In an attempt to improve her resume, history major Soledad Gutierrez, or Sol to her friends (because that's less depressing), decides to join the History Club at her Community college. However, the club at her school is quite peculiar: they have an initiation process. In order to join this club Sol must break into the oldest house in her small Californian town and steal one of their forks. The club members provide all the materials to break in, she just needs to take the utensil, take a selfie in the kitchen, and get out undetected--with the fork, of course.
The problem is: Ethan Winston saw everything that happened inside his grandparent's house, and is quite confused about the whole ordeal.