Pairing: Sam Kiszka x Danny Wagner x (F) Reader
Word Count: ~6800
Warnings: it's a threeway with HEAVY slash. Don't like it, don't read it. (voyeurism; oral sex w/ M & F receiving; dirty talking; bottom!Sam; Danny is a bit of a dom; fingering all around; protected anal & vaginal sex) 18+ only!
A tumblr friend sent a call to the universe asking for a Sanny x Reader fic inspired by the song Lost in the Fire by The Weeknd. I've been writing Sanny fics for a long time and I never get tired of doing it. I think I was one of the first, if not the first, writer in the fandom to write a Sanny threeway, actually...and I never thought I'd write more of those but I felt very inspired by this song and the idea...even if it doesn't fit your specific image, I hope anyone who reads this enjoys it ;)
—
Sure, you had reconciled with the fact that Sam would never love you as much as he loved Danny. At first, their overwhelming affection and adoration for one another was kind of cute to you. Seeing Sam so enamored with a boy was adorable–quite special, really. You loved that he could love a best friend so fiercely, so passionately. But then it had become clearer and clearer throughout your relationship that you would never be even close to a priority no matter how long you were with Sam or how close you two became–Danny would always be closer, and Danny would always be number one.
So things ended. Amicably enough, thankfully, and you still saw Sam–and by default, Danny–all the time. You were friends. But you weren't sure how to respond when Sam started sending you pictures that showcased more of their friendship than you'd ever imagined. Well, not seriously imagined, anyway.
The first one was almost passable as innocent–a picture of Sam and Danny's arms slung across one another's shoulders, Danny leaning in and pressing his lips to Sam's cheek.
Cute, you texted back.
Jealous? Sam replied.
You balked at your phone. Sam was ridiculous. Of you or of him?
Either
Nope
Hmm...
After that text, he sent you a picture of them actually kissing–Danny was planting a big one right on Sam's mouth and Sam was smiling into it, arm outstretched to capture the moment on his phone.
What about now?
You stared at the picture, flabbergasted. It was kind of hot, you had to admit, but you also felt your chest tighten with bitterness–you'd really tried with Sam. You'd been patient and forgiving, welcoming of how close Danny was to him, but it just never felt like you were enough. Not the perfect fit. And that wore you down more and more until it just all had to end. But here Sam was showing off his perfect match, apparently really trying to make you jealous when you thought all those feelings of jealousy had been buried and forgotten.
You left Sam on read, ignoring his attempt to antagonize you, but later, when you'd nearly forgotten about the pictures, Danny texted you:
Did Sam send pics of us together to you?
You sighed. You weren't really in the mood to get more, but maybe Danny would spare you.
Yes. Did you guys take those just to send to me and make me "jealous?"
Actually no. I didn't even know he sent them until now. I'm really sorry if it upset you
Another sigh. Danny was a sweetheart. Surely he really didn't want to rile you up or hurt your feelings.
It's okay. You guys are good together
Thanks. You and Sam were good together too
You left that alone. As much as you could appreciate the sentiment, you weren't in the mood to travel further down memory lane. But later, when you were lying in bed, you found yourself opening up your texts to look at those pictures again, especially lingering on the snapshot of Sam and Danny kissing. Finally, with a huff you locked your phone and tossed it aside before you tossed yourself into a fitful sleep.
But the next day, the pictures commenced. The first one was sent in the middle of the night and was a perplexing awakening–a picture clearly taken from Sam's POV. You'd recognize that torso anywhere and there it was in clear digital–Sam flat on his back, a string of bright pink bite marks down his stomach and Danny's wild dark curls pressed against his belly. You couldn't see his face, but you also knew that hair anywhere. You sat up in bed rubbing your eyes and once your brain made full sense of the image, you wanted to be mad. You were mad–you could feel the heat rising in your body, the tension growing in your mind, but you also felt a tingle of betrayal shudder through you all the same.
No text accompanied the photo. It was bait and you weren't going for it. If Sam wanted you to be jealous, you weren't going to give him the satisfaction; if he just wanted you to have the pictures for whatever demented reason, you'd accept. But when the pictures kept coming and got progressively more raunchy, you thought the picture of Sam kissing Danny's neck, his hand shoved down Danny's pants, had to be the last one. There was no way it would escalate. But it did–later that night Sam sent you a picture of Danny straight up sucking his dick.
