The Killers' Nightmare (A Female Creepypastas X Male Reader story)

Chapter 34 | Happy Holidays?

However, I wouldn't have guessed that such a simple question would cause the uproar that it did. As I finished my sentence all the girls (minus the walking trio) swarmed me and kept saying "me me me!".
"You really didn't think about this in the time it took us to walk here?" I asked, only to get several head shakes at once. "Alright then, I have a way to decide" I stated, keeping everyone's attention. "Everybody who would like a kiss, please line up single file in front of the door, the order does not matter" I said, allowing everyone to stand next to each other in a near and organised line. "Just for some ground rules, to each of you who want a kiss, you can have up to five seconds" I explained, holding up my right hand and all of the fingers on it. "I'll count down using my hand, and when the timer reaches zero I'll pull away. Understood?" I asked, getting a nod from everyone except Tami, who had her hand raised. "Yes, Tami?" I asked.
"Wh-what if w-we want more th-th-than f-five?" She questioned, innocently enough.
"Well I feel like you're gonna have a lot of problems with everyone else, including the boss lady" I explained, pointing at Slenda who was at the far end of the line.
"G-good point" Tami replied, her sentence punctuated with a nervous gulp.
"Glad you understand, and now: the order of the kisses" I prepared to announce.

"I'm going to go in order of..." I took a pause as I looked along the line.
"Don't lie, you know you're just going to go in line order" Nightmare commented.
'Damn, I've been caught' I responded sarcastically.
"Lazy ass..." Nightmare groaned.
"I'll go in the order off... hmm..." I pretended to think as I rubbed my chin in 'thought'.
"Can you just go in line order? This end to door end solves your thinking issue, and it's most effective for time" Liu noted.
"Yeah, I guess that works" I said with a shrug, thankful that Liu said it before I did.

"Before you start, I have a question" Ann said, raising her hand from her place in line.
"What's up?" I asked back.
"Will you follow our lead or do we follow yours?" She asked.
"Kisser's choice" I said with a shrug.
"You shrug so damn much" Nightmare noted.
"Follow up question, do you take special requests?" She added, leaning out of her spot to let me see her better from the front of the line.
"As long as I'm comfortable with it and no one asks for more than five seconds, sure" I said with yet another shrug.
"Wonderful, thank for answering" Ann said politely before returning to her place.

The order in line went: Jane, Benny, Sally, Ann, Jess, Clockwork, Jackie, Jax, Jill, Tami, Hoodie, Masky, Helen, Slenda and finally, Angel.

Jane's kiss was simple. Nothing crazy, just a peck on the lips that lasted two seconds. It was short and sweet, and she didn't ask for anything in terms of a request. But I feel like she was proud that some lipstick stayed on my lips.

Benny's was quite sloppy, and I'm pretty sure she was trying to go as long as she could. As if Slenda was thinking the same thing, the millisecond my last finger touched my palm I felt her pry Benny off of me. As for her request, she asked if she could wrap her legs around me as I held her up, she said she saw it in a 'movie' once and I had no reason to say no.

Sally only wanted a single peck on the lips, but she used her request to use the rest of her time for hugs and head pats, to which I gladly obliged.

Ann pulled her mask down and me towards her the second I let go of Sally, but before we began she whispered her request in my ear. It was quite the specific one too. She asked for me to count up from zero to five rather than the other way around, and when all five of my fingers were up she wanted me to spank her while I held her close with my other hand on her hip. I had no issue, but I was certainly taken aback by how aggressive Ann's request, moans and kiss were.