A/N: Reader x Olivia
Backstory: Y/n has a friend called Demi, (I have a friend called Demi that's why I always call like girl side characters Demi cause she's literally the only person who knows me truly without having to ask me) the two have been binge watching Greys Anatomy and Olivia feels like a third wheel because... well she is. Until Demi meets someone and then they all grow to live with one another.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Y/n and Olivia were fast asleep and when Olivia turned around she felt another body behind Y/n, she opened her eyes and looked to see Demi fast asleep. She moved back confused and sat up, glancing between the two to see Y/n and Demi out like a light and in the exact same position.
"Y/n." Olivia breathed out,
"Mhmm?" Both Y/n and Demi hummed out, Y/n groaned and turned around,
"Demi? What're you doing here?" Y/n asked,
"McBoring turned out to actually be really boring."
"Really?" Y/n gasped out slightly, Demi nodded her head.
"Yeah! I mean I ask what he does and guess what he says?"
"Bartender?"
"Yeah! How'd you know?"
"He seemed like a bartender." Y/n hummed out,
"I thought so too! But then—"
"Hello!" Olivia cut off between the two, both Y/n and Demi turn to Olivia,
"What's up?" They ask at the same time, Olivia glanced between the two.
"What— What're we doing? Why are you here?" Olivia asked confused, she glanced between the two.
"She went on a date with a boring guy, she's upset." Y/n explained.
"Yeah, me so sad." Demi pouted out making Y/n giggle. Olivia glanced between the two and sighed,
"I'll get the drinks..." She mumbled before leaving the room, Y/n moved up to the middle so Demi had more room.
"So, what happened on the date?" Y/n questioned.
"He was so boring, only talked about himself. His job sounds so boring."
"Could be McWhore."
"Oo, definitely." Demi agreed. The two giving one another a fist bump as they both stare ahead.
****
Y/n and Olivia had a late night last night as they went out for dinner and then when they came back... let's just say a nice rendezvous. Demi knocked on the door before marching into the bedroom.
"Hey, guys. So, I have a date but this time it's with a girl and I don't know what to do. Do I dress casually or—?"
"Say less!" Y/n groaned out, Olivia sighed and her eyebrows furrowed.
"What's going on?" Olivia groaned out,
"Come on, Olivia, we gotta get up. Demi needs help." Y/n explained as she started to place a kiss on her cheek before getting up, Y/n being naked but Demi simply not caring as they continued to talk. "Description?"
"Name's Grace; little sister named Amelia, she likes playing darts, going to bars, is a good cook and—"
"Y/n, what the hell?" Olivia asked as she quickly covered herself,
"What?" Both Demi and Y/n asked confused as they turned to her, Y/n still trying to find clothing naked while Olivia was covering her body.
"I'm naked." Olivia stated,
"Yeah? So, am I?"
"Demi..." Olivia started as she turned to her,
"Oh, don't worry, I'll turn around." Demi said as she turned around, Olivia stared Y/n down and when Y/n put a bra on as well as a hoodie, she put boxer shorts and jeans on with shoes then grabbed Olivia clothes and walked over and helped her put clothes on, placing delicate kisses here and there in a way to make it up to Olivia.
"I'm sorry." She mumbled.
"It's okay. This is nice." Olivia hummed out,
"I can do it every morning." She whispered to her placing a kiss on her lips as she helped her put her jumper on,
"Are you guys done?" Demi asked.
"Yeah, we're okay." Y/n softly said to Demi, Demi turned around to see Y/n taking care of her.
"Aw, cute." Demi let out, making both Olivia and Y/n giggle as they stared into each other smiling. Once Y/n got up, she put her hand out for Olivia and Olivia got up and out of bed. They all walked downstairs,
"Ok, is that all you know?"
"No."
"What more do you know?" Olivia asked as she started to make toast since Demi brought out the butter and a knife and Y/n got plates for the three,
"Her favourite colour is red, she has a little brother, she is 20."
"Oh, so, you're 3 years older than her?" Olivia teased,
"McHottie, not now."
"She's not McHottie, she's McDreamy and then when you date someone they will be McSteamy and we can call—" Y/n paused, "Shit, who was McDick's cousin?"
"Oh, no, you're thinking about Hayden... what'd we call him?"
"Little Spawn. He was younger and cuter."
"Oh, yeah! He was so sweet."
"Yo! You two, keep me up." Olivia complained.
"You don't know him." Y/n and Demi said. Olivia didn't say anything in return, she just listened.