That made you gasp and, without even thinking about it, press the call button.
"Sam!" you shouted when he answered. "What the fuck are you doing? Does Danny know you're sending me all these?"
Sam laughed. Such a bastard. "He didn't at first. But now he does. He's been encouraging me."
You held your face in your free hand, sighing. "Sam. What the hell is wrong with you? I've really worked hard to move past our breakup and I–"
"Y/N, I know. That's not what this is." Sam paused for a second and you sensed he wasn't alone on the other end. "This is an invitation."
You couldn't lie to yourself–you'd thought about it. How could you not after receiving all those pictures? But still the words from Sam didn't make sense in your mind. "What do you mean by that?"
"I mean exactly what I said. We're inviting you to join us." When you didn't respond, Sam continued: "Just for a night, you know? Test it out?"
The words were still bouncing around. Your heart sped up with curiosity. "Let me talk to Danny," you ordered. "I'm sure he's with you right now. Right?" Danny would make it make sense.
Another laugh from Sam. "Yeah, he's here. Hang on." There was a vague shuffle and then Danny's voice was in your ear.
"Danny, please explain this to me," you demanded, growing even more flustered and impatient. "What's Sam talking about?"
"Well, um, I think he kind of said it all."
You let out an exasperated huff. "He did not say it all, Danny. Clearly I need you to spell it out for me."
"We both like you and we want to have a threesome," Danny explained and you could hear Sam laugh in the background. "That's it. If you don't want to, it's totally cool. And I'll tell him to stop sending the pictures."
Maybe it was strange, but when you'd looked at all the photos, you'd never pictured yourself being part of the action. Sam and Danny came as a pair–clearly. Your relationship had ended because of that–and were truly, as far as you were concerned, meant for one another. To get between that seemed strange, not to mention held incredible risk to damage the friendship you were still clinging to with both of them.
You thought about the pictures some more though and felt you landed on some middle ground, unorthodox as it was. But all of this was entirely unorthodox. "What if I watched?" you proposed.
"What? You want to?" Danny asked, the surprise in his voice ridiculous to you given what he and Sam had already proposed themselves.
"Sure. Clearly, Sam's into that."
There was a slight pause, then Danny said, "Okay. Yeah, sure. We're into that too."
It was probably one of the worst decisions of your life. But when you hung up, you couldn't help but feel a little excited about it.
-
You were surprised at how Sam and Danny didn't seem to care at all that you were watching, sitting in the oversized, plush lounge chair that had been hauled from the living room to the bedroom for the big show. You were also surprised at how, as the action progressed and you were seemingly forgotten, sinking back into the walls like you were invisible, you cared less and less as well. Sam and Danny were completely enthralling to watch–Sam was lying half on top of Danny, kissing him like his best friend was made of pure magic, and Danny was cradling the back of Sam's head like he was a precious piece of art. Both things were true in your mind–Danny was like a magical, mystical storm enveloping Sam, who was indeed a rare and beautiful work of art that needed to be treasured.
When Sam smiled into the next kiss, a lightning bolt of jealousy pierced your chest. They looked at one another like they were completely in love, probably because they were. Sam had never looked at you like that. But it made sense. You were just the last in a string of failed girlfriends before Sam finally realized who his true partner was. You could imagine that Danny had been silently waiting and beckoning Sam to come to him for good.
Nevertheless, you couldn't deny that what you were privileged to witness was also painfully hot, even hotter when they both took their shirts off; Sam dipped his head down to begin kissing Danny's neck and Danny's hands roamed Sam's shoulders and back, then up to toy with his hair.
For the first time since they'd begun, Sam addressed you. "Isn't he so hot?" he asked, glancing at you while he ran his fingers over Danny's ribs.
"Very hot," you agreed; Danny blushed in response.
"Did you ever think about fucking him?" Sam continued. The question didn't catch you off-guard, having expected to be a little scrutinized with all the build-up to this event. If nothing else, the conversation probably just made Sam even more turned on.
