"It Wasn't Me" by Shaggy

Another brilliant solo sung by William Schuester. I can imagine an episode where he's caught cheating on Emma and he comes to his students for advice and it kills. The other guy singing could be Brad the Piano Player or something, I don't gaf

• • •

"The Way I Am" by Ingrid Michaelson

I could totally see Isabelle Wright sing this! I don't know why she would be singing this song, but I can't help but smile thinking about it.

• • •

"Put Your Head on My Shoulder" by Paul Anka

Just picture Rory singing this song— I'm weak. I'm actually weak.

• • •

"Fresh Eyes" by Andy Grammer

This one was also hard for me to think, but then I remember that the Season 6 newbies exist. Freaking Rodrick. He deserves some love.

• • •

"Chandelier" by Sia

Yes, I am 100% aware they did this song, but the Glee version's chorus sounds an awful lot like Rachel and Kurt, and they weren't even the ones singing it. So, yes, Hummelberry would've owned this duet.

• • •

"Gravity" by Sara Bareilles

This song is wayyyyy underrated. And yes, I do think Tina deserved this solo. I don't think she's much a belter — correct me if I'm wrong — but the song also has a lot of head voice that she could sweep the floors with.

𝘨𝘭𝘦𝘦 𝘥𝘪𝘢𝘳𝘺Where stories live. Discover now