Here is the top voted story that you guys chose! Sorry it took me a bit longer to put this one out, I didn't want to burn myself out.
I hope you enjoy (because I love writing for him, seriously)
*LEMON*
Toshinori sat on the bed and rubbed his eyes. He took in a deep breath as the silence filled house made his brain spiral into a thousand different stories and thoughts. He looked at his hands as his world began to darken around him.
He could no longer protect himself, he couldn't protect anyone. But most of all, he couldn't protect you. His hands ran through his hair as his leg bounced up and down.
Were you going to leave him? Would you being to think less of him because he wasn't number one anymore?
No, she wouldn't.
He couldn't even help but think, that he wouldn't be able to pleasure you...uhm...sexually. "I hate this."
He heard the front door unlock and a sound of someone fumbling inside.
"Toshi! I'm home!"
He stood up from the bed and went into the living room to see you holding a large box filled with paper work and a bag that held your laptop that hung over your shoulder.
He had a soft smile on his face as he watched you set your things down with a huff as you smiled to yourself, pleased that you carried all that in.
It amazed Toshinori, even though he was retired and was VERY well off, you still kept your job plainly because you knew it was important.
"(Y/n)." He sighed walking toward you as your smiling face turned to him. He held you in a tight hug, even though he was smaller now, his height still towered over you as he rested his chin on your head.
"I missed you." His chest grumbled as he calmly spoke. "I saw you this morning." You rubbed his back as he relaxed into you, your touch was sweet as you held him close. "Still...you make my day so much better by just being in the same room."
"I love you Toshinori." You leaned up and kissed his cheek quickly dodging as he coughed out blood from being suprised. You went and got a tissue, dabbing the crimson liquid from his chin.
"Thank you...what would I do without you?"
"Have a bloddy chin." You smirked at him as you turned to go throw away the tissue. You yawned, "What do you want for dinner?" You began to sift through the kitchen, looking in the pantry and fridge for things to make.
"Let's make something together. I want to help, you are still working, the least I can do is cook some dinner." He said following in behind you, his army green pants dragging across the floor with every step he took.
"You worked for years being a hero, you risked your life...I can make you dinner and grade some kindergarten papers."
"I'm not a hero anymore." His eyes lowered to the floor as you looked at him, the smile falling from your lips. "What's wrong Toshi? You can talk to me." He sat on the couch as you followed suit, sitting beside him with your hand on his.
"Hey..." You said, his eyes trailing to you. "Talk to me. We have been here for eachother for 20 years, I may not understand what you are going through but I can be support for you."
Your hand squeezed his. What did he do to deserve you? You had known eachother since you were in your early 20's and Toshinori was in his early 30's. It was funny how you met, All Might showed up to teach your kindergarten class about being a hero and then you two began to talk.
The more you two talked the more interested he became. He began to open up to you after a year and showed you his true form, telling you about how his quirk was inhereted.
When he got in the accident, you were there by his side, not caring at all if his quirk lasted forver or not. You just wanted to make sure he stayed alive.
Only a handful of people knew about your relationship with All Might, Principal Nezu, Nighteye and Naomasa. He was always worried about villians coming after you because you were special to him, so he couldn't take that risk.
He was suprised when you gave him a soft nod of understanding, agreeing to keep your realtionship on the down low. Even from your own parents.
"I can't do anything about the inevitable downfall. For years I was apart of the action...but now all it seems I can do is sit and watch. Just hoping that young Midoryia pushes through."
"He will." You lifted his head to look at you. "You may not be a hero anymore, but look at what you did while you WERE a hero. You saved so many lives, kept us all safe for years. I haven't met Midoryia, but from what you have told me, he is willing to do whatever it takes."
He held you close to him as his hands caressed your back. "Please don't leave me." Your breath hitched in your throat, "Why would I leave you?" You questioned holding him to you, holding onto the fabric of his white tank top.
"I'm not number one anymore. Everything I stood for is gone now, crime has increased 3% and I-"
His rambling was cut off by your lips on his. You slung your arms across his shoulders, him laying down on the couch with you on top of him. His tounge licked your lips swiftly asking for entry.
You pressed your body against his and let his muscle explore your mouth. He pulled away for a brief moment, "(Y/n)..." He spoke in a raspy tone as his hands wandered under your shirt, feeling your soft skin against his calloused fingers.