*****
"I'm just wondering why she can't seem to leave us alone for more than 2 hours!" Olivia complained, Y/n sighed,
"She's lonely! Let the girl be lonely—"
"No! No, I can't deal with this—"
"So, what? You're going to leave me?" Y/n asked Olivia, "Fine, if you want to leave, fine. All I'm saying is that she's lonely! Alright? And she's the only person who has ever been there for me when I truly needed her. Throughout the whole 14 years that I've known her, she's been there! She's proved herself."
"And I haven't?" Olivia questioned which made Y/n look down feeling bad,
"I-I didn't mean that... I just... if I killed someone, I'd call her. She's a physco and the best... bad influenced person that I know. She needs a person. And I'm that person. For her. She's a support system but when it's me, I'm her person."
"And what if I want to be that person!" Y/n stayed quiet and looked down, "I'm not broken enough for you..." She mumbled, Y/n looked down. "just say it's true."
"I didn't— It's not that— okay, maybe it is. But she understands—"
"And I don't... because I'm not broken enough."
"I-I love you... Olivia, I do. I just want you to trust me, I want you to trust us—"
"I do! I trust you, and I trust her. I just don't get why she always has to be around us."
"I don't have the heart to tell her because I don't want her too. I just want to live a life with you and her." Y/n expressed as she felt torn, she didn't want to choose between the two and she wasn't going too.
"You tell her everything, you can't tell her just give me and you some alone time."
"We have that alone time—"
"We don't! Why? Because she always and always comes in, during the night, in the morning—"
"Yeah! Because that's just how we are!"
"You are both 23! I have never met two best friends with such separation anxiety." Olivia complained, she sighed, "I'm going for a walk." She stormed off, and left the room to which a few minutes later, Demi bursted in the room.
"I heard everything, I'm sorry—"
"Don't apologise." Y/n dismissed as she turned around and went to her bedside table, staying quiet as she sat down on the edge of the bed, she pulled it open and pulled out a vape pen,
"Dude, don't. I can move out—"
"You've been living here?" Y/n asked confused standing up,
"Yeah, I got a key." Demi scoffed out, almost as if it was a known fact that she had a key.
"Since when?"
"Since you moved in here. How'd you think I got in here?" Demi asked and Y/n looked at her confused until her face relaxed and she shrugged,
"Good point."
"Anyway! Anyway, don't distract me. I'm sorry and I can... relax. Give you two a little more freedom—"
"Right—"
"Left." Demi grinned out, in attempt to make Y/n giggle which she made Y/n turn to her, her eyes narrowed as she let out a small snicker and shook her head.
"I'm just... what if you take it too far? And don't come over at all anymore."
"We can text."
"You never reply, you hate texting, calling, FaceTiming, you want the real person to be there. That's why you broke up with Finn." Y/n expressed.
"But I'm willing to do that for you—"
"No, you're not listening. Ok? I don't want to have to ask you for space just because of a relationship. We swore when we were little—"
"We're not little anymore, Y/n and you know that. Okay? You're always saying how happy now that you're grown, rules can be bent and I want to bend a rule. I know we promised that any relationship wouldn't change us but this time... I pushed to far—"
"You didn't do anything—"
"No, you're not listening to me anymore." Demi scoffed out, "I want you to listen close... I'm literally down the street. I'm not going anywhere. Plus, the only reason I came up here was to actually tell you that I'm moving in with Grace and she lives down the street." Demi explained, "So, yeah, we may be busy but we always find the time for one another! She adores you."
Y/n just sighed and laid down on the bed, lying down on her stomach and her head dug into the sheets.
"What's this really about?" Demi asked.
"She doesn't... understand it."
"Understand what?"
"Our... dark and twisty side! Ok? I need someone to cheer me on and that's you. When I panic, I go to you and cheer me on. If I murder someone, I go to you and you cheer me on and help me out. Why? Because you care about me and I care about you. She might be my lover but you... are my person." Y/n expressed angrily, she sighed and looked down, "I'm going for a shower." She groaned out and headed into the shower.
(2 hours later)
Olivia came back and Y/n was still in the shower, Olivia saw Demi come down with bags and clothes,
"Wha— Where are you going?"
"Leaving. Duh." Demi scoffed out, Olivia's eyebrows furrowed and all colour drained from her face.
"What? Why?"
"Look, we don't have to play stupid here, Olivia. I know about the argument. I live here. Well lived. I'm moving in with Grace, she lives down the street, but anyway! That's irrelevant—"
"I may want some space but that doesn't mean I want you to leave."
