Cry Baby - BEN Drowned x Reader

Computer

"Please?" I asked again.

He shook his head.

I stepped inside my closet and closed the door, it was a tight squeeze but I could manage.

I stepped out and nearly head-butted BEN.

I gasped and he stepped back.

"Jesus, you scared me." I said, wiping tears away.

"Damn you cry over everything, don't you?" He muttered.

"No, only things that scare me." I said.

"So, everything?" He raised an eyebrow.

"No... not everything." I said quietly.

Suddenly, my phone started ringing.

I walked over and nearly had a heart attack when I saw the caller ID.

'Cassie'

"Oh shit I'm in trouble now." I muttered, clicking the 'answer' button.

"WHERE THE HELL ARE YOU?! ITS 9!" She yelled, making me grimace.

"I'm sorry! A lot has been going on already and I won't be able to go to class!" I explained.

"What do you mean 'a lot'? What happened? Is mom okay?" She asked quickly.

"Yeah, moms fine. It's just-" I stopped as I heard beeping, signaling that the phone call ended.

I looked at the phone screen in confusion.

"What happened?" I whispered, opening Messages.

"I can't let you do that. You can't tell her, or anyone else about me. If anyone found out, I'd have to kill them, and you." BEN stepped over to me and took the phone out of my hands.

"Why can't they know?" I asked.

"It's common sense, (Y/N). People think we're just stories, and we have to keep it that way." He said.

"Um... can I have my phone back? She's gonna yell at me if I don't explain why I hung up. I'll just tell her my phone died." I said, holding my hand out.

He looked down at my hand before placing my phone in my palm.

"Thank you. Um... are you hungry? I was gonna make some breakfast before you popped up." I asked quietly.

"Sure. What were you gonna make?" He questioned.

"Waffles." I said.

He paused and stared at me before walking over to my computer.

"Mind if I invite someone?" He asked.

I shook my head slowly, confused.

He crawled into the computer and popped back out a few minutes later, another person coming out after him.

"Toby?" I said, shocked.

Toby looked at me and took his goggles off, along with his face mask.

"Y-yup!" He said happily.

"Oh my god, are all the creepypastas real?" I asked.

"Pretty much. Most of the more well-known ones, anyways." BEN said.

"Is Jeff real?" I asked.

Toby nodded.

My eyes widened and I smiled.

"Can I meet him? He's my favorite." I said shyly.

"What?! But you summoned me!" BEN yelled, sounding offended.

"Well, you're my second favorite. Toby is my third, then EJ, and then Sally." I said.

"I'm o-one of yo-our favorites?" Toby gasped.

I nodded quickly and jumped when he pulled me into a hug.

"You guys are exactly how the fanfictions describe you." I mumbled quietly.

"What's that supposed to mean?" BEN asked.

"You're a pervert, and Toby is happy and bubbly. I'm guessing Jeff is mean and curses a lot, and EJ is quiet and smart?" I asked.

"Basically." BEN said.

"So... can I meet Jeff?" I asked again.

"I guess. But don't get all buddy-buddy with him, got it?" BEN said, crawling back into my computer.

"That gets weirder and weirder every time he does it." I said quietly.

Toby nodded in agreement and grabbed my hand.

"Why are you holding my hand?" I asked.

"Cau-se you're go-onna try and r-run." He said.

"No I won't, Jeff is my-" I paused.

"WHAT THE FUCK IS UP, BITCHES?!"