"Who hasn't?" you replied. You had, not that you'd ever told Sam that. Not that Danny ever showed any interest. And not that Sam would have cared, you realized; on the contrary, you now knew he would have jumped at this opportunity much earlier.
"I know, right?" Sam resumed pressing kisses to Danny' neck, holding the side of his face; Danny nuzzled against his palm and that image made your heart swell. They adored each other so vividly and so overtly.
"I'm surprised you're okay with being watched, Danny," you noted, feeling a little more apt to talking now that Sam had extended that olive branch.
"I said I'd try it. For Sam," Danny told you. Sam smirked against his skin and wiggled down to mouth against his chest. "I don't mind, really. It's just you."
"You like watching?" Sam inquired, peeking at you with his face still pressed against Danny's chest, his cheek resting against his sternum.
"Yeah, it's hot," you said. You could feel your own body literally growing hotter by the second just watching, even more so when Sam finally brought one hand down to Danny's crotch. Your breath hitched as Danny's did too, and he arched up into Sam's touch.
"Just wait 'til you see his dick," Sam said, stroking Danny over his sweatpants. You could see the faint outline, impressively sized, not to your surprise. Sam brought himself to his knees and moved lower, bringing his fingers to the waistband of Danny's pants. "It's so big I can hardly take it."
Your cheeks suddenly burned. "Jesus, Sam."
Sam laughed. "What? It's true!"
"It is true," Danny affirmed, putting both his hands on Sam's head. "But you're gonna take it tonight, right? Show Y/N how good you can be for me?"
You hadn't, however, expected Danny to chime into the dirty talking. It seemed so out of character but it worked, and it had you rubbing your thighs together, starting to feel tortured. But you were going to try to keep up. "You let him fuck you, Sam?"
"Sure do. He's fucking good at it too," Sam said with a rough, low laugh. He pulled down Danny's pants and that impressive dick was free, rock hard and looking heavy against Danny's abdomen. You watched Danny close his eyes as Sam licked straight up his length, cradling his balls in one hand while the other was clenching tight around his hip.
"Is Sam good at sucking dick?" you asked. Danny seemed to be enjoying it already, even with Sam just licking and jerking him off slowly.
Danny nodded, humming, and laced his fingers through Sam's hair. "He's so good at it. He knows just what I like. Why don't you show her, Sammy?"
And Sam did, gripping the base of Danny's cock to prop him up before he went down. Danny was big–the fact that Sam could take half in one go was impressive and you squeezed your thighs together harder, struggling more and more to figure out what to do with your own hands. Meanwhile, Sam knew what to do with his hands. He started to stroke Danny while he sucked and his other hand trailed up Danny's body, palming at his chest before he slipped his fingers into Danny's mouth.
There was no music to curtail the sounds they were both making–Sam's sloppy sucking and occasional gags, Danny's muffled gasps and moans that turned to whimpers with Sam's fingers in his mouth and his cock being worked over longer and harder. Maybe all of this should have been shocking. You never thought, not before all those pictures anyway, that Sam would go down on any man and you certainly never could have imagined you'd watch it happen, but the whole thing was far more arousing than shocking. It was like your brain couldn't even acknowledge the surprise that should have been blatant, rather it was fixated on the pure pleasure Sam was giving to Danny and how it translated to you somehow, an invisible line connecting all three of you.
Forever, for sure. You'd have to take all of this to the grave.
Sam suddenly grunted and popped off, grinning at Danny with spit coating his chin. "Ouch, Daniel." He turned to you. "He's such a biter."
You'd been too busy watching Sam going down on him to have noticed Danny chomping on his fingers. "I remember," you said, voice just a tad wobbly which you hoped would go unnoticed. "From that picture. All those marks on your stomach." You could still see faint pink remnants on Sam's torso now.
"Mmm, yeah." Sam jerked Danny off, a wet slick sound thanks to all the saliva he'd left behind, and kept his eyes on you while he asked, "Wanna watch him do it?"
You felt like you were about to burst despite no one touching you or touching yourself, but the idea of Danny doing that was too enticing to turn down. You also felt it was possible that such a long delay before your own ecstasy could make it all even more incredible. So you said yes and quickly Sam flopped onto his back, encouraging Danny to come to him with outstretched arms, but he had to wait a moment–Danny fumbled on the bed for a few seconds trying to get his pants all the way off and his struggle elicited a much-needed laugh from you and Sam.