"That's what she thinks and honestly, she's not wrong to think that. She's an overthinker, Olivia and so am I. We get that you do it but you do it for a different reason. You do it because you want to know if you're work is good enough. We do it because we have had such shit things happen to us that we've given up on hope ourselves and decided that if we're gonna go through life, it may as well be together as we got into a rhythm of people coming and leaving. It happens." Demi expressed, before she walked past and left, Olivia stood there as she bit her lip out of nervousness.
"C—" She sighed and turned around, "Can you at least tell me where she is?"
"Still here. Don't worry, she didn't leave." Demi dismissed as she could tell that Olivia was thinking it.
"I— I-I wasn't—"
"I know you were. You bite your lip when you're in deep thought and your stance becomes a little more... stiff when you're overthinking and I've noticed that normally Y/n calms or relaxes you when you get nervous. She's in the shower. Been in there for 2 hours." Demi explained, "See you around, Welch!" Demi cheered off with a smile that Olivia knew was a fake one,
"Wait, wait, that's it? You're just leaving?"
"Yeah. Just down the street, why is everyone acting like I'm leaving the fricken state?"
"Well... well when are you next coming over?" Olivia questioned confused, as she walked toward her and stopped in front of her. Demi shrugged, "What do you mean by that?"
"Relax, Welch. What's stressing you out?"
"I may want some more alone time with Y/n but I don't want you going in total. We may not have the connection you and her have but I still... wouldn't mind putting up with you."
"Uhm... I'll accept that I definitely overstepped but... yeah, I don't know." Demi shrugged, "See you around." She started to walk off so, Olivia headed back inside and shut the door, Y/n came downstairs in shorts and a t-shirt. She had her socks and shoes on, and didn't say anything to Olivia.
*****
It'd been an odd time for Olivia and Y/n as Olivia had started filming and had to be dating someone else for the movie that Y/n seemed unbothered about and Y/n wasn't working on a project and Demi had been busy with Grace, so, she mostly spent her days inside, or working out.
Olivia came home from work and saw that Demi was seated outside the door and she looked at it confused,
"She's locked herself inside." Demi said casually.
"What? Why?" Olivia asked worriedly.
"Why does she do anything? I don't know. This is normal, just take a seat and wait." Demi explained, Olivia nodded her head and the two sat on either end of the door.
"Y/n." Olivia called out, "Are you okay?"
"Fine." Y/n fired back quickly.
"Don't be rude, Y/n." Demi ordered which Y/n ignored, Demi rolled her eyes, "Ok, I'm getting bored of this. I've been sat here for two hours. I'll be right back."
"Ok." Olivia agreed, Demi got up and went into one of the spare rooms, "Y/n, can you open the door?"
"I want to nap and be unbothered." Y/n explained,
"I just want to check on you, I'll be nothing but a minute—"
"I'm fine." Y/n sighed out.
Demi stormed out of the room that she was in and had a set of keys, she unlocked the door and moved it, moving Y/n as she was against the door.
"Up." Demi ordered, Y/n ignored her so Demi pulled her up and pushed her onto the bed while Olivia got up. "What're you doing?"
"What am I doing? What're you doing? Why do you have boney... bones?" She asked.
"Oh, stop it! You cannot blame Olivia for something that was bound to happen soon." Demi argued.
"I didn't mean for it—"
"But you did, and now poor Olivia's trying to balance her work life and getting you out of bed," Demi exclaimed silencing Y/n, "she chose you, Y/n. She wants all of you. She wants the mess."
"What if she leaves—?"
"I'm right here." Olivia said but both Demi and Y/n stared her down, she nodded her head and stayed quiet, looking down at the ground. They turned back to one another,
"If she leaves, fine. That's on her. But you do not get to hide, you have so many walls built up. You've always said how you only wanted to get into a relationship if you could truly see it going somewhere, you've only been out with one other person... but Olivia... she brings you a smile that you can't ignore... any longer."
Y/n stared at the ground staying silent,
"She doesn't get it."
"She might... but you won't know because you haven't given her a try."
"That's supposed to be what you do though." Y/n sighed out,
"I know... but I'm asking you - just this once - if she gives you shit advice," Demi turns to Olivia, "sorry Olivia," Olivia shakes her head with a small smile, before Demi turns back to her, "then I will continue to be your person. I'm just asking you to give her something. Anything." Demi expressed. Y/n stayed quiet,
"I'm sorry." She mumbled.
