I Just Can't Stop Loving You...

By dessascorner

28.4K 1.1K 407

Athena Tyler is an Italian-American musician who rose to fame as the lead singer of a girl band with her sist... More

~Intro~
Chapter 1-Born
Chapter 2-Encounters
Chapter 3-Dance
Chapter 4-Neverland
Chapter 5-Book
Chapter 6-Soul Train Awards
Chapter 7-Morning
Chapter 8-Trees
Chapter 9-A Reluctant Suitcase
Chapter 10-Reunited
Chapter 11-Birthday
Chapter 12-Work of Art
Chapter 14-Adrian
Chapter 15-Dance Studio Confessional
Chapter 16-Kayden Tyler
Chapter 17-Fear of the Unknown
Chapter 18-Bond of a Sister
Chapter 19-Death By Dresses
Chapter 20-Floral Day
Chapter 21-More Expectations
Chapter 22-What About Entertainment?
Chapter 23-The Drive of Excellence
Chapter 24-Lionel Richie
Chapter 25-Whispers on Twilight's Path
Chapter 26-Love's Gentle Touch
Chapter 27-Suds & Sisters
Chapter 28-Hypothetical Marriage
Chapter 29-The Mysterious Wife
Chapter 30-Lost Wife, New Connections
Chapter 31-Hairwashing Secrets At the Wedding
Chapter 32-Exemption To the Hair Rule
Chapter 33-Tender Sweetness
Chapter 34-Twisted Ache
Chapter 35-Beyond The Shower Veil
Chapter 36-Under The Tree
Chapter 37-True or False
Chapter 38-Havoc Over a Misunderstanding
Chapter 39-Boiling Eggs
Chapter 40-Excessive Force
Chapter 41-Scandals Piling Up
Chapter 42-Escape The Storm
Chapter 43-And....Back Out Again
Chapter 44-Basement Blues
Chapter 45-Exoneration By Nightfall
Chapter 46-Imagining The Chaos
Chapter 47-Confirming Suspicious Behavior
Chapter 48-Paisley Park
Chapter 49-Michael & Prince
Chapter 50-The Truth Must Be Told
Chapter 51-Lesson Learned
Chapter 52-Tableside Tears
Chapter 53-Meeting Under the Table
Chapter 54-Family Mediation
Chapter 55-The Big Idea
Chapter 56-Dress Haven
Chapter 57-Soft Sheets
Chapter 58-Trail Mix
Chapter 59-The Tables Get Turned
Chapter 60-Bolting From The Scene
Chapter 61-Bora Bora Bash
Chapter 62-Prepare For Takeoff
Chapter 63-Before The Storm
Chapter 64-Mischief & Madness
Chapter 65-Cosmetologist Challenge
Chapter 66-Mayhem at 45,000 Feet
Chapter 67-The Wind Is Blowing
Chapter 68-Lives Tied Into One
Chapter 69-Parental Reflection
Chapter 70-Italia
Chapter 71-The Time For Amends
Chapter 72-Fulfilling A Promise
Chapter 73-Chaos Ensued
Chapter 74-The Rewatch Of Mr. & Mrs. Jackson
Chapter 75-Abby Lee Miller
Chapter 76-Perfecting An Appearance
Chapter 77-The Oprah Winfrey Interview
Chapter 78-Phone Call Mayhem
Chapter 79-Family Gossip
Chapter 80-New Friend, Brotherly Wisdom
Chapter 81-Surprise Visit
Chapter 82-Fatherly Advice Takes Course
Chapter 83-Hotel Shenanigans
Chapter 84-There's A Difference
Chapter 85-Prepare For Takeoff
Chapter 86-The Dynamic Duo
Chapter 87-In The Closet
Chapter 88-Remember The Time
Chapter 89-The First Scandal
Chapter 90-Protective Instincts
Chapter 91-The Last Name Debate
Chapter 92-Enemies Resurface
Chapter 93-Gathering In The SUV
Chapter 94-Hospital Surprise
Chapter 95-Frenzy of Paparazzi
Chapter 96-Ringing Cell Phones
Chapter 97-Gradual Awakening
Chapter 98-Lizzo & Prince Martial Dispute
Chapter 99-Impromptu Photoshoot
