Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenarios

~When He Meets Your Parents~

Jeff the Killer

Your father/mother stared at Jeff. They were terrified at his appearance, open eyes and a carved smile. Finally they spoke, "Uh... So... You're name is Jeff... What do you do for living?"

Jeff gestured to his face, "Amateur plastic surgery."

You giggled, which earned a frown from your parent/s. Your mother/father told Jeff, "Obviously that isn't true because you're too young to have been through enough years of college to become a plastic surgery. What do you actually do?"

"That is for me to know... Your daughter already knows, so I see no reason to tell you. If you are worried about me not being able to provide for Y/N, then you just need to stop worrying. I will always be able to provide for her," Jeff was serious. If he didn't have that smile carved into his face, his lips would've been set in a hardline.

Your parent/s nodded, "Alright... So... Why does your face look so... Mangled?"

"A story we won't go into on our first meeting..." Jeff answered,  "I will tell you that having no eyelids has it's downsides as well as upsides."

"Oh... You honestly have no eyelids," You parent/s commented.

"Nope... I burned them off," Jeff answered.

Your parent/s gave you a concerned look before looking back to Jeff, forcing a smile, "Well... Uh, nice meeting you Jeff..."

*********

Eyeless Jack

He'd really already meet your parent/s on your birthday. So when he showed up it was more of just you two hanging out with your parent/s.

"So... Jack, what would you like for dinner? You're the guest so-" You cut your mother/father off.

"Uh, don't give Jack that kind of power!" You exclaimed.

Jack frowned behind his mask, "Whatever is fine, Ms./Mr. L/N. (A/N: L/N = Last Name)" He "looked" at you, "Just because I have an acquired taste for an organ you don't eat doesn't mean you gotta be mean."

You blushed, "It's where you get those organs from that is bad... But, I'm sorry about that." You kiss the cheek of his mask, "I wish you'd let me see you underneath that."

Jack got all flustered and crossed his arms, "Maybe... After you prove your love to me?"

"How am I- Oh you nasty...." You made a playfully disgusted face.

"Just saying... How can I be sure a fan girl like you won't snap a picture of my face and then leave me?" Jack asked.

Your parent/s were simply listening in on your conversation. You rolled your eyes, "Oh if only you could see me..."

"Believe me... I want to... But I don't need to see to know that you are the most beautiful person in the world," Jack smiled faintly behind his mask.

Your parent/s smiled, "Aww.... You two... So cute...." They finally went to go cook dinner.

*********

Laughing Jack

You, your parent/s, and L.J were all sitting at the table. You all were having dinner, L.J sprinkling some small candies on his food. Your parent/s watched him curiously,  "Uh... Are you sure you're gonna eat that?"

"I'm not bound by the same rules, or dull tastes, like you mortals," L.J replied,  "So... Yes, I'm going to eat this."

You smiled slightly, "You might need to explain that, L.J..."