CREEPYPASTA X READER

CHAPTER 12

2nd Person's POV
"Well? Do we have a problem?" You repeated.
"Yes! Of course we have a fucking problem! Why the hell are you flirting with that bitch?!" Jeff screamed.
"Do you do anything but scream?" You scoffed.
"Answer me!"
"I have nothing to say to you, there's nothing between us so I don't owe you an explanation."
"B-but" you chuckled, stepping towards him.
"Are you jealous? You're hurt that I'm making Jane my bitch and not you?" Jeff said nothing. You walked around him, kicking the back of his knees causing him to kneel. You lowered to his level, "you want to be with me, huh? You're so fucking jealous, it reeks"
"S-shut up"
"This is why I like Jane~ she's so submissive and breedable~ hiding behind you just to seem tough, what an idiot. But I like you too, the bratty subs that need to be put in their place~ I'll gladly do it~" you purred and straightened up.
"Come to my room tonight and I'll put you in your place for good~" And with that you disappeared. Jeff felt himself stir in his pants at the thought. Since when did he like that? He huffed and stood up, walking home alone.

-TIMESKIP-
Jane came to you when you returned, "Are you ok?" She asked.
"Of course, now if you'll excuse me, I have a little business to take care of" you chuckled and walked away, going to Ben's room.
"Oh Ben~" you called out, entering the room.
"Gah! What the fuck do you want?" He gasped, startled. You tutted, "Now now elf boy, is that anyway to talk to your superior?" Your heterochromia eyes gleamed.
"Superior, my ass" he scoffed. You chuckled, you loved this attitude. Stepping into the room, you disappeared, the door locking.
"Bennn~" your voice echoed in the darkening room. He panicked, backing into a corner. "YoU sHoUlDn'T hAvE dOnE tHaT~" your voice whispered in his ear before he felt you grab him by the throat. He squeaked, thrashing in your grasp.

Your form materialized, smirking at him.
"Be A gOoD bOy FoR mE, oK bEnNy~?"
He nodded in fear, swallowing thickly.
"You're actually quite cute, you know that right? Unlike Jeff. I just don't understand why you have to be so stubborn." You spoke, tracing his lips.
"I-I"
"You don't have an explanation, you were just following Jeff around like a dog, pathetic" you scoffed. He whimpered slightly making you raise your eyebrow, "Oh so you like being degraded? Interesting~ I'm going to have so much fun with you~" you laughed, tendrils coming out.

Those things are being used for nothing but sin, sigh

He gulped at the sight of them, "Tell me Ben, would you let me have my fun with you?" You asked. He nodded, "words Benjamin" you growled, squeezing his throat.
"Y-yes ah!"
"Good boy~" you praised and kissed him, your tendrils stripping him to his underwear. He moaned against your lips, kissing back.

He was skilled, you'd give him that

You pulled away and sat down on a nearby beanbag, pulling him to straddle your thigh. He instantly caught on, mind clouded with lust as he begun rutting against it, moaning in pleasure. You mentally captured the sight of the smaller boy fucking your thigh, desperately chasing his high.
"Fuck~ I'm close~ mm~" he moaned.
"Cum for me~"
He came, creaming his boxers and panting hard. You swapped places swiftly, pinning him down on the seat, "see you later, elf boy~" you cooed and disappeared. Ben laid there, catching his breath. Damn

-TIMESKIP AGAIN-
Jeff walked to your room that night, multiple thoughts running through his head as he approached the familiar door. Knocking, the door opened and he stepped in, closing it behind him. He saw you sitting at the edge of your bed before he dropped to his knees, avoiding eye contact which suprised you.
"Wow, I'm almost impressed, almost" you commented, getting up and walking to him.
"You're a bad influence Jeffrey, both Jane and Ben are fucking subs who are kissing ass to you and are afraid to be themselves" you spoke and grabbed his hair. He hissed at the feeling, looking you in the eyes.
"Why are you like this? Why must you be so difficult?" You sighed. He groaned when you pulled the hair, getting turned on.
"You like it rough huh? Not surprised honestly, you're just a little bitch who needs to know his place" you giggled and slapped him across the face. He moaned at the sting, "Do it again"
"Masochist, typical" you rolled your eyes but did it again, the skin reddening at the impact. Your tendril slipped into his pants and boxers, grabbing onto his cock.
"I see why Jane was drooling after you, pretty big but I've felt bigger" you commented, stroking him. He moaned, grabbing onto your pant leg, earning himself another slap.
"Did I say you could touch me?"
"N-no I'm sorry"
"Good, try again"
"C-can I touch you?" He begged. You hummed, teasingly before taking your tendril out of his pants.
"I don't know, can you?" You taunted, lightly stepping on his cock with your boots. His moans increased but kept his hands to himself.
"You can touch me. Get yourself off like a dog" you ordered. By this time, all Jeff's pride went out the window as he began humping your foot.
Enjoying the sight, you laughed, pressing more on his crotch. His body shuddered and he moaned out making you raise an eyebrow.

He came... without permission

"Fucking stupid, couldn't even ask for permission before cumming." You tsked and removed your foot.

"Looks like I'll have to train you~ isn't that right?" You knelt behind him, grabbing his neck. You sank your sharp teeth into the flesh where his neck met his shoulder, blood squirting out as he cried in pain. You drank a bit and pulled away, a mark left as Jeff fell forward, numb.

"YoU'rE mInE~" Jeff felt the collar wrap around his neck tightly, taking his breath away and causing the new wound to sting.

"Go to your room, I'm done with you...for now"

Later that day, you were making your way to Slenderman's office to inform him about some things. Entering without knocking as usual, you began speaking. "So Slenderman I- WHAT?!"
The pair at his desk jumped, separating. There, at his desk, was a shirtless Slenderman.

He was hot, ngl but he was like a father to you so gross.

(I'mma but a little visual here for your viewing pleasure~)

(Credits to the owner!!!)

That wasn't even the surprising part!

The surprising part was the collar around his neck and the leash leading to the hand of one person that shocked you...

"MOM?!"