A Forbidden Decision (Bendy x Cuphead/Bendystraw)

Ch.12

Narrator POV

After what happened the walk up to the school entrance was silent. Dice was waiting at his street for the two. Once they came into view his face lit up.

"Good morning! What's wrong Cup? Still sleepy?" Dice asked. Cup looked up at him.

"Oh uh yeah." He lied. They began walking again. Cup was by Bendy's side while they were walking. Dice began talking up a storm which to Bendy was unusual. Normally he'd talk some to him but never directed his full attention to Cup. He turned and walked by Cup. Bendy started to focus in more on the two.

"Hey Cup, did you hear about the new café that opened up not far from school? I heard it's a sweet shop! Lot's of people are getting crazy about it." Dice rambled. Bendy slowed down walking. He was finally getting a clear picture.

"Their cake is really good I hear! Since they're not over the walls sweet I'm sure you'll like them as well. Cup are you listening? I'm guessing you're not to crazy about cake. Do you want to go check it out with me?" Dice asked him smiling happily. Cuphead kept his face blank. Bendy saw it clear. When it was said Dice got a boyfriend Bendy realized it was Cup. Because of what happened last night rambling through his head he ran pushing in between the two.

Cuphead POV

I stood there next to King Dice seeing Bendy run off. Shit.. He figured it out..

-time skip-

Bendy POV

I stood in the bathroom brushing my horns back into place from my shower. I heard the bathroom door open. I saw Cuphead walk right behind me when I put down the brush. I looked down. I turned around and tried walking away.

"Hey don't avoid me like that." Cup told me. I stopped in my tracks looking down.

"Why didn't you tell me you were dating Dice..?" I asked him. He didn't reply. I began trying to walk away again. Except he ran over grabbing my wrist.

"Wait!" He exclaimed. I started trying to pull my arm away from his grasp.

"Let go!" I said. I heard a knocking at the door causing me and Cup to freeze. We heard a voice so Cup went to answer it. I stayed in the bathroom listening. When he opened the door it was Dice.

"Cup please tell me your kidding!" He exclaimed.

"What's wrong?" Cup asked.

"I.. I heard you filled out transfer papers and you might leave.. is that true?!" Dice asked. My eyes widened.. Cuphead... transferring...?

Cuphead POV

I looked down at Dice as he asked me questions. I glanced over my shoulder seeing the bathroom door cracked open. I didn't want Bendy to hear anything..

"Let's talk outside.." I told him. He nodded. I walked behind him out the front door. We began walking down the street.

Bendy POV

I looked down at the tile floor. I felt tears roll down my cheeks.. I began having flashbacks.. I remembered that day Cup stopped me from taking my life. I remembered all the times we spent together in and out of school. How he treated me so well.. How he protected me.. Always so kind... so.. gentle.. More tears fell..

"Don't go.. Don't leave me Cup!" I thought aloud. I ran out the bathroom and out the front door to hunt them down. I ran as fast as I possibly could. More then I ever have before. Like my own life depended on it. I could see them in view. I picked up the pace even more.

"Cuphead!" I exclaimed coming to a stop. Both him and Dice turned around looking at me. I breathed heavily, my hands on my knees trying to regain my breath.

"Don't go! Don't leave me here alone!" I said. His gaze at me softened.

"Please... stay with me!" I begged feeling my tears fall down my eyes. I looked down. I was not crying aloud but a river of tears fell.

"Dice, let's continue this conversation some other time."

Narrator POV

Dice watched as Cuphead walked over to Bendy picking him up bridal style and began walking. Bendy buried his face in Cup's chest as he walked. Eventually, Dice could no longer see them.

"Cup.. is it true you filled out that paper..?" Bendy asked quietly.

"Yes.." Cup simply answered.

"I'll go with you!" Bendy exclaimed looking up at Cup.

"Slips to transfer have ended due to the time of year. Besides I'm a grade higher, so at the end of this year I'll be gone to college." Cup said looking down at Bendy.

"Don't you know that the law says since we live together we uh need to always be together!?" Bendy lied kicking his legs.

"Stop making things up Bendy.." Cup told him. Bendy laid his head on Cup's chest.

"Why..? Why do you have to go?" Bendy asked slightly teary eyed. Cuphead stopped walking.

"Because I love you. If I continue living with you I won't be able to restrain myself for long." Cup told him looking straight ahead. He looked down at Bendy. "I can't remain by your side." Bendy looked down tightening his grip on Cup's shirt. He looked up at him.

"Take me back to my room." He said blushing a soft pink. Cup's eyes widened.

Cuphead POV

I sat across from Bendy as I pulled off his shirt. Mine was already off.

"It's so embarrassing.. to do this with you.." Bendy said blushing with his eyes shut tightly. I looked at him softly.

"I've always wanted this. I had hoped you could fall in love with someone else while I stayed to the side and watched. But.. I don't want that to happen.." I told him. He looked at me. I grabbed his hand kissing it.

"Your soft skin.. Your sweet pale lips.. Your adorable size... Your toned body.." I leaned down and kissed his neck softly. He gasped.

"N-no.." He protested.

"I want to make all of it mine." I said as my breath brushed against his neck.

"C-cup.." He stuttered softly. I looked up at him.

"Are you scared.?" I asked him.

"Because Cup..." He trailed off.

"Say it if you are.." I told him.

"I'm.. I'm not scared..." He said shakenly. My eyes widened as I looked at him. "Do it.." He said. I looked down closing my eyes.

"Don't do it out of sympathy... You don't even love me yet.." I told him as I wrapped a blanket around him. He widened his eyes as he looked at me.

"Your body isn't enough for me. I want you heart as well. Hurry and love me.." I instructed.

"I won't pressure you. I'll wait. Just know.." I caressed his cheek. "There's nobody in this world who could love you more then I do." I hugged him. I pulled away and smiled at him.

"Goodnight." I said walking out of his room.

Bendy POV

I laid in bed thinking over everything.. He really loves me.. If he didn't he would have just done it with me.. But.. he didn't.. This feeling... what is it...?