The Killers' Nightmare (A Female Creepypastas X Male Reader story)

Chapter 17 | Recovery and meeting the other Residents

"Y-you little b-bitch!" she yelled as a hatchet whizzed through the air towards me. Turning my head to see it spinning at me, a smirk crept across my face.
"That's me" I said smugly, doing a running 360 and catching the weapon with my free hand as it caught up to me. "And this is mine until you learn how to behave" I added, running backwards and waving it around.
"Fuck y-you!" she said, clearly annoyed at me.
"I have a rule. Take me on a date first~" I said with a wink, making her go slightly red and slow down a bit. "Buh-Bye now!" I added, bolting up the stairs and running straight to my room. "Phew" I said, getting inside and locking the door behind me. As I sat against the door and wiped my forehead with my arm, I looked at the plate of food next to me and smiled. "Waffle ti- SHIT!" I yelled as a hatchet smashed through the door above me multiple times, forcing me to move away from where I was sat. After the axe was removed from the door, a familiar face peered through the crack.
"Heeeeeere's T-Tami~" she said, hitting the hole again, making it larger.
"What the fuck, Tami!?" I exclaimed.
"Y-you took m-my waffles!" she yelled back, still whacking the door.
"Do you want them back!? I haven't eaten them yet!" I said, grabbing the plate and holding it in her line of sight. She stopped hitting the door and analysed the plate through the door.

"C-c-can I have m-my hatchet b-back as w-well?" she asked, lowering her weapon.
"Yeah, I was planning in giving it back anyway" I said, grabbing it off of the floor. I cautiously unlocked and opened the door and held out the plate and axe for her to take. "Here you go" I said simply.
"Th-thanks... and h-here" she said, tearing one of the waffles in half and giving it to me.
"Thanks" I said, pulling my mask down and putting the whole thing in my mouth at once. "Glad we could come to an understanding" I added, pulling my mask back up.
"M-me t-too" Tami said, stuffing her face with the waffles.
"Was breaking my door really necessary?" I asked, still chewing what was in my mouth.
"Y-you had i-it coming, y-you took my w-waffles" she answered, still chewing her own food.
"Hey, in my defence, I didn't know they were yours" I said with a shrug.
"Y-you d-didn't see m-my name in p-p-purple sh-sharpy on th-the box?" she asked, finally swallowing.
"I haven't eaten right in forever, I was too hungry to read" I explained, turning around and looking for something to use to cover up the hole.
"W-want me t-to bring you s-s-something real qu-quick?" she asked kindly.
"If you wouldn't mind" I said, a smile under my mask as I gave her a thumbs up over my head.
"N-no problem" she said with a kind smile as she turned to leave and skipped down the hall.

As I rifled through my drawers once again, I couldn't find anything to use initially. However, after a few moments more I managed to find a few rolls of duct tape. 'If you don't take sound proofing into account, this should work perfectly' I thought as I looked for the edge of the roll. After a little bit of continuous picking at the circle, my nail eventually caught a slight lip. "Aha!" I said aloud, glad that I found the edge. Pulling the edge away from the roll, it loudly made the tape noise as plenty of tape was unfurled in my hands. "If I've learned anything in life, it's if you can't fix something with tape... then you're not using enough tape" I mumbled with a smirk as I walked to my door.

(Time skip brought to you by Tami somehow setting a glass of water on fire)

"Aaaaaaaaand, done!" I said after putting the last strip of tape on the door. As if it was on a timer, I heard some footsteps approaching me as soon as I finished 'fixing' the door.
"I-I got you s-some food" Tami's voice said from behind me.
"Thank you very much" I said, turning around and taking a plate out of her hands. Looking at it, I saw some plain yet very burnt toast stacked unevenly on the plate. Looking up from the 'food', I saw Tami looking at me with some very hopeful and expecting eyes. Bracing myself for what I was about to put in my mouth, I pulled my mask down and took a large bite out of a piece. My eyes widened I as I felt the 'toast' touch my tongue, it was somehow hot and cold at the same time. 'Fucking hell! It tastes like someone took a shit on a piece of charcoal!' I mentally screamed, trying not to show any disgust or discomfort on my face... even if it had turned to ash after mixing with my saliva.
"D-do you like i-it?" Tami asked me innocently. Swallowing whatever I could, I gave a thumbs up and nodded in approval of what she made, even though I began to tear up slightly.
"It's... great" I said, my voice becoming more and more raspy.
"R-really!?" she asked, seeming very happy at my answer.
"Y-yeah, it's... awesome" I said, doing my best to keep a straight face.
"H-hang on o-one sec, I n-need to g-get B-Benny" she said, darting to Benny's room and bursting through the door without even knocking.