Gilmore Girls - What Should H...

By Erin_Chilton

21.7K 1K 190

This story is about what could have happened had Lorelai not run away with Rory as a baby but had still not m... More

prologue
1. At Last
2. Spreading Like Wild Fire
3. School Work, Dinner's, Intention's and Goodnights
4. Long Weekend Surprise
5. Good Day's
6. Birthday Fun
7. Birthday shenanigans
8. So Much To Celebrate
9. Holiday's and Sweet 16
10. Birthday Boy
12. Arrangements and Loopholes
13. Australia
14. Final Prep and Arrivals
15. Last 48 Hours
16. Till Death Do Us Part
17. Honeymoon Hijinks
18. Honeymoon's Over
19. Holiday Festivities
20. Summer Break
21. Graduating with Honors
22. Summer Getaway
23. The Big Announcement
AN: sorry
24. Fall Fun
25. Holiday's Away.
26. Love Is In The Air
27. Babies Galore
28. Babies and Baby shower's
29. New Years New Titles
30. Not A Fool
31. Happy Times and Sad Events
32. Life's Surprises

11. Tell Me More and Valentines

570 27 6
By Erin_Chilton

At a table away from the guys

"So where did you and Logan really go?" Paris asks smirking

"Like he said we went to talk and have some time alone" Rory says

"Then what was with the look when Robert insinuated all you really did was kiss" Steph asks

"I know that look on my brothers face... please tell me you two didn't..... Because I know he doesn't have anything with him" Honor says

"Oh no, no, no, no... I don't think this is something I should really talk about with you here honor" Rory says

"Oh please he will talk to me about it later anyway, well I will get it out of him at least," Honor says

"So are you still intact?" Steph asks

"Umm I think so.... Oh god, he put his finger in me" Rory says

"You're still intact," Steph says smirking

"What all happened and How did it happen anyway?" Paris asks

"Well we where making out and then I felt ready to take it further and so we just let things happen and I kind of went down and then he reciprocated" Rory says

"Oh our little Rory is growing up. So how was it" Honor says laughing

"Wow.. He's good, amazing. I have never felt anything like that" Rory says smiling

"That's good that he was able to satisfy you the first time, most guys it takes a bit of time to figure out," Steph says

"Well, You cant accuse me of being the most virginal here still at least" Rory says looking at Paris

"Well... I'm not exactly that innocent either" Paris says

"WHAT......" the girls all say looking at Paris

"Well, I kind of maybe gave a guy a hand job once or twice or so" Paris says quietly

"When.. Your never alone with any guy's other then maybe.... Oh god... Tristan?" Rory asks

"Eww no not him.... Another guy" Paris says

"Paris your parents don't let you near guys in less it's a group activity with us, So he would have to be one of us... Who is it?" Steph asks

"Promise you wont make fun of me or judge" Paris asks

"Ok, Who?" Honor asks and everyone nods in agreement

"Robert" Paris says

"Excuse me? Did you say Robert the creeper... wait he stopped being a major creeper a few months ago, Paris when did this start?" Rory asks with her eyes wide

"Around the time he stopped being such a creeper.... I kind of made a deal that we could secretly see each other and continue things if he stopped being so creepy all of the time" Paris says

"OMG, Paris.... Do you like him really or just taking one for the team?" Steph asks

"It happened once when we were drinking a lot, I was fairly buzzed and I had a small crush on him so next time we made the agreement and we haven't ever been alone..." Paris says

"So you mean someone was there when this happened?" Honor asks

"Yes, it would start when people started to get in the car so we were forced to sit closer and then no one would be really paying attention to what we were doing and my hand would slip under his coat or whatever was over his lap and into his pants. I would do it carefully so no one would see or hear anything, when his head was laying back and he looked like he was resting his eyes he was umm in the moment and trying to be discrete" Paris says

"Oh my god Paris, your really not a prude stick in the mud" Steph says

"Nope, but please don't tell anyone about this, If anyone else found out I would be mortified and if my parents found out I would be shipped off to a convent to live until they find me a husband" Paris says

"We wont tell anyone" Honor says

The boy's at the bar

"Now that Robert's not here tell us the truth" Tristan says

"I did tell you the truth, we did just go to talk" Logan says

"Talk and make out of course but what was with the look on Rory's face when Robert mentioned using your mouths?" Tristan asks

"I don't know, maybe because we did make out and stuff" Logan says

"By stuff you mean, down low?" Finn asks smirking

"Dammit Finn. I'm only saying something because I know one of you will get it from her and I know honors probably getting it out of her now" Logan says

"Oh Logan got birthday...." Finn says being cut off

"Goddammit. Quiet and Don't make it sound so cheap" Logan says

"OMG, Rory didn't...." Colin says

"No, no. She is still virginal, we just fooled around a bit, satisfied each other" Logan says

"What, how did you get her to do something?" Colin asks

"She did it all on her own I just reciprocated and boy is she amazing, if I didn't know any better I would think she had practice" Logan says