"Stop laughing," Danny protested with a final kick, sending the sweatpants to the floor. "Getting naked isn't always like, a graceful thing."
"You're not as bad as Sam," you assured him, and Sam shot you an insulted look. "He just tears everything off like an animal. No grace at all."
"I like doing it for him," Danny said. He kissed Sam on the mouth softly, deeply, and Sam's arms circled his shoulders, bringing him even closer. You watched closely, glued to the chair, as Danny brushed Sam's hair back and brought his mouth to his neck; you'd always loved kissing Sam's neck, too. Would he make the same sorts of sounds when Danny did it?
The soft sigh that Sam let out when Danny kissed along his throat was similar, yet still different. There was more desperation in that sound, especially when Danny carried on gently for another few moments before you saw him sink his teeth right in. Sam shuddered and clawed at Danny's shoulders, and suddenly you were wondering what Danny's mouth would feel like on you.
"Yeah, Sam loves when I mark him up," Danny purred, trailing his increasingly harsh and teeth-filled kisses down Sam's torso. He stopped at Sam's belly, his teeth pressing into the soft skin as he pulled down his shorts. Seeing Sam's dick was nothing new for you, but when Danny abruptly grabbed Sam by the hips to toss him over, then lifted him onto his knees, that was an entirely new sight.
Danny gripped Sam's ass while he dove right in and took a bite into one cheek like he really was trying to eat him; Sam yelped and you gasped. It looked like it hurt–when Danny pulled back, there was already an angry red mark, but then Sam moaned and laughed a little.
"God, Sam. I didn't know you were like this," you remarked, perplexed and fascinated and so turned on that you had to sit right on top of your hands. "I've never seen you so–I don't know. Submissive."
"He's a good boy for me," Danny said, the words low and deep, and pet his hands up Sam's sides. You could see that–Sam was perfectly pliant beneath Danny's touch, like he was just waiting for whatever happened next, and so responsive to everything. Danny looked at you and his next question, though you'd been secretly waiting for it, nearly made you collapse out of the chair: "Wanna help him get ready?"
You balked for a moment, wide-eyed and so stiff from all the pent up excitement and curiosity. "Ready for–?"
Sam snapped his head to the side, peering at you sharply through his hair that had fallen into his face. "Ready to fuck me, obviously," he snarked, but when Danny grabbed his hips hard and gave another bite to his ass, he quivered and his voice softened as he added, "Get over here, Y/N. We need you."
That short sentence circled around in your mind, urging you to move but you felt like you couldn't–the thought of getting up fully clothed to just wander over to what was happening on the bed seemed awkward and silly. Clearly your trepidation didn't go unnoticed, because Danny was walking over to you, naked as the day he was born, and lifted you up.
"Don't be scared," he said in your ear, pushing you onward while he stayed behind you, his erection unceremoniously pressing against your lower back.
"I'm not scared," you said, but you gasped again when Danny tugged at your pants and Sam was suddenly right in front of you yanking on the hem of your shirt. Helpless, you let them both strip you down to your bra and panties; Sam leaned back on his hands with a grin while you felt Danny move in even closer, his hands stroking your hips.
"Is that okay?" Danny asked, his lips on your ear.
"Yeah, sure," was all you could say. You shivered when Sam reached one of his hands out to lightly press his fingers to the crotch of your panties.
"It was really hot for you to watch," Sam said, drawing a line down your thigh with one fingertip. "Danny was nervous about it. Performance anxiety, you know. But–" He leaned to the side to look behind you. "It looks like he's doing just fine."
You were feeling more relaxed–Sam was back to himself, at least momentarily, and Danny was keeping his touches gentle and tentative. "You guys look like you're made for each other. It makes sense why we didn't work out."
Sam frowned a little. "I feel bad about that, Y/N. I didn't even know how into Danny I was until, well, pretty recently."
Danny gave a little snort. "Please. I think everyone but you could see it pretty clearly."
Sam rolled his eyes before he sighed and looked back at you. "You should try kissing him," he suggested, leaning back once more. "It's totally serendipitous."