Chapter 100-Movie Theatre Antics
Chapter 101-Musical Chairs
Chapter 102-Plan In Action
Chapter 103-Closet of Endless Designer Shirts
Chapter 104-Hayvenhurst Family Dinner
Chapter 105-Evading Tough Matters
Chapter 106-Cuddles at Dusk
Chapter 107-Ecstasy In An Embrace
Chapter 108-Diane Sawyer Interview
Chapter 109-Diane Sawyer Interview: Part 2
Chapter 110-Rumors Circulate Neverland
Chapter 111-Testing Loyalty
Chapter 112-Revenge Scare
Chapter 113-Trapped On Both Sides
Chapter 114-Steamy Shower
Chapter 115-The Real Daytime
Chapter 116-The Jackson Show
Chapter 117-You Are Not Alone
Chapter 118-Solace In Thunderstorms
Chapter 119-Fertility Woes
Chapter 120-Relishing In Television Drama
Chapter 121-Olivia & Finn
Chapter 122-Los Angeles Coffee Shop
Chapter 123-Rearranging The Schedule
Chapter 124-The Shock of a Lifetime
Chapter 125-This Changes Everything
Chapter 126-Sorelle TV
Chapter 127-Sorelle TV: Part 2
Chapter 128-Detained In New York
Chapter 129-Busy In Action
Chapter 130-Lost In Love
Chapter 131-Bailed Out
Chapter 132-Jackson Family Meltdown
Chapter 133-Gather At Neverland
Chapter 134-This Is a Bad Idea
Chapter 135-The Truth Revealed
Chapter 136-Security Footage
Chapter 137-Back To The Bank
Chapter 138-The Return of the Misses
Chapter 139-Closet Rendevous
Chapter 140-Fun Turns To Work
Chapter 141-Dance Rehearsal Interrupted
Chapter 142-The Door Is Shut
Chapter 143-Conflicting News Stories
Chapter 144-Overwhelming Relief
Chapter 145-Trying New Things
Chapter 146-Impatience Comes To Play
Chapter 147-The Worst News A Man Could Get
Chapter 148-Reassurance Comes In Many Forms
Chapter 149-Midnight Intrusion of a Panicked Sister
Chapter 150-To Tell or Not To Tell
Chapter 151-Mama Reggie
Chapter 152-Beach Girls
Chapter 153-The Unexpected Proposal
Chapter 154-Cheryl Portor's Dream Comes True
Chapter 155-Melody McCarthy's Dream Comes True
Chapter 156-Reconnection At Last
Chapter 157-Preparations & Ideas
Chapter 158-Hallway Eruption
Chapter 159-New York Family Meeting
Chapter 160-30th Anniversary Celebration Concert
Chapter 161-9/11 Attacks
Chapter 162-Heart Ache
Chapter 163-James Corden
Chapter 164-Another Round of Musical Personal Belongings
Chapter 165-Superbowl XXXVI
Chapter 166-Neverland Is Officially the Family Meetup Area
Chapter 167-Cat Fight
Chapter 168-The Aftermath
Chapter 169-Throwing Away Pride
Chapter 170-Suds and Love
Chapter 171-The Queen of Pop
Chapter 172-The Will Talk
Chapter 173-Risk of Toxic Shock
Chapter 174-This Is It Rehearsal
Chapter 175-Scared Shitless
Chapter 176-More Talk Show Shenanigans
Chapter 177-Devastation In Motion
Chapter 178-Ronald Reagan UCLA Medical Center
Chapter 179-The Grammy Awards
Chapter 180-Love & Suspicion
Chapter 181-This Is A Life Changer
Chapter 182-We Are The World 25: Part 1
Chapter 183-We Are The World 25: Part 2
Chapter 184-Crowded Hospital Room
Chapter 185-Unwanted Guests
Chapter 186-Prince Michael
Chapter 187-Tough Love
Chapter 188-Reggie's Second Wedding
Chapter 189-Climbing Furniture
PLEASE READ: SURVEY
Chapter 190-The Greatest Night In Pop Documentary
CHARACTER Q & A QUESTIONARE

