Spike - The Bronze. You order drinks and enjoy the live music.
Buffy - Patrolling. It's a relatively quiet night, but you accomplish some slayage.
Willow - Coffee shop. You chat shyly over steaming cups of sweet tea.
Xander - Cinema. You watch a film and hold hands all the way through it.
Tara - Book store. You pick out a book for each other.
Anya - Restaurant. A newplace in Sunnydale with really good fajitas.