You could imagine. You turned in Danny's arms; he smiled at you so sweetly that you were wrapped up in his softness, not even realizing he was single handedly bringing you down to the bed to lie next to Sam. Then he was kissing you as tenderly as he'd smiled at you and you felt you understood what Sam must have been feeling while you'd been watching earlier–kissing Danny was like magic.
You were feeling quite fulfilled just from making out and touching–Danny was so warm and so firm, his muscles taut beneath your fingers, his hair so soft–but then he was abruptly being pulled away from you. "Alright, back to business," Sam commanded, yanking Danny away by his hair, to which Danny was grimacing and reaching up untangle Sam's fingers.
"Ha!" Danny exclaimed when Sam freed him. "You're jealous."
You'd never seen Sam jealous before, actually, but now that Danny was pointing it out, you could see it clearly–the darkness in his eyes beneath furrowed brows, the exaggerated slant of his cheekbones as he pouted, the flush on his cheeks.
"You're supposed to make it even during threesomes," Sam said, looking from Danny to you then back again. Jealous or not, he was still hard, you noticed. "You have to divvy up the attention, Daniel and Y/N."
"Fine," Danny said shortly. "Then get on your knees again." Instead of waiting even one second for Sam to do it himself, he grabbed his ankles and rolled him over again.
"Such a dom," Sam said with a chuckle.
"God," was all you could say, breathless at being involved now, not just witnessing. You needed to see more though and you were starting to understand your place in all this–you moved up to sit in front of Sam, lightly touching his face. "Hey, Sam–can I kiss you?"
He smirked at you, though you felt he had no right to when he was in such a vulnerable position, his ass quite literally in Danny's face. "I thought you'd never ask," Sam said, inching forward on his elbows, an image so ridiculous that you almost laughed. Instead, you brought your smile to his lips and kissed him for the first time in months–it should have felt ordinary but it didn't. It felt brand new, strange and a little scary, made even scarier by the sudden popping sound that broke out from below.
You pulled away to identify the source, which was Danny squeezing lube onto his fingers. "Where'd you get that?" you asked, keeping your hands on Sam's shoulders.
Danny chuckled, closing the cap of the bottle. "It was already on the bed." With his dry hand he lifted a strip of condoms from the mattress and waved them around. "We came prepared."
You grimaced; Sam and Danny both laughed. "Well, um–that's good," you said, but jeez. When had your ex-boyfriend and his best friend become such sex-crazed maniacs? It wasn't the condoms or the lube–it was the fact that Sam was wiggling his hips back to Danny and Danny was squeezing one of his ass cheeks, anticipation evident on his face.
"Are you good?" Sam asked, propping himself up on his knees to get directly in front of you, wrapping his arms around you.
"Yeah, uh, I'm very good," you stammered, running a hand through your hair and nearly knocking Sam in the face in the process. "It's just–a lot to process."
Danny moved right behind Sam, holding him so you were all pressed together like an obscene panini. "Yeah, it is for us, too," he said, resting his chin on Sam's shoulders. "You're the only one we'd wanna do this with."
"Speak for yourself," Sam said. "I'm keeping my options open."
"You're fucking rude, Sam," you said, but all the distractions kept any real heat away from your voice.
Sam laughed, that loud cackle that nearly made the walls vibrate. "I'm kidding, Y/N!" He grabbed your face and pulled you forward to plant a fast, harsh kiss to your mouth before he snapped back and said, looking over his shoulder at Danny, "Now let's get this show on the road, big guy. Show her what you're made of."
That certainly did set things in motion, with Danny moving swiftly to get Sam back down in front of you; Sam planted his face in your lap and grabbed your hips, hastily pulling your underwear down. You weren't sure where to fix your eyes–at Danny kissing Sam's spine and his arm moving vaguely below or Sam tossing your panties to the floor, then latching his teeth to your inner thigh.
You let out a flustered breath and unhooked your bra. "Since everyone else is doing it–"
Sam's voice was faintly muffled with his face between your legs: "That's the spirit." Though it shouldn't have, the swipe of his tongue up your center came as a surprise, but not as much of a surprise as the loud keen that came from him as Danny perked up behind him, looking at both of you.
