Would you rather...
Cuddle Ticci Toby?
Or
Kiss BEN's forehead?
If you're fangirls of both of them altogether, it would be hard for you. But if you're only a fangirl of Toby/BEN, then it would be easy.
Since I also like Toby(he's cool and cute but still has that scary and creepy side of him- that all Creepypasta need, like it's okay to be cute and hot but still creepy and scary side) I'd choose to cuddle him :3
xoxo,
~Yelly