Chapter 13-Hayvenhurst

354 13 11
By dessascorner

As Michael stepped into Athena's mansion and closed the front door behind him, he called out her name to grab her attention. "Athena! Are you here? I noticed your car parked outside," he exclaimed, his voice echoing through the spacious foyer.

Athena appeared from around the corner, a bright smile on her face as she walked towards him. Wrapping her arms around his torso, she greeted him with genuine warmth. "Hey there," she said, her voice filled with affection. "How are you?" Athena asked, genuinely interested in his well-being.

Feeling her embrace, Michael returned her affectionate gesture and beamed down at her. "I'm doing great," he replied, a hint of excitement in his voice. "How about you?" he asked, genuinely curious about her state of mind.

Athena let go, mindful not to overwhelm him, and replied earnestly, "I'm doing well, thank you." She paused for a moment, her curiosity piqued. "But why are you here?" she asked, a mild sense of confusion in her voice. "Not that I mind having you here, but there must be a reason, right?"

Michael's eyes sparkled as he revealed the purpose of his visit. "I came here to ask if you would accompany me to Hayvenhurst," he explained. "It's the family house where my parents reside. Though technically, it belongs to my parents, some of my siblings still call it home. I left in 1988 after purchasing Neverland," he shared, a touch of nostalgia in his voice.

Athena's eyebrows raised in genuine surprise as she absorbed the information. "You want me to meet your parents?" she asked, a mix of anticipation and apprehension evident in her tone. "And your siblings? While I had the pleasure of meeting your brothers, who are amazing, I can't help but wonder if your sisters will see me in the same light."

Michael countered her worries with confidence, his voice brimming with reassurance. "Janet and Rebbie would never harbor any negativity," he said, his voice filled with utmost belief in his siblings. "And even though LaToya doesn't come around often due to her marriage to a man named Jack Gordon, she's certainly not capable of harboring any ill feelings."

Athena's eyes widened at the mention of Jack Gordon's name. Immediately, she tried to conceal her suspicion, shaking her head dismissively. "Oh, I've heard of him," she blurted out unintentionally. "They say he's quite a nasty character, but perhaps it's just rumors," she added quickly, hoping not to alienate Michael with her doubts.

Intrigued by Athena's reaction, Michael took a seat on the plush couch and gestured for her to join him. "What do you mean by 'nasty'?" he inquired, a twinge of concern coloring his voice. "He's been keeping LaToya away from us, from the family," he explained, his voice tinged with frustration. "He's convinced her that we kidnapped her, and he's doing it all in the name of her protection. It's hard for me to understand. We used to be so close, but ever since he came into her life..." Michael trailed off, his voice heavy with a mixture of longing and disappointment.

"She changed?" Athena empathized with Michael's predicament and nodded sympathetically. "People can change when they're in a relationship," she remarked, her voice tinged with understanding. "It's natural for you to want your sister back. And it's the same for your parents; they simply want their daughter to return home."

Michael offered her a grateful smile, appreciating her understanding. "That's exactly it," he sighed, his voice laced with a mix of sadness and hope. "But I truly believe that meeting you would bring joy to everyone's day," he emphasized earnestly. "My mom and Janet have been pleading with me for months, begging to meet you."

Athena's modesty shone through as she responded with a soft smile. "I may not be all that exciting, but if it would make them happy, I'm more than willing to meet them," she said, her voice filled with warmth. "Just let me grab some flowers or something. Does your mom have a favorite?"

Michael's eyes lit up with a touch of delight. "She adores roses," he shared, his voice tinged with affection that something as little as his mother's favorite flowers was something Athena actually cared about. "The smell of a freshly bloomed rose can brighten her day instantly."

Grateful for the guidance, Athena nodded, her mind already forming a plan. "Okay, roses," she smiled brightly, "Those are my favorite too."

~

The Jackson Family Home, HAYVENHURST—4:30PM

The front door of the big family house opened and Katherine Jackson stood there, grinning happily when she saw who was on her porch.

"Athena Tyler!" she exclaimed with a bright smile, bringing the girl into a warm hug, "I've been waiting to meet you for months!"

"Of course, I'm sorry," Athena smiled at her as she was released, handing her the flowers she had brought, "I was on tour with my sisters. I'm sure you know how that is."

"Thank you. Of course. My sons. Now let me get a good look at you," Katherine nodded, as she took the flowers and handed them off to her son, suddenly grabbing Athena by the shoulders and playing around with her face and hair, "Oh, clear complexion, high cheekbones, strong and pretty hair, beautiful eyes, perfect eyebrows—Michael, my son, she's a keeper!" she calls over to him after he had put the flowers away in a vase.