"Oh my god," you uttered, trembling as you met Danny's gaze. "Are you–"
"I'm getting him ready," Danny answered as if it were the most ordinary thing in the world. When you straightened up a bit, you got a better peek at what Danny's hands were doing–one was gripping Sam's hip and the other was thrusting idly. "I gotta open him up." He draped himself over Sam's back, his own upper body long enough for his own dark curls to mix with Sam's sleek chestnut hair. "How do you want it, Sammy? Nice and easy or hard and fast?"
Sam gave an upwards nod at you. "Whatever she wants to see."
Being given a clear say in this matter triggered a need for vengeance that you hadn't even known existed. "Hard and fast," you told Danny. He looked a little surprised, eyes widening slightly and lips parting; you tugged Sam's hair a bit to make him look up at you again. "I bet that's how you really like it, isn't it?"
Of course Sam wouldn't give you the satisfaction of feeling like revenge was ever possible. He laughed softly and said, "I like it however Danny likes it."
Danny pulled back. "Which just happens to be hard and fast," he said, and you caught a glimpse of him thrusting his hand forward again and Sam let out a choked little whimper, then a bitten-back groan as Danny gave a shockingly sharp, hard smack to his ass.
You had nothing to say to that. You simply tried to process what the hell was happening all around you once more, which was a good thing; you couldn't exactly speak when Sam began nipping at your thigh and sliding two fingers inside of you. You kept your hands in his hair and fought the urge to close your eyes–you wanted to see as much as you could of Danny working his own fingers in and out of Sam and the way your ex-boyfriend's body moved so sinuously with every motion. Sam pressed his tongue to your clit again, licking with impression intention given the position he was in, while his soft grunts got muffled against your heat.
"How's that feel?" Danny asked, and you weren't sure if he was asking you or Sam or both of you.
"Good," you said at the same time Sam said, "Amazing." He looked up with suspicion. "Just 'good?' Alright, guess I have to work harder." He brought his face back down, lapping at your clit wetly while his fingers worked deeper and harder through your own wetness. You felt a little embarrassed at how you were already dampening the sheet beneath you but you couldn't help it–this was by far the most wild and the hottest sexual experience of your life. It made you a little mad that Sam being a kind of shitty boyfriend had to be the lead up to it.
Danny hummed. "So, Sam–think you're ready?"
Sam nodded between your thighs, then looked up, his lips and chin shiny with your slick and his spit. "I've got an idea," he began, lifting himself up and using your legs for leverage. "Get under me. That way, it'll be like getting fucked by both of us." He laughed a little, looking very satisfied with his own suggestion. "Except I'll still be getting fucked the way I want."
"Always about you," you muttered, a futile sort of defense mechanism against this very bewildering idea. But Sam only pulled you down as much as he could, until you were halfway down the bed and halfway beneath him.
Danny, you could tell based on the crinkling sound, was getting a condom on; you watched him slip one to Sam, who wasted no time in tearing it open. His abdomen flexed as he stayed upright on his knees and rolled the condom over his own cock; you reached out to touch him, his body still so familiar. The onset of an ache, of wanting Sam so badly, began to override the ache for punishing him. Maybe all of this was an apology in and of itself.
"I gotta get in you before he gets me," Sam said. His voice was calm but his cheeks were vivid scarlet and sweat beaded on his hairline. You spread your legs and got your arms around his waist, both bringing him down to you and giving yourself some much-needed stability, and Sam slid into you like it was any other ordinary time, except for Danny's hands looping around his chest and bringing his chin back to Sam's shoulder.
The slide was easy–probably far easier than Sam's experience would be, you thought–and Danny watched while he sank his teeth into Sam's skin, the swirling forest of his irises fixed on yours in a way that would have made you feel self-conscious if it weren't for Sam overtaking you being so distracting.
"God, you feel good," Sam said quietly, giving a shallow thrust. That was enough to make you moan softly in response, gripping his middle more tightly. Your arms were brushing against Danny's abdomen; Danny brought one hand to your forearm as if encouraging you both to keep going, so Sam did with a few more gentle shoves of his hips. As you were just getting used to the sensation of three bodies of increasing heat coming together, Sam's cock sliding through your wetness and his hands squeezing your breasts, Danny shifted and Sam's serene face turned to an open-mouthed, tense visage.