He kissed you once again while your hands ran through his hair. You gasped as you sat up, his eyes looking at your curiously. "Hey. How about I make you your favorite dessert?! It always makes you feel better!"
Before he could even answer you rolled off of him slightly falling on the floor with a thud as your foot got caught. "I'm okay!" You said running to the kitchen, him chuckling at your odd switch in character.
I really hope I don't fuck this up, today is NOT a good day to mess this up
(Y/n). It's Strawberry Shortcake....I have made it before. I should be fine.
You grabbed all of the ingredients reminding yourself once again that over half of it is just whipped cream and strawberries.
After about an hour, you took the four small cakes out of the oven since you made enough for only the two of you. Grabbing two plates you set one cake on each plate and grabbed the whipped cream.
You carefully placed it on the cakes, making sure it was just enough but not too much. You then grabbed the cut strawberries, placing them in the whipped cream before grabbing the other cakes and placing them on top.
You dolloped more whipped cream on top and grabbed the slices strawberries once again. You cracked your neck as you slowly began lowering the strawberrries on top one by one.
"Toshinori Yagi, I can feel you staring at me and I swear All Might that if you make me mess this up I will be so furious!"
"You swear to me?" He asked pointing a finger to himself as your hunched back was still facing him. "You know what I meant." You grumbled placing the last few strawberries on top.
"DONE!" You cheered, turning around, hiding the cakes behind your back. You looked at your lover who was now inches away from you. "Nah-ah! Go sit down and I will bring it to you." You crossed your arms and stuck your nose up in the air.
He shook his head at your childish display before grabbing your hips and kissing you sweetly. "You're so good to me." You twirled the thick strands of hair that came down infront of his face.
"You deserve someone who is amazing Toshinori. So I try." You playfully smiled at him. He leaned his forehead on yours, "You never have to try. As long as I have you, that is all I need." You kissed his nose, patting his shoulders.
"Quit trying to suck up to me to get closer to the dessert and go sit down." He groaned trudging his way toward the table and plopping down in his seat.
He heard you laugh to yourself and raised a brow, being unable to see you as he sat. He saw your leg extend from behind the wall and heard your voice.
"Be....our..."
You twirled out from around the corner with an apron on over your outfit while you sang. "Guest, be our guest put our service to the test
Tie your napkin 'round your neck, cherie and we'll provide the rest..." You tucked a napkin in his shirt as you walked behind him.
"Soup du jour, hot hors d'oeuvres why, we only live to serve try the grey stuff, it's delicious, don't believe me, ask the dishes. They can sing, they can dance after all, sir, this is France and a dinner here is never second best!" You spun around making him laugh in amusement as he watched you put your heart and soul into this.
"Go on, unfold your menu, take a glance and then you'll be our guest oui, our guest, be our guest!!!" You held the note running into the kitchen and brining out the two plates setting one infront of him.
His laugh echoed through out the house as he applauded you. "Encore!" He shouted, your eyes went wide. "I didn't prepare an encore!" You faked your panic as you sat down next to him, kissing his cheek.
He looked down at the nicely made strawberry shortcake and his eyes lit up. He grabbed his fork, stabbing into it quickly and shoving into his mouth, sighing contently as the fluffy texture hit his tounge.
You took a bite, more calmly then he did, pride growing in yourself as it had turned out better than expected. "This is amazing (Y/n)." He said covering his mouth so you didn't see him chewing his food.
"I hope so, I want to just make you happy." He smiled at you, shoving another large bite in his mouth, half of his dessert was gone already. "Don't make yourself sick." You commented, taking another bite.
He waved his hand dismissively, "I know....".
After a few more moments Toshinori stood up, grabbing your empty plates, and headed to the kitchen to wash them. You cleared the table and went into the bedroom, changing into your sleep wear before brushing your teeth and collapsing on the bed.
You waited for a few moments until you realized the sink was no longer on and the faint sound of the TV could be heard. You got up and walked to the living room, standing back as you looked at Toshinori who was staring at the screen.
"I think what we are all learning is that we might be in danger with the loss of All Might. The crime rate is slowly rising and it doesn't seem to be slowing."
The news reporters voice made your heart sink. You felt helpless, like your voice and efforts were being drowned out. No matter how hard you tried it seemed for every one happy moment you gave him, the world gave him 10 more moments of agony.