"Mother!" Michael says with an embarrassed smile, pulling Athena towards him, "Stop that."

"Apologies, dear Athena," Katherine smiled, "I've always wanted to meet you. And now that you're with my son....I got a little excited."

Athena waves it off with a gentle smile, "No problem at all, Mrs. Jackson."

"Oh! You have to meet my daughters!" Katherine laughed and then called up the staircase, "Rebbie! Janet! Latoya!"

"Latoya is here, mother?" Michael asks in surprise.

"Yeah," Katherine nodded, "Jack is away on a business trip so she came over."

Michael and Athena looked at each other and she smiled at him, settling his nerves a little bit. The three girls came running down the stairs, grinning in delight when they saw who was in the house.

"Is this her, Mike?" Janet asked excitedly.

"Yeah, this is—"

"Hi, Athena! I'm Janet."

"I'm Rebbie!"

"I'm LaToya!"

"I'm Michael!" Michael says before everyone looked at him, "What? I wanted in on it too!"

"Hi, Janet, Rebbie, and LaToya," Athena smiles before introducing herself to the girls, "Athena Tallerico."

"I thought it was Tyler?" Rebbie asked thoughtfully.

"It is, technically. That's my stage name." Athena smiled, then laughed, "I still accidentally sign Tyler for legal documents though...." she trailed off thoughtfully.

"I would totally do that!" Latoya giggled as the front door opened again.

"Athena! It's so good to see you again!" Marlon smiled as he brought her into a hug, "We didn't expect you tonight. How are you?" he asked as the rest of the Jackson brothers walked into the house.

"I'm good. You guys look great." Athena said, bringing his hand up and gently kissing it, doing the same for the other brothers after she had hugged them.

"Oh, hello," Joe Jackson said as he walked in after his sons, "You must be Michael's girl. Athena, right?"

"Mr. Jackson," Athena smiled before also kissing his hand, "It's lovely to meet you."

"Time for dinner!" Katherine smiled at the interaction of the raven haired woman and her sons and husband, already knowing Athena must've been raised right from just watching her behavior.

As the night progressed, the Jackson brothers were engrossed in catching up with Athena, recounting their latest adventures, and engaging in playful banter. Marlon, ever the entertainer, cracked jokes that had Athena laughing uncontrollably, while Jermaine shared stories of his recent music projects. Tito, the ever-calm and collected one, engaged Athena in a deep conversation about art and creativity. Jackie spoke to her about music and life.

It was during these moment that Athena truly felt like she belonged with this family. The warmth and acceptance she received from the Jacksons made her feel cherished and loved. In return, she showered each brother with affection and attention, making them feel special in her presence.

As the dinner was served, Katherine, the matriarch of the family, watched with pride in her eyes. She had seen the way Athena effortlessly blended into the family dynamic, embodying the values and principles that she held dear. The way Athena interacted with each brother, sharing kind words and expressing genuine interest, was a testament to her upbringing.

And she was correct in assuming so; as Athena grew up in a very classy family. Well...half of her family was classy anyway. She and Kayden were taught:

1) Dress to Impress.

2) Respect Your Man, as He Should Respect You.

Which was taught to Athena, meanwhile her brother was taught Respect Your Woman, As You Would Your Mother.

The only exemptions to this rule were if the man or woman was just completely and utterly intolerable. In which case, just say nothing and walk away. Don't engage in petty arguments—therefore, sending a message that there is now a boundary between you and that person.

3) How to Treat a Man & How She Should Be Treated By One.

Again, this was taught to Athena, while Kayden was taught this lesson the other way: How to Treat a Woman & How He Should Be Treated By One.

Athena learned this lesson very easily, her brother and father being the people she practiced it on. She took care of them when they were sick, and gave hugs and cuddles. And just as she did with the Jackson family, she also did hand kisses. While Kayden learned this lesson practicing on Athena, his only sister. Basically doing all of the things Athena did, and then some.

4) Love Unconditionally.

Pretty self-explanatory. They were taught to see someone's heart instead of the color of their skin. Because in the end, skin color doesn't matter. We all bleed the same color, we all breathe, we all feel—why intentionally make it your mission to hurt people because society tells you that's what's right?

5) If A Man Wants Your Hand in Marriage, They Need to Ask Daddy's Permission First.

