinking. We had played some party games as well, a lot like a middle schooler party would.

"Anyone have any suggestions of what to play?" Josh asked, sitting down on the soft rug , everyone following his motions.

"Hows truth or dare?" The group was in total agreement of Bens suggestion. I was a little nervous, everyone always asks questions about love lives and i wasnt sure if i was ready to out my crush on Ben or not yet.

"Alright alright. Ummmm, Tommy! Truth or dare."

"My italian instincts are tellin' me to go for da dare, Andrew."

"Okay. I dare you to........ do a strip tease to "Brooklyns here"."

"Is that all you got?"

The short man stood up and DeMarius had started playing the song on his phone. We were all cracking up as he sunk lower to the ground, going as far as to crawl torwards andrew and start grinding on the floor. The song ended and he looked thoroughly upset.

"Well, that was quite the dare." Andrew looked scarred for life and shook his head, almost as if to erase the image from his mind. (Newsflash: its impossible)

"Okay, lets go with....y/n. Truth or dare?"

"I guess truth."

I hesitated with my answer as nerves built up in my body, terrified of what he would ask.

"Which one of us do you like most?"

I took a look around the group, watching the men jokingly suck in their guts and sut up tall. All of them but one.

"Id have to go with, Ben F."

Bens POV

My head shot up as my name left her mouth. I assumed she meant as a friend, we were pretty close after all. Still, the butterflies in my stomach were set a flutter once again, just the thought of the possibility alone is enough to do that to me. There were a few more rounds, a couple involving deepest darkest cast secrets and others with beyonce riffs from yours truly. Ben cook finally got his shot to ask a question or give a dare, and he brought it back around to the first time y/n got asked who she liked.

"Y/n, lets see. We already know that Fank here is your favorite, somehow." He mumbled that last part under his breath, almost offended the answer wasnt himself.  He continued on with his point, raising his voice level back up to ask, "but which one of us would you most like to go out with? We're talking fancy dinner, you know. Go out to DeGrezia, get some Antipasto Toscano, a nice bottle of 1998 Castello di Ama Chianti Classico."

"Umm...."

My palms felt sweatier each time she glanced around the large living room, absorbing the looks of all the men there.

"Id have to go with Ben F again, honestly."

"What! Are you kidding me? Okay, to each his own i guess."

I almost missed everything ben cook was ranting about as i locked eyes with y/n. I couldn't believe out of all of these guys she would most want to go out on a date with me. I couldnt forget about it the entire rest of the night.

Your POV

Oh crap. Everyone knows now. I mean, it cant be a bad thing i suppose, just one of the most embarrassing moments in my life if he doesnt feel the same way. I cant even imagine what would happen if someone suggested we played spi-

"How bout a few rounds of spin the bottle? We have plenty of them here!"

"Only if its the 7 minutes in heaven version!"

"All agreed?"

"Lets do a few rounds of just kissing first, I'll need a couple more rounds before im ready for those 7 minutes."

Well fuck. All i could do at this point was pray i didnt spin it on ben or that he wouldnt spin it on me, im too scared to know what the reaction would be.

After a couple rounds of anthony Zas spinning it to the same swing and vice versa over and over, someone finally chimed in and forced him to give the bottle to someone else. Unfortunately, this someone else happened to be me.

"Spin it, y/n!" 

My hand shook hard as i twisted the bottle left and abruptly pushed it to the right. It spun on the carpet for a little bit miraculously, landing on tommy bracco. Before i could move, everyone was switching around and moving places until tommys spot was replaced with-

Ben.

Of course.

A chorus of "ooohs" surrounded us as we leaned in closer to each other. I felt tingles rush up my spine as we moved in, inch by inch. I softly closed my eyes as he did, and tried not to crack up as i was near kissing this man. The next thing i knew was sensational. His perfectly pink lips caressed mine in a way that made all other mouths seem like a course rock grinding along pavement. His were soft, smooth, wise in the direction they were to move. We pulled away after a second but almost immediately reconnected, ignoring the stares and giggles of the other cast members.

As to not have a string of saliva residing as we rested, we stopped sooner rather than later. Some of our friends were dumb founded, jaws agape while others were handing each other money, bets I suppose. We didn't care, we just went back to our spots and stared at each other the rest of the game. We almost didnt notice when others left until josh was cleaning up.

"Hey love birds, its great that you two had an amazing makeout sesh and are deeply in love now, but im deeply in love with my house being clean. Get a trash bag or get out."

"Oh, uh, right. Whats your plans, y/n?"

"Oh, um, probably go grab some food and head home."

"Right, yeah yeah of course! Do you have your car?"

"No i walked. Why?"

"Its just that its cold and dark outside, a-a-and we wouldnt want any creeps hitting on you or anything. Plus Jeremy was my ride here and he left a while ago."

"Well, what do you suppose we do?"

Ben and i locked eyes and smiled for a while, inturrupted by josh.

"For petes sake walk her home already!"

"Will do. Bye josh."  Ben said, grabbing his coat from the couch.

"Thanks for having us!"

"Yeah yeah, just make sure to be safe you two!"

Sucky ending, i know. I hope you guys didnt mind that this chapter is A LOT of conversation! I try not to do that but sometimes i cant help it.