You walked up behind him and wrapped your arms around his frame while you leaned your head on his back. "I'm going to bed...you should too." You suggested. You felt him raise your hands to his lips as he kissed them, but let them drop softly.
"I can't." He walked away from you leaving you standing there, the light from the TV being the only brightness. You rubbed your arms and hung your head as you turned around and went back to the bedroom.
It felt cold and empty as you laid there, the large mattress was too much for a single body to be in alone. You hugged a pillow to your chest letting out a soft whimper while a few stray tears fell down your face as you stuggled to sleep.
When your alarm went off the bed was still the exact same way it was the night before. Telling you he didn't ever come to bed. Your heart twisted at the sight, as you got up getting ready for work.
He was already gone, as usual, considering he had to be at UA VERY early. You assumed he had slept on the couch based on the fact that there was a blanket slightly draping onto the floor.
You packed yourself a lunch and grabbed your bag, leaving the house in silence. The day seemed to keep getting longer the more that time passed. You felt immovable, though you had a smile on your face with an attitude to match, your mind wasn't focused as it usually was.
You watched the students mess around with eachother, occassionally having to hound them about being too violent with their quirks. Finally the day ended, you requested the next day off, hoping that some time to think would make it easier.
But you were wrong.
You sat alone waiting, just wanting Toshinori to get home so you could hold him and cry. But an hour passed, then two, then three and soon it was 12 in the morning and he hadn't even messaged or called you.
Your lips quivered as you laid down on the couch, holding the blanket he used last night to your body for some semblance of relief. The smell of him lingered on the fabric, making your lungs burn as you began to quietly sob.
You had no idea what was going on. You knew he wasn't telling you the full story and frankly, you felt useless to him. When he was All Might you always struggled to see him considering he had work, but now that you can see him as you wish, it seems the struggle has been getting through to him.
You shook your head and sat up wiping your eyes as you took a shakey breath in.
"Okay (Y/n), he is going to probably be upset at you for this but at this point it needs to be done. Tomorrow you are going to march into UA and tell him that he needs to be open! You may not understand but you can help him!"
You let yourself fall back down with a huff pulling out your phone. You messaged Nezu letting him know you would be coming by tomorrow and to try and keep it on the down low. Despite your frustration, you didn't want the whole school to know about you and All Might, but a few students could be spared.
You set your phone down as you closed your eyes. "You're kinda dramatic sometimes you know that?" You spoke to yourself with a laugh. "Yup. And I love it." With a smile you fell asleep with your game plan for tomorrow.
You woke up at 6:30, shooting off of the couch and getting changed and ready. You were so pumped for this, goddamn it he would fucking talk to you if it was the last thing he did!
You had had it with this on and off sulking you both had been doing for a month. You wanted Toshinori back, you wanted to show him him much you loved him.
You got in your car and drove to UA, you began to second guess yourself however as you stood infront of the large gates. The doors opened and your eyes travled down to see Nezu waiting for you. "Long time no see." He waved.
You gave him a short smile. "Yeah, you look well." You began to walk with him as he took you toward the large dorms that you had only heard about through word of mouth. "I'm suprised Toshinori wanted you here, isn't your relationship still private?"
"Oh yes it is, he doesn't know I am coming." You had a focused gaze on the buildings ahead of you, Nezu being suprised for a moment and then nodding.
"Ah, he is closed off even to you? He spent the whole last night just walking around the campus because he said he 'couldn't go home'. Did something happen between you both?"
You sighed. "Not really, there wasn't an argument...it just feels like no matter how hard I try, my small words of encouragement get blocked out by societies booming voice." Nezu lightly chuckled.
"(Y/n), if there is one person who can get through his thick skin, it is you." He paused looking up at the large doors. "(Y/n), he is in here but class 1-A and their instructor are having breakfast, are you sure you want people to know?"
You puffed air out of your nose. "I don't think there is a major threat anymore considering he isn't one. If anything it would just be some crazy fans pissed off at me."
Nezu laughed, "Sometimes those are the worst." You chuckled, your heart speeding up as you grabbed onto the door handle. "Good luck. Let me know how it goes." He said waving to you as he turned and walked away. You shit your eyes, taking a deep breath as the door creaked open.
