Creepypastaxreader Stories

Refine by tag:

885 Stories

Normal // A Ticci Toby x Reader Story by justaperson2
#1
Normal // A Ticci Toby x Reader St...by justaperson2
Ehhhhh I'll write a description later
  • waffles
  • jeffthekiller
  • slenderman
+16 more
Music Shifter by zodiacaries
#2
Music Shifterby Aries Star
You are a secret killer for a few years, nobody can ever track you. You gain powers are from music Example: you hear the song unravel from Tokyo Ghoul, you became a gho...
Completed
  • readerinsert
  • creepypasta
  • music
+4 more
To Live without Fear [Jeff the KillerxReader] by Jcreeps
#3
To Live without Fear [Jeff the Kil...by Jcreeps
The one thing every living creature has in common is fear. Fear keeps us alive, drives us forward, and makes us still. Jeff the Killer thought he knew everything about f...
  • jtkxreader
  • jeff
  • jtk
+8 more
Schooled [Laughing JackxReader] by Jcreeps
#4
Schooled [Laughing JackxReader]by Jcreeps
You are a Kindergarten Teacher at a small elementary school. You love kids, and you love your job. But when a little girl from your class is murdered, you decide to take...
Completed
  • laughingjackxreader
  • laughingjack
  • creepypastafanfic
+3 more
SLENDERMAN'S LOST DAUGHTER ( A Creepypasta X Reader) by Beru_is_Berry
#5
SLENDERMAN'S LOST DAUGHTER ( A Cre...by Berry_is_Beru
~UNDER EDITING~ Yn Ln is an abused teen since she was 6 yrs old as a child. She was adopted by a woman named Maria Reynolds (only Hamilton fans will know) now as her fos...
  • creepypastaxreader
  • xreader
  • fanfiction
+2 more
Misunderstandings // A BEN Drowned x Reader Story by justaperson2
#6
Misunderstandings // A BEN Drowned...by justaperson2
(Y/N) (L/N) was always a fan of creepypasta. She wasn't necessarily crazy obsessed with it, but she found the stories interesting. Sure she had pondered the idea of them...
  • humor
  • hoodie
  • jeffthekiller
+21 more
Creepypasta x Witch! Female Reader! by Queen_0f_Demons
#7
Creepypasta x Witch! Female Reader!by ~404~
(Y/N) was a normal teenage girl that had social anxiety that lived in a normal town and went to a normal school and had close friends but had online friends. She was the...
  • zalgo
  • sally
  • jeffthekiller
+12 more
Ben drowned x reader by Freak-reading2
#8
Ben drowned x readerby Abel
"I-I shouldn't have done that . . ." "Damn right."
  • bendrownedxreader
  • bendrowned
  • ben
+5 more
Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios by TheNightPhantom
#9
Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenariosby A Humor Enthusiast
Read at your own risk! Contains: One deranged killer who wears pink boxers. One little blonde elf.. Midget... Thing. One extremely Dark and handsome Link. One monochr...
  • fanfiction
  • xreader
  • creepypastaboyfriendscenarios
+16 more
Jeff The Killer X Reader by ThePerfectBlur
#10
Jeff The Killer X Readerby Baka
Secrets. Some are best hidden from the world and from other people. Although, the more secrets that build up, the angrier a person may get.
Completed
  • readerxcharacter
  • warning
  • wattpad
+15 more
Creepypasta X YouTuber! Reader! by ItsJustMeNaelline
#11
Creepypasta X YouTuber! Reader!by ʜɪ sᴛʀᴀɴɢᴇʀ
You are a famous YouTuber with over 10 million subscribers, Your known for Comedic skits, Singing, animations and Gaming, little did you know, The pastas also enjoy your...
  • creepypastaxyoutubereader
  • creepypasta
  • youtube
+3 more
Thirteen [Creepypasta x Reader]  by LifeisFunandGreat
#12
Thirteen [Creepypasta x Reader] by LifeisFunandGreat
(Y/N) woke up to three people carrying her through the woods. She couldn't recall any memory of what had happened before she was being carried. All she knew was that she...
  • creepypastaxreader
  • sally
  • eyelessjack
+22 more
Is It Love?~Creepypasta OneShots! by -Mxrtal
#13
Is It Love?~Creepypasta OneShots!by —🥀—
I couldn't be bothered to edit this. :) Want to read stories of you and your Favorite Creepypastas? Well, c'mon and read 'em! Well I take requests and would love to hear...
  • slenderman
  • jeffthekiller
  • oneshot
+13 more
Frustratingly Hot (Ticci Toby x Reader) by HewwoHuwan
#14
Frustratingly Hot (Ticci Toby x Re...by ★tinychu★
*ONGOING BOOK* You lived an unnoticed, simple life as some may call it. Until a man broke into your home almost bleeding to death. You decided to help his health, but th...
  • ticci
  • lemon
  • smutmaybe
+22 more
Bloody Sisters (Creepypasta x Reader ) by UmeJuuzou
#15
Bloody Sisters (Creepypasta x Read...by 🌿Karachin☘️
Your Jane Ankersaw a.k.a Jane the killer's little sister. You guys get new neighbors but it soon gone hell.After the accident with Jeff who killed your parents you lost...
  • homicidalliu
  • nathanthenobody
  • creepypastaxreader
+3 more
Complicated (A Ticci Toby Soulmate AU) by pokemon240
#16
Complicated (A Ticci Toby Soulmate...by Pokemon240
Imagine waiting years on end for your soulmate only to find out he's a serial killer. DISCLAIMER: I do not own any creepypasta characters, just my own character Lauren.
Completed
  • toby
  • creepypasta
  • ticcitoby
+7 more
A Soldiers Rifle(CreepyPasta x Reader) by AndreiLouiseCasim
#17
A Soldiers Rifle(CreepyPasta x Rea...by Andrei Louise Casim
Born to be the next generation Soldier of the (L/N)Family.You were known as to be the last one.Being a commander is a huge rensponsibility.One day.You went on a mission...
  • creepypastaxreader
Free Me: BEN Drowned x Reader ✔ by Fyristdim
#18
Free Me: BEN Drowned x Reader ✔by Fyristdim
All credit goes to a great Devianart writer, MidnightRainbowFire. Cleverbot: "Welcome back Jadusable." My hands trembled. He was here. I typed slowly. User:...
Completed
  • ben
  • creepypastaxreader
  • bendrownedxreader
+5 more
Jeff The Killer x Suicidal!Reader by S-enpaii
#19
Jeff The Killer x Suicidal!Readerby 𝕊 𝕖 𝕟 𝕡 𝕒 𝕚
I've had a sad life full of bullying and abuse, one of the people doing it be my own father. This was until one fateful day where someone came and turned everything arou...
  • crazy
  • creepypastafanfic
  • yandereboy
+18 more
Serene And Gentle: A Creepypasta Fanfic by Devil_Tenshi
#20
Serene And Gentle: A Creepypasta F...by Meiko
{ VARIOUS! Creepypasta X MALE! Reader } Warning: Swears, Dark Backstories, Mature Content, BoyXBoy, Triggering Scenes Calm is the forest right after the dawn light has k...
  • yaoicreeypasta
  • malereader
  • boyxboy
+7 more