Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

~First Argument~

Authors Note: 

One of these will not be an argument. I'm sorry in advance.

Nightmare_Pixie

*********

Jeff the Killer

Jeff was back, asking about his knife again, "Are you sure it's not here?" He started searching your house very thoroughly, almost turning the place inside out. You were upset because he didn't believe you about his knife not being at your house.

"Your knife isn't here!" You crossed your arms, I don't know what more I have to do to make you understand that!"

"Are you saying that I'm stupid?" Jeff asked, stopping his search.  He was glaring at you now, crossing his arms too.

"No! I was just saying that you aren't getting it!" You replied in a huffy manor.

"So... You're saying I'm ugly?!" Jeff snarled at you, stalking towards you like he was going to hurt you.

"W-What?! N-No! Where did you even get that from?! Do you need mental help?! Obviously you do because you kill people for fun!" You backed away from him, trying to find something if you need to defend yourself against him.

"AT LEAST I HAVE FUN! YOU ABIDE BY THE RULES YOUR PARENTS SET!" Jeff shouted at you, and then the yelling match was set into motion.

"WELL YOU CARVED A FREAKING SMILE INTO YOUR FACE!"

"AT LEAST I KNOW HOW TO USE A KNIFE!"

"OH YEAH, BECAUSE CARVING YOURSELF UP LIKE A JACK O LANTERN SAYS THAT YOU KNOW HOW TO USE A KNIFE!" You growled, turning your back on him. 

"DON'T TURN YOUR BACK ON ME!" Jeff shouted at the top of his lungs.

"Just did," You replied, ending the argument and leaving the room. Jeff stomped towards the door, finding his knife on the coffee table in your room.

"FOUND MY KNIFE AND IT WAS HERE!" Jeff yelled before leaving your house.

*********

Slenderman

You and Slenderman were mid-argument in the middle of the forest. No animals dared come within one hundred feet of you two. Slenderman was upset because you had sought him out to explain about Kevin. You were upset because he didn't want to hear it. He was trying his best to ignore you and you were trying your best to get him to listen, but eventually he just snapped.

"I don't care! You care more about him than you do about me!" Slenderman yelled at you.

"How can you say that? I lov- I like you! I'm dating you, not him!" You tried to make him see reason, but he was too upset.

"Y/N, you were in the tree with him! OUR TREE!" Slenderman shouted.

"WE HAVE ALL THE TREES!" You hissed at him, gesturing to the whole entire forest.

"THAT ONE WAS THE ONE WHERE WE SAT TOGETHER AND LOOKED AT THE STARS WHILE YOU WERE CAMPING. THE SPOT WHERE I REALIZED YOU WERE MINE!" Slenderman took a deep breath to compose himself, "But I see now that I was wrong. I see that you're nothing more than another pathetic human." 

You looked at him, completely hurt all over again, "Pathetic human?"

"Yes... Now, get out of my sight before I regret not killing you," Slenderman hissed, causing static to start irritating you. 

"I'm not pathetic, Slenderman," You replied, getting choked up before running off towards your house. You cried as you dashed away.

Slenderman felt horrible because he knew he made you cry, which was something he most definitely did not want to do... He was in love with you after all, not that he wanted to tell you that because of what he thought was going on.