You heard chatter from a few rooms down, you assumed that is where their breakfast room was. You slowly walked toward the room and stopped at the sound of Toshinori's voice.
"Young Midoryia, I promise I am okay."
"No disrespect All Might sir, but you don't look okay...."
"I'm f-"
Before he could finish his sentence, you stepped around the corner. "No you're not." His eyes went wide as they landed on you, the students all gazed at you in confusion.
"Quit lying Toshinori." You crossed your arms and locked your eyes on his. "(Y/n)...why are you here?" He asked confused as he stood up.
But his confusion could not even compare with how off guard the students were right now.
"You didn't come home last night and I got ya know worried?! What kind of question is that?" You fumed at him. He walked toward you with a huff. "How many people saw you?"
"Does it matter?" You asked glaring at him.
"Yes! Because you could get hurt!" He stood inches away from you as you both clashed. "So what?!"
"Are you serious!? So what? People could want to kill you to get to me!"
"Then answer your phone once and a while!"
"I would have come home later, why couldn't you just wai-"
"IF YOU WERE ME YOU WOULD HAVE DONE THE SAME!" You raised your voice shutting him down as he looked at you.
"Y-you sit for hours watching the news on the people that want All Might back. You have been the hero since I first met you and years before that. We have been together for years and I..." You choked trying to hold back tears.
"I want to help, but I can't understand what is going on if you don't talk to me Toshi. I feel like I can't do anything when you have the whole world telling you how much they need All Might...I just feel like I don't do anything."
Your eyes met with his once again as he walked toward you, pulling you into a hug. You tightly gripped his shirt as he stroked your hair, calmly sushing you while you calmed down.
"(Y/n), you deserve so much better then what I have ever given to you...the late nights where you didn't know if I would come back, the days on end I would be in the hospital...I should never had made you feel like your words held no meaning."
His arms wrapped around you, pulling you into him. "Everything you say matters to me. The small gestures, the whole desserts-" he lifted up your head and wiped the tears from your cheeks. "- you make me so incredibly happy. I guess that I still have some explaining to do...I promise when we get home I will tell you everything."
"All of it?" You asked with a sniffle.
"All of it." He kissed your lips quickly before his attention fell back on the students and now his fellow staff member who were still standing perplexed.
"Who is she?" Aizawa grumbled to his friend looking in between the both of you. "Ah, yes- mhm...students, Aizawa, this is (Y/n). My girlfriend."
You watched as a few of the students screamed in disbelief, sat in silence, or in one boys case he began to fumble on his words and mutter to himself as he pointed at you.
"H-how long??" The mumbling boy said. You assumed this to be Midoryia based on what you had heard.
Toshinori cleared his throat, rubbing the back of his neck as he looked at you. "About 20 years." Midoryia fell to the floor as others heads fell onto the table or they leaned onto it to help them stand.
"Y-you have been dating someone for 20 y-years??? How did no one find out?!" Midoryia said sitting up a bit.
"Well we never got married because we knew that someone would find out if we did, so it was just a lot of hide and go seek pretty much."
You nodded and smiled at him. Midoryia stood up, walking over to All Might as everyone freaked out to eachother. "Does she know about uhm..." He motioned his finger to himself, Toshinori letting out a laugh.
"Yes I do. But I have known for a while so don't worry, it's safe with me." You winked, Midoryia nodded in appriciation. "Are you a hero?" Another student asked, a nervous smile grew on your face. "Ah...no, I am a kindedgarten teacher." You waved your hands.
"So you have to deal with newly developed quirks?" Midoryia questioned, imagining that it must be hard to deal with children with brand new powers. You nodded. "Yes, they can be a bit much sometimes but as long as they remember to be kind to others, it doesn't matter."
You heard a grunt and looked over at an ash blond boy with spikey hair. "You were a problem child, weren't you?" Your close eyed smile and a sour undertone made a shiver go down the students spines. You were suprisingly scary for some reason.
He stomped over to you. "WHAT IS THAT SUPPOSED TO MEAN!?!"
"Inside voices." Your eyes grew dark. Even though he was taller than you, you wouldn't tolerate such disrespect. "Alright alright everyone let's calm down." Toshinori said stepping inbetween you both with waving hands.
"Alright. But he needs to keep his temper in check, it won't get him anywhere good." You turned around and began to leave the dorms, telepathically communicating to Toshinori that you were hungry and wanted to go.
