What if?

Calypso keeps a hero

"So right now I can have a crazy and obsessed boyfriend that hypnotized me, or be a god with Thalia and Annabeth, it be a demigod with Annabeth and Thalia. What else?" The raven haired demigod asked himself, scratching his neck.

"You decide, you hero. What is it you wish to see?"

"Well, I have always wondered what would happen if I stayed with calypso," Percy said, getting transferred to the island once again.

"That does not do wonders to my stomach," Percy grumbled under his breath, before looking at his surroundings.

He was on a familiar beach, looking out to the waves that crashed against him. Percy looked over to calypso, who knew he had to leave.

But the real question was, did he want to?

Although this Percy has traveled back in his time, he was overwhelmed by the same feelings he had last time. Feelings that he might end up liking the cursed girl that had cared for him.

It was these feelings the hero chose to listen to, like he almost did all those years ago.

"Calypso?" Percy called out, motioning calypso to come stand next to him on the beach.

"It's okay, I was cursed to be like this. You won't be the first to go. Just say you wish to leave olgea,"

"I wish," Percy started, staring at calypso, "to stay on olgea,"

Calypso was shocked, never in a million years did she think the charming hero in front of her would chose her.

Percy smirked, "that is, if I'm welcome to stay,"

The brunette jumped into his arms, hugging him tighter than she ever had before. The son of posiedon smiled, "I'll take that as a yes,"

"Of course it's a yes. Here, I'll show you to your room," calypso said, taking percys hand.

Calypso lead Percy to the small house she had, and sat on the bed. The son of the seas just smiled at her, "you know, if I'm going to stay here, I have a few things I'm gonna need to do each day,"

Percy leaned forward, grabbing calypso and kissing her gently. There lips parted after a moment, both of them smiling.

After a lot of talking, the two decided to head to sleep, only for Percy to be enturrupted by, you guessed it, the fates!

Percy was back in the black area, knowing he had to see what his future would be like. "So now I get to see my future?"

"Yes, Perseus," the three fates answered, sending him to the future.

Percy say up groggily, unaware he had done that in many different realities. The world was spinning, but Percy recognizes the place he was in.

"Hey perce," calypso said, giving him the loving smile he fell in love with all those years ago.

"Hey Calypso," he said, groaning slightly at the pain. He didn't remember much, just that they were trying to escape the island together. "What happened?"

"We escaped. But the power of keeping the waves steady, you fell into a coma once we reached shore. I called in help and we made it to camp half blood,"

"How long was I out?"

"It's been two months,"

"Have you gotten settled in?"

"Yeah. I didn't have a cabin so I've slept at the big house for now. Do you want to go see everyone?"

"I'm not sure how many people I really know. Who took over the prophecy?"

"A demigod by the name of nico DI Angelo. Quite popular at camp actually,"

The two walked through the camp hospital, finding the camp Percy had been years ago.

"Hey seaweed brain," A voice said from behind the two.

Percy turned around to see Annabeth chase. Although they had not seen each other in years, perch remembered his friend.

Annabeths normally curly blond hair was instead straitened, pulled back in a ponytail. Her grey eyes didn't calculate him, instead they just showed joy.

"Wise girl," Percy replied, running up to hug the blond.

"We thought you were dead," Annabeth said.

"I'm not. I'm sorry, I just couldn't leave calypso,"

"Your fine, though we could've used you in the war between Gaia,"

"How many people were lost?"

"A hundred and twenty three,"

"Who?"

"A bit of everyone. Including six of the seven,"

"Who's the seven?"

"They were the prophesied heroes. I'm the only one of them that remains,"

"I'm so sorry. Annabeth, is Grover...." Percy trailed off.

"He's alive, he's off on a quest with will solace. I'll tell you when he's back,"

"I'd like that. Oh, and Annabeth?"

"Yeah?"

"I want to introduce you to my girlfriend, calypso,"

The camp continued to talk, and when night fell, the young hero was taken back to the fates dream land (it's not an amusement park).

Regaining all of his memories, he just wondered why he had abandoned her, knowing she would become cold hearted when he did.

"So that worlds not bad, causes me a lot less hurting,"

"You havnt seen it's future,"

"What?" Percy said before he was taken to the future.

The world was burnt, darkness consuming it all. For once, Percy wasn't in his body, more like watching.

The man on the throne looked like him. The raven hair was messy, and a crown was on his head. The difference was that the sea green eyes of the hero were instead blood red.

Annabeth knelt before him, covered in scars and bruises, "what is it you want me to do, my lord?"

"Go fetch Zeus. It was her birthday, so I'll get her a present,"

When the room was abandoned and only the two percys remained, the grinning crazy one looked at the horrified demigod in front of him.

"What happened to you?" The younger one asked.

The Kung of Olympus looked grim, "they killed her. We had gotten back after she had been punished and they just killed her!"

"You're not serious. You didn't do it, right?"

"Let's just say dear old dad and his family isn't here anymore. The only one alive is zues, only made for being tortured,"

"I become evil?"

"You become powerful," the other Percy corrected.

"No. Take me back fates! Take me back!"

The demigod was back to the blackness, realizing not all futures were good. Percy could be a god the right way, be a demigod and be able to die, be inslaved to love someone, or become a corrupt and evil king.

And the worst part was, Percy didn't hate the last option.

New chapter! How did y'all like the evil Percy? I thought it would be a nice touch. Remember, if you have any ideas, comment them and I'll get to them soon.