"Apparently lollipops, ice pops and such are good practice" Tristan says

"What?" Colin asks looking at him

"Steph told her that they are good practice and she asked me if I thought it was true" Tristan says

"Wait... She asked Steph and you... So did you know she was planning this?" Logan asks

"I figured she was planning on it someday of course, I had no idea when" Tristan says

"When did she ask you this?" Logan asks

"Oh about a month or so ago" Tristan says

"You had this knowledge and didn't tell anyone?" Finn asks

"It's not my place to tell anyone. Its between her and Logan she just asked my opinion" Tristan says

"What else do you know that you haven't said anything about?" Colin asks

"I know a lot, the girls seem to trust me about things and ask my opinion and I pick up on things" Tristan says smiling

"Name one thing you have observed" Logan asks

"Robert has been less creepy to the girls in the last few months, He's been getting some relief from someone other than himself," Tristan says

~Robert walk up~

"What where you boys talking about?" Robert asks

"Oh just how you have been getting some action and not sharing like usual" Colin says

"It's nothing big, I have just been getting handjobs from a girl," Robert says

"Who may this girl be?" Finn asks

"A girl I kind of like, I wont risk saying who as if her parents found out they would send her far away and I would never see her again" Robert says

"Only girl I have seen you even sit close to is Paris and I don't see the prude ever doing anything like that" Logan says

"I do, I see a lot of things around, in looks and smirks," Finn says smirking at Robert

"Finn... don't....." Tristan says

"Wait, are you insinuating it's Paris... Paris the prude is giving Robert hand job's when... they are never alone or close enough other then in the... OH SHIT" Colin says

"Woah, Paris gives you hand job's in the car? Oh god that's why you rest your head back so often" Logan says

"Shh guys, please don't tell anyone I can't risk anyone else finding out she would be horrified and her parents would kill me and send her away," Robert says

"Mate, we wont tell anyone" Finn says

"Thank you, don't even let her know that you know she may break things off with me and I really do like her a lot" Robert says

The rest of the night everyone had a lot of fun, they danced, they sang, they drank, and Logan opened the presents everyone had for him. No one mentioned anything that was private or a secret about that night, and all was well in the land of high society teens.

At the end of the night, everyone went to their own homes to get ready for valentines day at school the next day.

February 14th, 2000

~Logan knocks on Rory's front door~

"Happy Valentines day babe, You ready to go?" Logan asks kissing her on the cheek

"Yes I am, no help from my jewelry thief of a mom," Rory says raising her voice, so her mom hears

"I didn't steal anything, and you forgot you let me borrow them," Lorelai says

"No, I didn't, I asked you if you saw them and you lied and said no until I found them in your room. Goodbye mom" Rory says before closing the front door

"what did she take this time," Logan asks chuckling

"My earrings and bracelet, she knows they are off limit," Rory says

"Oh I'm sure you will find a way to make her pay for taking them too, you know I have always liked that blue dress of her's that she let you wear once," Logan says smirking

"Oh, the one that you said makes me look like belle when I put my hair back?" Rory says knowing very well

"Yes, I do believe that is the dress," Logan says smirking

"Maybe it will just end up disappearing from her closet into yours," Rory says smirking

The rest of the day went as any usual day would other than the chocolate roses that were handed out to the girls whose boyfriends and secret admirers bought for one of the various fundraisers the school has year round. They also had a valentines lunch theme, the bowls and plates were shaped like hearts, they had heart cookies for dessert, and the drinks were decorated with heart and cupid stickers.

At the end of the school day at the front gate, Logan suddenly stopped and turned around

"Logan" Rory says as she bumps into him

"Sorry babe I just wanted to say I love you," Logan says as he pulls out a little red box

~Rory opened the box and gasps~

"Logan... It's beautiful" Rory says

"It's almost as beautiful as you. I was thinking, we are in a committed relationship, and I want people to know I'm taken, and we both know you like sparkly things so I thought we could wear ring's" Logan says

"I will, but you don't have too," Rory says

"I want to wear a ring, we can tell our family's they are purity rings, and that may just make them so happy they start planning our wedding long before we get to that point," Logan says smirking

"My grandparents would just love you even more, as for wedding plans I think they would be planning cotillions and ball's for us before wedding plans," Rory says laughing

"Well it's really all leading to the same thing essentially," Logan says

"Yes it is," Rory says

~Logan and Rory put the rings on each other's right finger's~

Everyone around them cheered, The girls awe'd and the guys smiled knowing Logan had it bad.

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

59K 1.5K 41
Rory's pregnant. Will she tell Logan? Heartache strikes, relationships bent, and more. This is book 1 and there will be a book 2. (Completed) I'm not...
2K 48 19
Briella Lorelai Gilmore is the Daughter of Rory Gilmore and Logan Huntzberger. Rory had Briella at 22 after she graduated from Yale she left her behi...
3.5K 183 15
What Rory's life could've looked like after college if things had gone a little differently.
70.2K 1.7K 52
This story takes place 7 years after Rory turned down Logan's proposal. What happens when Logan and Rory run into each other in New York City? Loga...