This one was taught specifically to Athena. Though their father has said that he would at least like to meet the person Kayden chooses to marry before it officially happens. Kayden kind of just does his own thing. Meanwhile, Athena actually takes her father's opinion into consideration. So she can respect that her father would want to approve of the person she chooses to marry. After all, she is his only daughter.

"That was great, Mrs. Jackson," Athena says kindly as she gets up from the chair.

"Thank you, Athena." Katherine smiled at her as she and everyone else got up, "After dinner, what we normally do is, the boys usually retreat upstairs and the women get together in the living room."

"Oh, that sounds nice," Athena nodded, "Lead the way."

Latoya, Janet and Rebbie giggled and caught up with Katherine and Athena—giggling because they were so excited that Athena was in their house. They were fans of Sorelle before, which of course, is where they knew her from. And they were also so giggly because they were ecstatic that Michael finally met someone. And hopeful that that someone would soon be a Jackson.

"Thank you for having me in your family home. It's beautiful, by the way. It slipped my mind to say that at the door." Athena says as all the girls sit on the couches.

"So, Athena, how is it dating my brother?" Rebbie asked.

"It's good." Athena said, somehow being successful in not blushing, "He's a gentleman."

"That's my son," Katherine gushed, "I always raised him to be a good man. Joe was too focused on their careers to do any of the teaching or nurturing."

"My mother was the same way," Athena says, "But my father was great. He didn't push for anything, he didn't make us do things we weren't comfortable with. He just let us be....us." she added, "Then again, my parents never married each other so obviously we got different treatment than my mother's other kids."

"So how many siblings do you have?" Janet asked, "I know you have a brother, right?"

"Kayden is my full brother and my sisters are my half sisters." Athena explained, "We all have the same mother, but the other girls have a different father. And my one sister, Reggie, she has a different father than they do."

"So your mother had children with three different men?" Latoya asked, "That's a lot of kids."

"Not much more than what your mom had," Athena smiled, "There's nine here, right?"

"Let's see...." Katherine said, starting to count of her fingers, "Rebbie, Jackie, Tito, Jermaine, LaToya, Marlon, Brandon, Michael, Randy, and Janet—yeah, nine. Well, there would be ten if my son Brandon were here."

Athena frowned, "If you don't mind me asking, what happened to him?"

"He passed away a day after his and Marlon's birth," Rebbie answered, "They were twins."

"Oh my gosh," Athena shook her head, "I'm so sorry. Nobody deserves that."

"Athena, list off your siblings!" Janet grinned excitedly.

"In order?" Athena questioned then got deep into thought about who was born and when before answering the question, "Riley, Reagan, Renae, Reggie, Kayden, Rachel, and then me. I'm the youngest." she shrugged, "Nicole clearly had a thing for 'R' names."

"Nicole?"

"Oh, right. We were told to call her Nicole." Athena looked over at Katherine to explain the situation, "She wasn't mom or mommy or mama. She was just Nicole to us."

"My sons never were allowed to call my husband dad either. They had to call him Joe. I personally never agreed with that, but I just let it be because Joe is stubborn. There's no changing his mind once it's made up." Katherine says quietly so nobody upstairs would hear, "You and Michael are so similar."

Athena slightly smiles at that, "Your son is a gentleman. Even after all that he, or...you all went through."

"He's a fighter. He's got rhino skin, is that what he says?" Katherine questions with a small laugh, "It sounds funny but it's true."

"Rhinoceros!" Latoya laughed.

"I'm glad he has you. And I'm glad you have him," Katherine smiled at Athena, taking hold of the girl's hand, "Take care of my son."

"Of course, Mrs. Jackson." Athena smiled at her, slightly squeezing her hand, "I will cherish him forever."

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

34.2K 1.1K 18
"Michael I don't think this was right. I am a married woman." "Yeah to a man that doesn't love you, let me love you!!" Lena Waters had just moved int...
147K 6K 52
"Imagine yourself a store manager for a St. Louis clothing store by day and a singer in a local band by night. That was me for a while. But then in...
92.5K 3.3K 69
Bad era. -1987 🔥 We were Both students at the University I was an Model and he was an Average guy who also got bullied for being lonely all the tim...
31.8K 1.4K 24
❛ You pay the price of fame, So don't be feeling no pain. ❜ ⸺ ( Michael x black!oc ) Imani Sade, renowned songwriter and musician, has been workin...