Murder - EJ x Reader - COMPLETED

~8~

"My girlfriend?" He chuckled.

I furrowed my brows at him.

What the fuck is that even supposed to mean? (A/N: I'll love you forever if you understand this)

"Why's that funny?" I asked, annoyed.

"No reason." Jack said.

"You can go now." I gritted my teeth.

"I'm not leaving while you're here with them alone. I don't trust either of them." He crossed his arms.

"What?! I'm completely trustworthy!" Jeff yelled, offended.

"I trust you about as much as I trust BEN when he says he hasn't watched porn in 5 days." Jack said.

"It's been about an hour." BEN mumbled.

"Ew." I scrunched up my nose.

BEN wiggled his eyebrows at me.

"Fuck off." I said.

Jack laughed a bit and Jeff just sat there, still offended.

"Okay, I'm gonna go now. Thanks Jeff." I gave him a quick hug before standing up and taking Jacks hand, and leading him out into the hall.

He didn't have any gloves on, so I could feel his warm skin against mine.

I led him into my room and sat him down on the bed, then stood in front of him.

"So. What's your problem?" I asked.

"What do you mean?" He questioned.

"Why did you laugh when you said girlfriend?" I raised an eyebrow.

"No reason." He got quieter.

I sighed and closed my eyes, then put my hands on his shoulders.

With my eyes still closed, I wrapped my arms around him and pulled him into an embrace.

His arms hesitantly wrapped around me and he pulled me closer.

I took a deep breath and I could smell the irony blood that stained his hood.

My heart was pounding, but I'd never felt more calm.

"(Y/N), why did you hug me? I thought you were mad?" He asked quietly.

"I was. But I needed this more than I did an argument." I said.

He went silent and laid back, keeping me on top of him.

"I'm tired." He whispered.

I nodded and kept my arms wrapped around his neck.

After a few more seconds, Jack spoke up.

"I think I'm in love with you." He said quickly.

I sat up quickly and looked straight at him.

"Are you serious?" I asked, a smile beginning to form.

He nodded.

A huge smile found its way to my face and I hugged him again.

"Do... do you feel the same way?" He asked.

I sat up and laughed.

"How could I not?" I asked.

He sat up and took his mask off, setting it beside him.

I smiled at Jack and wrapped my arms around his neck, he put his hands on my hips.

In an instant, I crashed my lips into Jacks.

He almost instantly began kissing back, his lips moved with mine.

After a minute or two, we parted.

He smiled at me, making me smile back.

"What do we do now?" I asked.

"I suppose we should talk to Slender about this, don't you think?" He suggested.

I nodded and got off of him, then grabbed his hand.

With his mask secure and my hand in his, we walked to Slender's office.

As we made our way to the doors, my nerves got the best of me, filling me with paranoia.

I knocked shakily as static filled my mind, calming me.

"Hello children, how may I help you?" Slender's booming voice echoed in my mind.

"Honestly, I don't know. Jack and I need your advice." I responded.

Jack nodded in agreement.

"Oh? And would this have something to do with your... relations?" He asked.

"I suppose so." Jack said.

I glanced at him from the corner of my eye.

"Hm. Interesting. So, if I asked you the question I had asked before, would you be able to respond now?" He questioned.

"What question?" Jack asked.

"Just what is your relationship with this girl?" Slender asked.

Jack went quiet before looking at me.

"I... I still don't really know. I haven't felt like this about anyone. But I know that the way I feel is something I can't change." He said.

"Believe me I've tried." He joked.

I rolled my eyes and smiled a bit.

His childish side is cute.

"Hm. Alright, then what is it you needed exactly?" Slender asked.

"Advice." I said.

"It seems you already gave yourself advice, Jack says his feelings are undeniable, and I'm sure you feel the same way,
(Y/N)." Slender responded.

I furrowed my brows before nodding.

"I do." I said.

"Then why would you need help?" He asked.

"I guess we don't." I shrugged.

Jack nodded in agreement and we both left Slender's office.

"Well, that was eventful. Now, who wants some candy?"

———
Boy it took me awhile to update :)

Whoops.

I kinda almost forgot I had this book going 🤷🏼‍♀️

Now I remembered and I STILL don't have an update schedule bc I'm a bum.

Oh well, roughly 5 days from now, if not sooner.

Also I'm working on a Jeff x Reader because I know I have some crazy fangirls that have been waiting.

*tries to pretend she isn't a Jeff fangirl herself*

Anyways, see y'all in 5 days.