Title: Reminiscence
Author: nameless_noelle
Title: (5/5)
Cover: (5/5)
Description: (8/10)
Plot: (20/20)
Characters/Emotions: (20/20)
Writing Style: (15/15)
Grammar: (10/10)
Enjoyment: (5/5)
Total: (88/90)
Overall Review:
**WARNING: SPOILER ALERTS**
So the title was definitely unique. I could tell that it carried meaning behind it. The cover was also good, it was simple but appropriate for the story. The description was pretty good too. All I would say is that it was a little short, I wish there was a little more detail.
Okay, I haven't read many one shots, but this one was sooo good. You did an excellent job of setting the scene. I felt like I was watching a movie while reading. I could really feel the emotions of the characters and their pain. Although the plot was quite sad, it was unique and definitely not something you see often in fanfics.
I like how you did Jungkook and Isla's relationship. I could tell there were so much happiness and pain between them. It was really sad that they ended up divorcing. Then with what happened with Jihun, I couldn't imagine losing a child. The pain that Isla felt and the way you described it, was very accurate and realistic.
Although this story didn't have a happy ending, that wasn't needed. The reality is that not everything has a happy ending where the man and woman get to be together. Life unfortunately doesn't work that way. I like how you didn't go for anything too cliche but made the story your own.
I'm genuinely upset that this book has so little reads. It's a beautiful story and definitely needs more spotlight. Thank you for letting me review your book, author-nim!
Please remember to leave a comment so I know you saw this!
~~~
As this is the last review of batch three, I guess I'll have to open batch four huh?
It probably won't take long, so don't worry. Thank you for reading!
Until the next batch, my lovely readers ^-^