"That's it, Sammy," Danny encouraged. There was so much love in his voice that it made you feel loved too, though it was obvious in that moment he was wholly focused on Sam. Rightfully so. Sam responded viscerally not only with his facial expressions that only you could see, but with his voice, cursing softly and moaning low, and the full-body shudder that ran through him as Danny pushed forward.
You could imagine it being a bit of a challenge to take Danny yourself; the fact that Sam could do it was actually a little amazing. "God, Sam," you said, stroking his hair. The soft reverence emanating from Danny made you feel the same–this was an experience to be treasured no matter how it went. "This is so hot. You guys look really hot together."
"He feels so good. Literally so hot," Danny said. He leaned over Sam again, making Sam push down on you, and subsequently into you, harder. Danny was fully in charge now, something you were entirely unopposed to–you watched, fascinated, as he began to move, his hands wandering over Sam's chest and hips while he started to thrust. He built up a rhythm swiftly and easily, soon enough making Sam let out moans that became choked little sobbing sounds as Danny started to live up to expectations–he was fucking Sam hard and fast and you were on the receiving end of the last gyrations and echoes of his movements.
You grabbed the back of Sam's head, pulling him in to kiss. There was just barely enough room to snake your arm between the two of your bodies; your first two fingers made a V around the base of Sam's cock, stroking him lightly before you brought them to circle your clit. Sam's desperate moans were drowned out by your incessant kissing–you wanted to consume him like Danny did, or as close to it as possible.
Between pants and huffs of effort, Danny's voice snaked through your ears: "Do you like it, Sammy?" he asked and you opened your ears, giving Sam some necessary air and giving yourself quite the view as you strained to the side. Danny's thighs were flexing with each thrust and his hands had a stronghold around Sam's hips; Sam was all wobbly limbs and flushed skin, his hands clamped on your shoulders.
"Yeah," was all Sam said. It was probably all he could say while Danny pounded into him.
Danny's eyebrows rose. "What was that?" You bit your lip as Sam's face tensed, his eyes shut tight, and waited for Sam to respond, but he didn't. He only moaned a little, quiet and subdued, then the tension was slashed to pieces by another hard smack against his ass. "Sam?"
"Fuck!" Sam was explosive now with that one word, fucking himself back onto Danny and, subsequently, harder into you as he shifted back and forth. Words escaped you entirely as you just tried to ride through the dense waves, but Danny apparently had more.
"Tell Y/N how much you like this," Danny demanded, yanking Sam's head back by a fistful of hair, Sam squirming helplessly all the way.
"Oh my god, I like it," Sam let out breathlessly, trying to look back at Danny. With the additional space, you touched yourself again more freely. Your chest and stomach felt so tight, this huge buildup growing even more–the fear surrounding this was gone. The anticipation had been alleviated and the payoff was more than you'd ever imagined, because the image of Danny holding Sam's hip while he pulled his hair, his lips roaming Sam's neck, and Sam desperately trying to please both of you was the most incredible thing you'd ever seen.
It was Danny's name that escaped your lips as you came, eyes shutting to dizzying blackness, shuddering violently beneath Sam and squeezing his cock tight inside you. Even in the throes of your own little explosion, you realized what you'd said and managed to say Sam's name next, and reached for him with one hand.
"Oh fuck, I like that too," Sam said against your cheek, teeth then dragging down to your neck. "You coming around me while Danny fucks me. So fucking hot."
"Fuck, you guys–" you started to say, still out of breath, and tangled your fingers in Sam's hair, trying to keep him close. "This is–wow. Are you close?"
"Sam's ready to blow," Danny answered, not showing any sign of slowing down. "He's getting even tighter and–" He peeked down, then Sam gasped. "Yup, his balls are full. You gonna come for us, Sam?"
"Danny, where'd you learn how to dirty talk like this?" you questioned, genuinely flabbergasted by how easily the more easygoing, friendly and sometimes exceptionally shy and boyish side could give way to a man who was so in charge, so lustful, so commanding.
"He's a secret slut," Sam quipped, which got him another slap on the ass. He laughed a little, then you were caught in the dark again when he began to kiss you. Based on just that, it did seem like Sam was close–the kisses were getting sloppier, the stifled moans sharper, his hands squeezing your body harder. And when he did come, it wasn't exactly what you were used to because Sam also moaned Danny's name, both syllables whispered on your lips.