"(Y/n)! Wait I have to get my stuff!" Toshinori scrambled to grab his bag. "Still mad at you because you left me alone yesterday!" Your voice echoed from down the hall as he excused him self and followed after you.
"Mr. Aizawa, you didn't even know?" Mina asked looking at her teacher. He shook his head, "No.".
"I can't believe they have been dating for 20 years and no one found out about it! That is a long time to keep a realationship a secret." Ochaco commented.
"Well I imagine it would have been severley dangerous for her considering where his fame stood. Fans and villians would have bombarded her constantly, I am sure he would appriciate it if we kept this to ourselves." Momo sat back down at the table and resumed eating as she looked at her classmates. They all sighed in agreement continuing their breakfast, still chattering about you.
"She's really hot." Mineta said as he scarfed down his food almost choking on it as Iida karate chopped him on top of the head. "Don't make disturbing comments about All Mights significant other!" He reprimanded.
____________________
"I'm sorry for rasing my voice." You apologized walking through the door to your shared home. You dropped your car keys on the table near by as you walked to the bedroom to change out of your clothes.
"You don't need to apologize. I should have told you how much it was effecting me." He followed behind you, watching as you undressed yourself before slipping on some 'home-clothes' as you called them.
You walked over to him and undid the tie that was around his neck, letting it drop to the floor. "Talk to me." You said unbuttoning his shirt. Toshinori took in a deep breath as he began to speak.
"When I was All Might I felt like that was what I was meant to do. Even after I got my injury and Nighteye warned me about my fate, I didn't listen. I knew my power was fading and when it ran out, I guess that I felt lost...like my whole identity was gone."
He slipped the now unbuttoned shirt off his shoulders as he began to undo his belt. "I was scared to talk to anyone because I felt like I would never be satisfied with the answer. I have been number one for so long, but I thought, what kind if hero am I if I can't even figure myself out?". He pulled the belt off from around his waste, his pants now sagging at his hips.
"You are still the best hero. We all have times in our lives when we don't know who we are and yes sometimes we can do it by ourselves, but most times others can help us." You looked up at him as your hands rested on his chest.
"I am here for you and so are all your friends and students. Things are going to be hard, but I will always...ALWAYS, be here." You kissed his cheek as his hands rested on your hips.
"What else?" You spoke leaning back a bit. Spit got caught in his throat as his face began to burn, "oh...uhm....it's kind of embarrassing..." He rubbed the back of his neck, the long strands of golden hair ticklingyour nose.
"Toshi..." You said flipping his hair out of your face. He sighed, "I am scared that I won't be able to make you happy as just me, in general and uh....sexually." You barley heard him as his voice trailed off.
You placed feather light kisses on his chest, your hands running down his skinny yet muscular arms as you replied. " You have always made me happy as both. I would love you just as much either way, I never cared about the fame that you held. I just know that you are a good person and you treat me with respect..."
You looked up at him. "Not to mention you are dashingly handsome." He layed his head on your shoulder breathing a sigh of relief. "Do you want to prove to yourself that you can make me feel good?" Your suggestion made him gasp lightly, his hands snaking his way around to your back and under your shirt.
"Only if you'll let me." He breathed out feeling your soft skin against his fingertips. "Gladly." You kissed his lips eagerly, feeling all over his torso, touching the large scar that resided on his side.
His hands fiddled with the hem of your shirt, slowly dragging it up your body and disconnecting from the kiss briefly so he could pull it over your head.
Lips smashing together once again as the heat became more insense. You began to ache for the man in front of you, he had no idea how much more Toshinori turned you on then All Might, but he was about to find out.
You felt the need for you radiate off of him with every touch and kiss from his slightly chapped lips. You slipped off your shorts, his hands immediately grabbing your ass and lifting you effortlessly.
For a skinny man he was still strong.
"So gentlemanly, taking me to the bed and not doing it in the closet." You joked as he carried you out into the bedroom, mouth kissing up and down your neck. "I'm aching to touch you." He groaned laying you gently on the bed as his hands touched as much of your skin as they could.
The room was dark even though it was broad daylight, the curtians were closed and a small breeze would whisp through every now and then.
He bit at your neck while his fingers tugged down your underwear and groped the soft skin of your thighs. Your core began to throb with anticipation as he slid two fingers against your slit making you mewl.
