Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios (Male Reader)

Babysitting Sally

"If you're dating Jason, I think so." Sally said, making you nod a little. "Can't argue with that logic. You just can't argue with that logic." You stated, patting her head. She giggled and started to play with her toys again.

Hoodie-

Hoodie came over and patted your shoulders. "Watch her. I'll be back in a bit." He said, leaving you to nod and that's how you ended up babysitting.

At the moment, you were laying on the ground. "I lost at hide and seek." You dramatically cried, covering your face. "Oh, man!"

Sally looked down at you and giggled. "It's okay, M/R. No one can win against me." She said, making you peek through your fingers. "No one?"

She nodded before sitting down. "Now, tell me, did you really dress as a maid for an event at your work?" She asked, making you sit up with a chuckle. "Indeed, I did. I was a butler too."

"Really!"

You nodded and crossed your arms. "It was fun. At first, I thought it was gonna be weird but it was pretty cool. Women wore the butler outfit and men wore the maid outfit. Then the next day, it switched."

"You must've been a cute maid." She giggled. You chuckled and nodded. "Yep. I was a pretty handsome butler too." You said, making her laugh before gasping. "Do you still have it? The butler one?"

It took you a moment to think before you nodded. "Yeah, I think so."

That is how Hoodie came back to see you dressed as a butler, treating Sally as if she was princess.

Candy Pop-

Candy simply came and told you to watch her. Before you could say something, he was already gone. You scoffed in disbelief before you looked at Sally, who was standing there with her backpack. "I'm back again." She smiled, making you chuckle a little. "Yeah, you are."

"So, what are you doing?" She asked, walking to your table.

"Just lazing around." You answered, watching her put her backpack on the table. "I am taking a break though. Want to watch what I'm watching now?" You asked, making her gasp and nod.

"Its a funny show." You said, grabbing your remote as she sat next to you. "Okay. What sho-" She paused when you played the episode, watching two characters running in the rain as they yelled. "What are they doing?" She asked, looking at you.

You laughed and shook your head. "They forgot their umbrellas." You answered, Sally looking at the TV. "Can you show me what they were doing?" She tilted her head, making you chuckle and nod. "Okay, let me get a jacket." You said, pausing the show and went to get a jacket.

Minutes later, you had part of the jacket over you head and your arms out. "Nozaki had his jacket like this. Then Chiyo was in front of him." You said, Sally standing in front of you. "This must look funny." She giggled.

"It is." A voice said, making the two of you look to the side to see Candy. He was holding your phone with a grin on his face. Candy refused to delete the photos and makes sure you don't do it.

Dark Link-

Dark left Sally in your care. Didn't say much. Just asked you to watch her then left.

"Hey, M/R?"

You hummed, glancing down at her then your cooking food. "What's up?"

"Did you get hurt when you first met Dark?" She asked, making you snort and shake your head. "He was a complete asshole when we first met. He tried to kill my friend. He left me with a scar then I had to get rid of a pile of bones." You huffed at the reminder.