Total Drama X Reader OneShots! (Closed)

unexpected love triangle - Scott x Reader x Brick

As the reality show contestants stepped foot on Total Drama Island once more, I couldn't help but feel a little anxious. I, Y/N, had been chosen to participate in this thrilling adventure. But little did I know that my life was about to take another unexpected turn.

Among the familiar faces, I noticed Brick McArthur and Scott, both looking as determined as ever. Brick, with his strong physique and determined attitude, had always intrigued me. Scott, on the other hand, had a mischievous charm that was hard to resist.

As the first challenge began, tensions ran high. In a race to retrieve flags, each team struggled to find their rhythm. Brick, Scott, and I found ourselves working together, determined to prove our worth.

During the chaos of the challenge, Brick accidentally stumbled and I reached out to catch him, our hands touching briefly. The unexpected connection sent shivers down my spine, leaving me flustered and blushing. It seemed Brick felt it too, his cheeks turning a shade of pink.

Scott, always quick to sense opportunity, smirked mischievously, making it clear that he noticed the spark between Brick and me. His playful banter added an extra layer of tension to the dynamic, as if hinting at something deeper.

As our journey on Total Drama Island continued, unexpected alliances formed. Whether it was working together during challenges or spending more time together in the downtime, the bond between Brick, Scott, and me grew stronger.

Brick's kind heart and willingness to protect others won me over time and time again. Scott, despite his sarcastic banter, revealed a softer side, slowly peeling back the layers of his tough exterior. Both appealed to different sides of me, leaving me torn between two incredible individuals.

One evening, as we lay beneath the starry sky, the tension between us became too overwhelming to ignore. Scott, always the brave one, took the first step, declaring his feelings for me. Swept up in the moment, I found myself torn between reciprocating his affection or exploring the unknown with Brick.

Just as I was about to respond, Brick, his usually calm demeanor shaken, shared his own feelings. My heart ached at the thought of hurting either of them, knowing that whatever path I took would leave someone broken-hearted.

In the end, I made the difficult decision to remain true to my heart. I approached Brick, expressing my feelings and apologizing to Scott. Brick, understanding and genuine, accepted my confession and vowed to support me no matter what.

While Scott's heartache was evident, he took the time to reflect and eventually accepted my decision. The three of us, despite the lingering heartache, remained close friends, finding solace in the bond we shared.

As Total Drama Island came to an end, we left with a wealth of memories and a friendship that would withstand the test of time. And who knows, maybe one day, the winds of love may blow in a different direction, bringing about a new chapter in our lives.