"You're so wet." He said partially in shock. "I want you Toshinori, only you." You kissed him furiously as his fingers devled into you, your moan getting caught on his tounge as you softly sucked on it.
You hand trailed down his abs and to his breifs, slipping your hand inside and beginning to pump his hardened memeber. "Shit..." He groaned parting from the kiss for a moment in pure bliss.
"Watch your mouth hero~" You teased stroking him the best you could as his fingers went wild inside you. The amazing sensation began to bundle in your abdomen making you arch your back slightly.
Toshinori notcied this and pulled his fingers out quickly, you removing your hand from him as you watched him lick your juices off of his fingers. "Delicious." His electric blue eyes glowed in the darkness of the room.
You sat up, kissing a line down his chest while your fingers played with the band of his boxers. "You want more?" He teased. The look your eyes gave him as he viewed you from above made his heart thud, "Mmm, please..."
He quickly stood up, pulling his underwear off and pinning you to the bed, his pulsing member ready to enter inside you. "Give it to me Toshi~" You begged closing your eyes waiting for your moment of bliss.
And he gave it to you.
His hips slammed into yours as your legs wrapped around his back, you let out a loud moan making a snicker rumble deep in his chest. "More..." you said grinding your hips as best you could while his hand pinned down your wrists.
"Anything for you (Y/n)."
He slammed back into you repetitively, the breath getting knocked from your lungs as the bed rocked with his motions. "Oh fuck!" Shouting, your legs tightened around him, making him seethe.
"Such naughty words from you (Y/n)." He panted, eyes wandering over your face that was contorted in pure satisfaction. Your eyelids peeled open to look at him.
"I-ah! I can't help it when you fuck me like this!" His teeth bit down on your collarbone. "You wanted this." He smirked onto your now sticky skin as his thrusts became stronger.
Your bodies stuck together as your hair became a tangled mess, his own sticking to his forehead and shoulders as you squeezed him tightly. His lips found yours, sloppily inserting his tounge as he freed your wrists allowing him to hold your hips.
With your now freed hands, you pulled on his hair making him growl. Your kiss continued as you moaned from one another, each of you catching them with your lips.
"(Y/n), kiss me harder...." He begged, eyes squeezing shut as he white knuckled your hips. "Cum for me Toshi, I'm close~" Your final pants were heard before your lips sealed together as he spilled into you.
Your climax hit you like a wave of pleasure as you held him inside you, enjoying the feeling of him there.
After a moment Toshinori pulled out and rolled over beside you. "I love you (Y/n)." He heaved as he looked at the ceiling, his head turning to fsce you when you looked at him. "And I will always love you Toshinori."
He huffed a laugh to himself as he smiled. "Should we get married?" He asked looking back at the ceiling as he held your hand. You rolled onto your side and put your head on his chest.
"I mean technically we have been married for 15 years since I moved in with you, but I mean I guess the title wouldn't be too bad to have on it....are you okay with that?"
You traced his scar while he pet your hair lovingly. "Yes. Either way I will give all my love to you (Y/n)." He rolled his body to face yours gently kissed your lips.
"I already give you all of my love." You joked smirking rasing an eyebrow.
"Quit trying to one up me..." He said defeated. "I already have to think of how to propose."
"Do it now. We can get the ring later, that isn't the important part." His eyes widened. "I wasn't ready-" he coughed making you giggle. "WAIT!" He said sitting up, throwing on his boxers before running out of the room.
You sat up and stared at the door. "What?" You asked yourself as you grabbed your underwear and a shirt, putting them on as he came back into the room.
He had one hand behind his back as he walked up to you. "(Y/n). You are the most amazing and important thing in my life. I am so thankful you have spent 20 years with me and have always tolerated my stupidity and awkwardness..."
You smiled at how much of a dork he was being while he got down on one knee. "So (Y/n) (L/n), will you marry me?" You keeled over in laughter as he pulled out a ring pop from behind his back.
He chuckled at your enjoyment, pleased with the reaction he got. "Yes, I will galdly be your wife." You said calming down a bit as he slipped the ring on your finger then standing up to kiss you.
"I love you with ALL my MIGHT." He winked making you snort. "I love you to Toshinori..." You hugged him close.
"Always."
Word count: 5758