A Pretty Red Color. ( A Jimmy Casket X Reader Fanfiction)

Chapter 12: It All Comes Down

{I'm only going to warn you once... This chapter is going to crush anyone hoping for a lovy-dovey moment with Jimmy. That isn't how I roll.}

"I-I'm w-what!?" I exclaimed not believing my ears.

"You're in love!" Toast repeated.

"No, I can't be!" I argued.

"It's okay Ghost," (Y/n) started, "I feel the same way."

"NO!" I exclaimed, "I'm not because I can't be!"

"Well, sure you can!" Toast laughed, "I know you're afraid of dating because of prom, but-" I cut him off.

"Don't you understand!?" I exclaimed, feeling my adrenaline rise, causing me to blow my cover. At this point however, I didn't care.

"People like me," I laughed, "Don't get a happy end."

"What are you talking about?" Toast asked. I completely snapped.

"PEOPLE LIKE ME END UP SIX FEET UNDER!" I cackled maniacally, "ALONG WITH EVERYONE ELSE I PUT THERE!" I pulled my knife and threw it at Toast. It hit him in the shoulder, just missing his chest. (Y/n) screamed and Toast attempted to pull my knife out of his shoulder. I pulled it out for him, and smacked his head against the wall. He collapsed to the ground. I wasn't sure if he was dead, but I'll take care of that after I take care of (Y/n).

"Hey (Y/n)!" I exclaimed, "Remember me!? Let's get back to where we were!"

"Stay away!" She warned as she pointed a gun at me, "I-I'll shoot! I've done it before!" I laughed and slowly approached her.

"Sweetheart," I started, "I know what the difference between a killer and a liar is. I'll give you a hint, YOU'RE NOT THE KILLER!" I lunged at her, and she dodged. She shot, and grazed my cheek. I put a hand to my face, and when I pulled it off, I saw blood on my fingers.

"I'm proud," I started, "I don't think Toast would've been gutsy enough to shoot at me, and less likely to aim for the head!" I laughed. (Y/n) glared, and aimed again. Just before I could make a move, guess who finally decided to show up to class? I put my head in my hands.

"Damn it Ghost!" I mumbled, "Of all the times you could show back up, it had to be now!?"

"What are you doing!?" (Y/n) exclaimed, "Don't try to trick me! You killed Ghost, and then tried to take his place!" Actually, this might be good. I let Ghost have control and watched.

"(Y/n)?" Ghost asked, putting the knife down.

"Stop it!" She cried, "Just stop it! It's not fair for you to play with my emotions!" Her grip on the gun tightened.

"(Y/n), what are you talking about?" He started as he looked around, "What am I wearing? And-" He cut himself off when he saw Toast.

"TOAST!" He screamed running over to him. He checked his pulse, which to my surprise was still there, but only weakly. Hehehe...

"(Y/n), you need to call an ambulance! Quickly" Ghost exclaimed. (Y/n) continued to point the gun at him.

"Stop it," She said.

"(Y/n), he's dying!" He exclaimed.

"Stop it," She repeated. Her hands started shaking, and her eyes filled with tears.

"(Y/n)," Ghost started calmly as he carefully approached her.

"Stop it! I know you aren't really Ghost! Y-You killed him! And then you tried to kill me!" (Y/n) trembled with fear, and doubt.

"(Y/n)," He repeated as he made her lower the gun, "It's me." She started crying and hugged Ghost tightly.

"I thought you were dead!" She cried. As soon as I realized the knife was close enough to grab without breaking from the hug, I took over again, and quickly grabbed it without her noticing.

"Hey (Y/n)?" I started softly. She looked up at me, and I grinned as I stabbed her in the gut.

"I win." She fell to the floor, and a pool of blood formed around her body. She was breathing heavily, and letting tears stream down her face while she held the spot I stabbed her with one hand. I watched her bleed out for a couple of seconds before she spoke up.

"Well, don't just stand there," (Y/n) started weakly, "Kill me."

"If you insist," I chuckled. I put my knife against her chest over her heart.

"Any last words?" I asked.

"Yeah," She started, "You should've watched where the gun was." She shot me in the chest. I laughed as I fell next to her.

"Nice one," I said as I held my chest.

"Burn in Hell," She replied.

"You first," I said as I stabbed her in the chest. She died instantly. I looked over at Toast whom seemed to be waking up. I laughed.

"Of course I missed one," I continued laughing. I heard sirens outside that were quickly approaching. I knew this was it for me and decided to go out on my own terms. Toast watched in horror as I stabbed myself repeatedly, laughing as I did so. I continued laughing and stabbing until I was dead.

"Of course I missed one," I heard someone laugh distantly. I opened my eyes and saw Ghost stabbing himself next to a dead (Y/n), laughing like a maniac. I wanted to run away, to scream, to do anything, but it was like my body wouldn't allow it. I was stuck, watching in horror as he killed himself. Officer Maloney kicked in the door and saw the same scene I did. Ghost finally killed himself as Maloney entered the house.

"Are you okay?" Maloney asked, using a mini flashlight to check my eyes. I tried to respond but all that came out was gibberish. I couldn't saw what I wanted to!

"I'm at P.I.E HQ, we need an ambulance right away. I have an injured man, and two dead bodies I can confirm as Johnny Ghost, and (F/n) (L/n)."

"Oh man, it's him! The sucker and his twin finally died!" I heard a voice say distantly.

"Who's the chick that came with them?"

"I don't know his girlfriend?" I immediately shot awake and collided heads with (Y/n).

"Ow!" She exclaimed rubbing her forehead.

"Damn it!" I said rubbing my forehead. The two I heard talking scampered off.

"What's going on?" I looked over and saw Ghost sitting up.

"Ghosty!" I exclaimed as I tackled him.

"AHH!" He screamed, "Jimmy!?"

"I thought you had left me alone again!" I replied.

"You possessed me!" He yelled back, "I can't leave! I was probably out of it due to the dimensional energy (Y/n) and I was exposed to!"

"I didn't think of that," I giggled, "We're dead anyway, so what difference does it make now?"

"You killed me!" (Y/n) screamed.

"Wait, I'm starting to remember..." Ghost started, "... Jimmy! You killed people! Including us!"

"Of course I did! You didn't even remember I existed until now!"

"And you killed (Y/n)!?"

"We wouldn't be dead if she hadn't shot me, and you hadn't fallen in love with her!"

"You fell in love too! And you KILLED HER because you didn't want to admit it!"

"I don't love her!"

"Yes you do, you idiot!" Ghost exclaimed, "Now apologize, or I will make you!" Ghost was glaring daggers at me.

"I-" He cut me off.

"Jimmy, I've killed you once, and if I have to do it again in the afterlife, which means you are DONE, I will," He threatened.

"Sorry, (Y/n)," I said.

"I guess it's better than nothing," (Y/n) started, "I'll forgive you if you're completely honest about the question I'm about to ask you."

"Shoot," I replied.

"Are you in love with me?"

{HAPPY NEW YEAR! AND YOU'RE WELCOME FOR THE TEARS I JUST GAVE YOU! XD}