"I am too. You just... need too take a little more time in processing, plus, like I said, I'm just down the street."
"It's not the same. You're always busy and I get it, you're in a relationship. I just... I need my person there, and I need you to cheer me on and I feel like because you're so busy... I don't have anyone to cheer me on because in my mind - for everyone else - they could cheer me on and all I would listen to is you." Y/n expressed,
"So... you feel like with all the courage in the world, mines is the most that matters."
"Yes, because you're my person. I need my safe place to be okay and with me and when you're not with me... everything just feels... shit."
Demi turned to Olivia and Olivia nodded, Demi turned back to Y/n as Olivia moved next to her.
"You know... when you and McDreamy first got together, I felt like this." Demi explained, "I thought that because you got your dream girlfriend... I'd always be second from then on. But then we got even closer," She grinned out, "and I feel happy. Which is why... I'm suggesting all 4 of us live here. So, you can still have that support. So, we. We... can have each other's support." Demi expressed, Y/n staring Demi down with each other, "Is that okay with you?" She asked turning to Olivia who just nodded her head.
"I hate to admit it but I miss hearing you sneak in here so you can lie with us or you just coming in with your news." Olivia grinned out,
"Good, because Grace actually sold the place that we're living in and we had one more day to find a place."
All 3 of them laughed and Y/n smiled,
"Is there anything else you need?" Demi asked and Y/n simply stared at her which made Demi grin, "I love you, Y/n L/n."
"And I love you, Demi Carter." Y/n grinned out as the two pulled each other into a hug which was a very rare thing, although they were close, this was only the second time that they had said: 'I love you' and the 3rd time that they have hugged, one time Y/n thinking that Demi was wanting a hug when in reality she was just stretching, the other time being that their favourite teacher was leaving and they didn't want her to go.
"You got that all from a look?" Olivia asked in confusion,
"Yeah, y'know, she slightly tilted her head and her eyes glistened with a little thing got a plead and it's quite obvious what she was wanting to hear. For someone to say it. She doesn't hear it often." Demi explained to Olivia with such ease, it simply made Olivia smile.
"I see I have a lot to learn."
"Yeah, you better be in for the long haul." Y/n chuckled out.
*****
Olivia and Grace were becoming the new Y/n and Demi and the girls were loving it, Grace found it adorable how early Demi would wake up with Red Bull to which Y/n would then get up, in all fairness, Y/n's bed was big enough for all 4 of them. So, they would sometimes have sleepovers.
Olivia headed downstairs with Grace and the two were talking to see Y/n and Demi in the kitchen making breakfast and being so in sync, going under one another's arms, Y/n putting the toast in and then she would switch with Demi, Demi watching the toast and Y/n would wash her hands and the fruit that Demi had cut as two iced latte's were on the island counter for Grace and Olivia.
"That's our girls." Olivia scoffed out,
"I'm glad we're here. Thanks... for letting us stay here." Grace thanked,
"Of course!" Olivia smiled out as the two walked in,
"You're telling me McGrumpy died so then when Finn went over doing the trap, he simply started to cry in the first 3 seconds?" Y/n asked confused,
"Yes! I was getting my stuff, Grumpy was there, Finn as well. He answered the door, I asked for my things and he started to cry."
"What's the 'trap'?" Both Olivia and Grace asked in sync.
"He was manipulating her in trying to stay longer as Finn misses her." Y/n explained as she went underneath Demi's arms, the two switching again but Y/n putting the slices of bread on two plates and buttering it then cutting it in half and setting it down, Demi moved the plates toward Grace and Olivia,
"Thank you." The girls thanked, Demi smiled at the two before going to grab four slices of bread and put it in the toaster, Y/n grabbed two bottles of water.
"Anyway! So, once I got my things, he kept asking why I couldn't stay longer."
"Someone's desperate." Y/n scoffed out,
"Exactly! He was so desperate, and for what? Because I'm good in bed?"
"Oh, wow. Boohoo, he can go to a strip club." Y/n complained,
"That's what I said!"
Olivia and Grace started to giggle and the girls antics.
*****
Olivia, Demi and Y/n were walking down an aisle as they were going food shopping and both Y/n and Demi were acting like children, Olivia having to set rules and tell the two off as Grace was at the bathroom. Grace finally came back and saw that Demi pushed Y/n into the cart,
"Ow!"
"I didn't mean that!" Demi laughed out,
"Olivia!" Y/n groaned out, looking up at her and Olivia turned to Demi with a taunting look as she picked up a bag of chips.
