Arthur-
Arthur would drop everything. Who cares what Dutch wants him to do now? Who cares about what the gang needs right now? Who cares if somebody needs him to something that somebody else could do instead?! All he needed to do was get you back to the camp where it is safe, back by his side. He would waste no time going to find you, he was already out of the camp when others began to follow him to help him. He wasn't going to wait for them but he appreciated the help.
Once he had brought you back to the camp he would fuss over you a little, making sure that you were alright and not hurt too badly. He would blame himself a little for letting you get captured but you would assure him that it isn't his fault. He wouldn't let you do anything until you were completely healed from any wounds that the O'Driscolls gave you, and he would check on you all the time. He would only ever leave your side if he was given no choice because Dutch wanted him to do something. But once you were back on your feet he wouldn't be too worried about you because he knows that you can take care of yourself, but he would always keep an eye on you, just because he cares about you.
Dutch-
When Dutch found out that you were captured by the O'Driscolls, he would only be focused on getting you back to the camp where you are safe and where you are with him. He would get the whole gang together, figuring they were more likely to get you back safely if there was more of them, and they would all go out searching for you.
The ride back to the camp would be a little quiet, he was relieved to have you back but was still calming himself down from all of his worrying. Once you got back to camp he would take you back to your shared tent, telling the other to not disturb you. He would make sure that you rested, got some food and water because he just knew that they hadn't treated you well at all. When after assuring him that you were fine he would still worry, keeping an eye on you as much as he could and never leaving the camp so that he could be by your side.
Micah-
As soon as Micah found out that you were captured by the O'Driscolls captured you he was furious. He headed straight out to find you, not caring if the others followed but he did shout at them to "fucking move" when he was riding out of the camp. He wouldn't be patient, he would go in guns blazing and killing any O'Driscoll that got in his way or tried to stop him from getting you back to safety
Once he got you back to the camp and made sure you weren't too badly hurt, he would start lecturing you about being more careful whether it was your fault or not. You would just watch him while he paced back and forth shouting at you, you knew that he was just worried and cared about you but didn't want to admit it. You would roll your eyes and assure him that you are fine, giving him time to calm down. That's when he would finally calm down, mumbling an apology before sitting beside you. He wouldn't let you out of his sight after that, he wasn't going to lose you again.
Charles-
Charles would try to remain calm and level headed when he found out that you were captured by the O'Driscolls, he knew that he had a better chance of getting you back safely if he remained calm and collected, but the longer it took to find you the more worried and restless he became. When they found you he would get a few other members of the gang, anyone who offered to help him, and go to get you back.
Once he got you back to the camp he would take care of you, getting you food and water, making for to deal with any wounds you got while you were captured, but he mainly tried to get you to lay down and relax. When he decided that you were aright, he would lay with you and comfort you until you were ready to get back to normal. He would try not to fuss over you because he knew that it would start to annoy you, but he would look out for you just like he always did.
Javier-
As soon as Javier found out that you had been captured by the O'Driscolls all of his attention and energy was on finding you and bringing you back to him. When they figured out where you where he wasn't going to wait around while thinking of some sort of elaborate plan, no, he just jumped onto his horse and rode out of the camp knowing that the others would follow behind him.
Once Javier got you back to the camp he wouldn't leave you alone. He would make sure that you are alright before he didn't anything, but then he wouldn't leave you. He would tell you that he was sorry for letting this happen and that it would never happen again, you assured him that everything was fine and nothing was his fault. Afterwards he wouldn't let you leave the camp alone, at least for just some time, and he would try to spend as much time with you as possible.
Sean-
Sean was known for acting before thinking, and when he found out that the O'Driscolls captured you he would instantly go to find you, even against the advice of the others in the camp. Once he found you he would head straight there, and some other members of the gang would go with him mainly so that he didn't get both of you killed by doing something drastic or stupid.
Once Sean (with the assistance of the gang) killed or scared off the O'Driscolls, he would pull you into a hug before you could really process what was happening. He would bury his face in your neck and apologise before promising that nothing like this would happen to you again. When he got you back to the camp he would make sure you were alright but then not let you out of his sight, just holding you and telling you that he wouldn't let you go again, making you laugh by surprising you with kisses.
Requests?