The Three Mermaids

Seth Or Toby

Chapter 19

"Ok," I said. "I will gather water, and you will do something to it."

"Hmm, like what?" Seth asked.

Maybe, enchant it to chain him."

"Ok." Seth replied excited.

I used my hand and turned it towards the water. Water gushed everywhere.

"Omg, I'm screwed!" Toby yelled running around like a baby.

"If you only promised us that you wouldn't tell."

"Ok, I promise. Just let me go." Toby pleaded.

"Fine." I said.

Toby ran out the door screaming. At least he promised to keep quiet. First human boyfriend and he freaks out. Seth came over to see if I was alright.

"So first human boyfriend." Seth said rubbing my back.

"Hey, don't touch me and yeah. How did you know?"

"At least you didn't yell this time. That's a start." He replied taking his hand off my back. "I can read thoughts."

"I guess." I sighed.

"We should do something. Just you and me."

"Sure, I have nothing else to do."

Seth drove to a restaurant close by called Dairy Queen. I have been here a couple of times for my birthday. He stopped the car and waited for me to get out. I jumped out and took Seth's hand. This is nothing I thought. We are just friends.

"Hello, welcome to Dairy Queen. How may I help you?"

"Um, I will take a small chocoholic blizzard." Seth said looking at me.

"I will have a mint shake." I said.

We walked over to find an empty table and sat down.

"Hi Seth." Someone said.

"Hello Maia." Seth replied.

"What are you doing here?" Maia asked.

"Having ice cream with Nikki."

"You wouldn't forget about me, your girlfriend. Would you?"

"Of course not." Seth scooted over. "There's plenty of space."

"You have a girlfriend?" I asked. "How long?

"It's been one wonderful month." Maia replied.

Oh, and now he's a cheater! Perfect! I can't be jealous! He's a warlock! A back stabbing warlock!

"Oh, I forgot that I had a project to work on in school. Sorry got to go." I said leaving whenever the ice cream came out. "I'll take that."

I took the ice cream and left. I knew that Seth was going to run out whenever I was leaving. So I began to go faster.

"Wait, I can explain!" Seth cried out.

"Oh, like last time. When you were a warlock."

I jumped in Seth's car and drove away in it. I didn't care if I crashed. I just had it with boys.

I arrived home within five minutes. Toby was standing at the door along with Seth. Stupid warlock.

"Ok, you really need to choose between us Nikki."

"Hahaha, I choose Toby because he doesn't keep secrets from me."

"Wait, forget about all that has ever happened and choose."

"I-I don't k-know." I stuttered. "I need time. Like a lot of time."

"Fine we will give you two days, and then you will have to make your decision." Seth replied.

"I love you both. Does that count?" I asked.

"No Nikki." Toby said.

"Ugh, I can't choose!" I yelled at them. "I have to much other things to worry about than boys."

"Um, teenage boys." Seth smirked.

"Whatever. Do I have to forget that you did all those things to me, Seth?"

"Yes, that would be fair."

Macy come by later that evening. "You called me."

"Yeah, I can't choose between Seth and Toby." I replied.

"You already know its Toby. He didn't back stab you like Seth."

"Well, Seth said I have to forget that he ever did that because he wants it fair."

"Oh, then Seth. He is so much hotter than Tony."

"It's Toby not Tony."

"Whatever, same thing." Macy stood up.

"You think so?" I asked.

"Well yeah, he looks like Logan Lerman, but blond."

"I know that's what I like about him." I blushed.

"So who's it going to be?" Macy asked leaning closer to me.

"Hey, I need a little time."

"Maybe we can have a sleepover in the process. Like with Emma and Tessa."

"Yeah sure, I'll call them."