"Grace, can you handle your girlfriend? They both keep acting like 5 year olds." Olivia explained,
"Ok, who started it?" Grace asked to which the two pointed at one another and Demi moved the watermelon that was wrapped carefully atop of Y/n's stomach,
"OH—"
"Demi Anne Willow Carter!" Grace complained, Y/n and Olivia gasped,
"Oh, not the government name." Both Olivia and Y/n giggled out. Y/n moved the watermelon out the way and Demi helped Y/n out. Grace grabbed Demi by the ear and dragged her around.
"How do you know it works?"
"It works with both of them." Grace explained. Olivia looked at Y/n as her eyes lit up,
"Grace!" Y/n complained, Olivia grabbed her by the ear and dragged her along, both Y/n and Demi saying: 'Ow' each step they took as whenever they stopped for something, the girls let go.
*****
Y/n couldn't sleep as she was filled with thoughts and when she had tried to go into Demi and Grace's room, she heard moaning so she quickly turned around and went back into her and Olivia's room, once she shut the door, Olivia moved up.
"Who is it? Grace? Demi?"
"Neither." Y/n sighed out, Olivia opened her eyes and sat up.
"Y/n? What're you doing up? Is everything okay?"
"I have a lot on my mind and—" Grace moaned loud enough for both Olivia and Y/n to hear. "and yeah, they're... occupied."
Olivia giggled and sat up,
"What's up? Talk to me."
"I have a lot of writing ideas but I can't get them out of my head."
"Well what are they?" She asked, Y/n grinned and started to grab sheets of paper and pins, "What're you—"
"Give me a second." Y/n said, she wrote something and then pinned it on the wall, Olivia turned the lights on and went to the edge of the bed as Y/n started to write on another sheet of paper.
"Thriller?" Olivia read out,
"Yes, so, I'm thinking that" Y/n stopped writing and decided that she'd just go from there. "I want to write a thriller and I sort of have an idea but I don't know if it can go anywhere."
"What's the idea?"
"I'm thinking... that there is a group of 5 people, three girls, two boys. They have a series of school events and during one of them, something happens... some sort of possession. And the 5 characters have to try and survive it as it seems to go through each and every one of them at some point throughout the trilogy—"
"Wait, this is going to be 3 movies?"
"Yes. I think that if it's spread out through 3 movies, it'll be better. Anyway, the reason that it cicles through the 5 is because the main character got into an accident and knocked over something old that released the devil, or so people thought, she got visions of it and saw flashes of different things and because it broke, the people around her started to suffer until it tried to get to her. But she was already steps ahead as she realised who bumped into her to release the devil as there was a killing that night. So, the main character, Kaitlyn, thinks that she had bumped into the haunted object because of a killer who was already possessed by the Sheriff." Y/n explained, "Does that make sense?"
"Sorta."
"Ok, so, during one of the tasks, a possessed killer arrives and they have to try and survive it. Kaitlyn gets knocked over which releases the devil from the object that the Sheriff had placed as he was after blood. Kaitlyn's girlfriend's blood. When she has her hands on the broken pieces of the possessed object, she sees flashes of things that had happened that proves that the devil's innocent but since people are so scared of the devil, they take it as haunting."
"OH! Right, gotcha." Olivia hummed out, "So, who's going to be Kaitlyn's girlfriend?"
"I need a name."
"Abby?"
"Eh, maybe. But I want to write ou the plan but the one thing I need to figure out is how it can go through each and every one of them." Y/n expressed as she sighed and turned around.
"Well I'll be here when you figure it out."
Y/n smiled and as Olivia went and got Y/n's MacBook and opened it up for her, went on word and set it up, Y/n had started to write on post-its and placed it all over the wall in front of her as she wrote. By the time that Olivia had woken up, she saw that Y/n shut her MacBook screen shut and moved back quietly as she stared at the post-it notes.
"Someone's been busy." Olivia announced herself being awake as she got up and wrapped her arms around Y/n's neck, she leaned back into Olivia and moved her head up slightly.
"I have been." She sighed out, the two letting out small giggles.
"Why don't you come lie down with me? Mhmm?"
Y/n nodded her head and Olivia removed her arms and stood up normally, Y/n got up and turned around to Olivia putting her on her shoulder making her laugh.
"Wee! Back to bed, Miss Welch." Y/n giggled out as she laid Olivia down and rested atop of her and her body being in between Olivia's legs. The two being happy wrapped in each other's arms.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------