"That's good, baby," Danny cooed. Your vision was a bit fuzzy as you tried to look right at him, but you could see quite clearly how tenderly those big hands moved down Sam's trembling back. The gentleness was short-lived–Danny went back into thrusting harshly, their muscles clashing against one another's, Danny's fingers raking down Sam's sides. You'd never seen Danny come. Never thought you ever would. You thought that would be forever reserved for Sam now that they'd gotten together. So, enthralled once more, you stayed transfixed on him as he closed his eyes and lurched forward, his upper body hanging over Sam, his curls shielding parts of his face. But you could see the twitch of a brow and the parting of his lips, then the white teeth biting down, and then Danny let himself go entirely. He flopped down on top of Sam, who collapsed on top of you.
"Okay, jeez, you guys are heavy," you noted after getting the wind knocked out of you. Sam stayed motionless, but Danny had the decency to get up. You turned your head to the side to watch him move off the bed, carefully roll the condom off himself and grab his pants from the floor. You considered asking him to stay naked because, well, why not? But then Sam groaned loudly, interrupting your thoughts.
"I'm gonna be so fucking sore tomorrow," he declared, finally rolling off you, spreading out on his back; he stretched and you heard a crack come from somewhere. "Thanks, Daniel."
Danny stepped over to pat Sam's thigh. "You're welcome." He looked over at you. "How are you feeling?"
"I–" you paused, trying to find the right words, but first you needed to find your clothes again. Sam might have been comfortable living nude as often as he could, but you needed some sense of familiar security around you after all that. As you got redressed, you continued: "I felt many things during all that, honestly. It was kinda fun to see Sam getting wrecked." Danny beamed at that, which almost made you laugh, which made Sam actually laugh. "I think you guys really are great together and I'm happy for you. But breaking up still really hurt."
Danny gave a sympathetic frown then, his eyes becoming softer; Sam crawled over to your seat at the edge of the bed. "I'm sorry. I really am," he said, sounding shockingly genuine. "I should've been a better boyfriend while I was still your boyfriend."
"It's okay, Sam, honestly," you assured him, patting the arm that had wrapped around you. "It's over and, really, it was fine. You were just in love with someone else. Better being in love with Danny than some random stranger or something."
"Maybe if he'd told me sooner, we wouldn't have ended up in that whole mess."
Danny scoffed, planting his hands on his hips as he stood in front of both of you. "I sent you like, a million signals, Sam. You were pretty much the only person who didn't realize sooner."
"It's true," you chimed in. "Looking back, Danny never really tried to hide anything."
Sam sighed, then hopped off the bed and plastered himself against Danny's side. "Okay, well, we didn't hide anything tonight, did we?" He reached down and grabbed Danny's crotch while kissing his cheek.
Danny hissed and slapped Sam's hand away. "Too much too soon."
"Never too much," Sam replied, sneaking in another kiss, holding Danny close. "Never too soon."
"Ugh." You got to your feet, too. "Too much sappy romance for me."
Sam cackled and grabbed your hand. "No, don't leave. The night can't end like this."
"Yeah, we all at least need a few shots or a bowl or something," Danny agreed with a sigh, running his fingers through his hair. "And a shower. Definitely a shower."
"I get to go first," Sam announced, breaking free and jetting out of the room, leaving you with a final image of his reddened ass, all thanks to Danny.
So then it was just you and Danny standing in the middle of the bedroom where so many unexpected, wild and beautiful things had happened. You looked at the chair that you'd been sitting in, so unassuming, then to the disheveled bed, and Danny put one arm around your shoulders.
"Thanks for doing this, Y/N," he said. "Sam still talks about you all the time. He really cares about you. I think he respects you a lot, too."
"I'll always care about him," you told Danny. His touch was as comforting as your clothes, weirdly enough. You were starting to understand more and more why Sam was so smitten with him. "I care about you too, Danny."
From the hallway, Sam shouted, "Do you care enough about me to let my boyfriend get in the shower with me?"
Danny rolled his eyes while you laughed. "Okay, big guy," you said, steering him out of the room. "You get in there while I get the drinks."