This is one of the many suggestions I'll be doing. Here's what I made from this comment. Btw, this should probably be mentioned since some might not get the memo. Cyrus is bi in this one, not gay.
—————
Cyrus and Andi met at the Spoon, completely disappointed their friend, Jonah. "I just can't believe that he would pull something like this." Cyrus said.
Andi agreed 100%. "I know, right? All this time, and didn't find out until now that he was cheating on us for each other."
Both started laughing. "We're really dumb, aren't we? We hang out everyday, and we didn't even bother to piece that together."
"That is true. But this is still Jonah's fault, isn't it?"
"Oh, yeah. For sure."
——The Next Day——
Jonah walked to Andi when she was by her locker. "Andi, listen. I'm really sorry about what I did. I promise, if you give me another chance, it'll just be you and me."
Andi rolled with eyes with a smile. "You promise?"
"Promise."
"Well, since you put it like that, no."
"No?"
"You heard me! I don't care if you're choosing me now. You still cheated on me. And you cheated on Cyrus. We both really liked you, but after what you did, it's the complete opposite."
Jonah tried to say something, but Andi ignored him as she walked away.
—————
"You're joking, right?" Cyrus said. "Jonah seriously tried to convince you to date him again?"
Andi was just as shocked. "It was so dumb! He is so desperate for a date!"
"I blocked him on my phone. How about you?"
"Of course I didn't. If I need to complain about something, I'm going to send like 3 page essays to him. Be honest, nobody likes it when someone starts venting, and if I vent to Jonah, it'll annoy him and I'll get to release my anger. It's a win-lose. Perfect for me."
—————
Cyrus set up his table next to where the Frisbee team was. Jonah came up to him. "Cyrus, can I have a water bottle? It's really hot right now."
Cyrus chuckled. "Sure. Here you go." He opened his cooler and gave Jonah an empty bottle.
"Can I have a full bottle?"
"Sorry, bud. We're all out."
One of Jonah's teammates came to the table. "Cyrus, got any water?"
"Yep. Here you go, Luna. Enjoy." He gave Luna a cold and full water bottle, and she walked away in happiness.
Jonah got a bit annoyed at this. "Cyrus. I know I hurt you. I'm really sorry. I promise that it'll be just you and me if you'll take me back."
Cyrus started to laugh hysterically. "You know what's really funny about this, Jonah? Andi said that you told her the exact same thing. Man, it must suck. You try to get both of your exes back, and neither of them want you."
"Fine." Jonah said. "You don't want me back? Then I'm kicking you off the team."
Cyrus started laughing some more. "You know what makes this even more hilarious? I'm not officially on the team. I'm just Cyrus Goodman, #1 Fan. You technically can't make me leave. So I can continue to torture you with neglect as much as I want."
Another teammate ran over. "Cy, can I have a cold towel?"
Cyrus tossed the towel towards the boy. "Here ya go, Mac."
——2 Weeks Later——
This was Jonah's last attempt. He went to the Spoon to apologize to Andi and Cyrus. But as he walked in, he saw the most unexpected thing ever.
Cyrus and Andi, holding each other romantically in the of the booths, feeding each other baby taters. Just like a couple.
He made a sigh, turned around, and walked out.
Andi chuckled as she fed Cyrus a tater. "What should we do after this, Cyrus?"
"We could go to the ice skating rink," he suggested, "I hear it's pretty fun."
"Hold me if I fall?"
"Of course, Andi. And I won't let go."
—————
I'll be honest. This was actually really fun to write. Everything so far has been Jyrus, or Jandi, or Muffy. I'm happy that this was suggested to me.
Don't forget. There is no limit to how often, and how many time you can suggest Oneshots to me. Feel free to send me a barrage of ideas if you have any.