Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenari...

By TheNightPhantom

1.4M 36.9K 56K

Read at your own risk! Contains: One deranged killer who wears pink boxers. One little blonde elf.. Midget... More

Quick Author's Note
The First Contact
The Second Encounter
Getting to Know Him
He Finally Asks the Magic Words
Your First Date
He Does Something Stupid
You Wind up in Hosptial
Bonus: Ways to Annoy Him
The First Kiss
Close Calls
He Tries to Do Something Nice
Meeting the Parents
He Does Something Unexpected
He Scares You For 'Fun'
He Flirts With Another Girl
He Gets Pranked/Scared
When He's Sleepy
He Gets Jealous
~Special Chapter~
He Wants to Cuddle
He Gets Sick/Hurt
You Discover an Embarrassing Photo of Him
He Drunk Texts You
He Goes to The Dentist
You Go to a Carnival Together
He Does Something Strange
He Discovers 'Shipping' The Hard Way
You Go Out Somewhere
The Special Chapter
He Goes to a "Therapist"
He Does Something Stupid (Again)
You Discover Your Stalker
A Fun Fact About Him
He Gets Creepy-Napped (Part One)
He Gets Creepy-Napped (Part Two)
You Do Something Fun Together
His Reaction To More "Explicit" Fanfiction
Something Random Happens for No Reason Whatsoever
He Has a Nervous Breakdown
He Catches You Twerking
The Lost Island (Creepypasta Special)
You Catch Him Ballet Dancing
You Watch Anime Together
You Give Him a Present
Suprise Kisses!
He Tells You A Bedtime Story
Two Words: Pranking War
I'm Sorry...
The Fiftieth Chapter
You Tell Him a Bedtime Story
Another Fun Fact About Him
You Cry and He Comforts You
Something Hilarious Happens
The Parodies
Questions For The Creepypastas!
Something Randomly Falls Onto His Head For No Reason
When You Get Arrested
He Steals Something Of Yours
You Attempt Suicide
When You Two Have A Bet
Special Chapter: Pool Party!
You Go Shopping Together
He Meets Your Best Friend
A Random Tuesday
You Get Kidnapped
He's Captured
Special Chapter: Creepypasta Rescue!
He Meets Your Brother
He Gets Amnesia
He Eats Something He Hates
You Visit A Nightclub Together
You Catch/Discover Him Stalking You
You Find Out He's Good With Kids
He's Kinda Going Around Shirtless
When You Both Babysit Sally... (Or Not)
He Catches You Fangirling Over Someone He Hates
You Make Him Cry
When You Rage
When You Get Drunk
When He Cooks
When They Found The Death Note...
When He Visits Your School/Class
You Two Play A Game
When You Have A Random Day
When You Tickle Him/Tickle Fight!
You Watch A Sad Movie Together
Special Chapter: The Halloween Special!
He Wants To Cuddle (Again!)
He Gets Caught Reading Fanfiction About Himself
More Fun Facts!
You Discover A Different Side Of Him
He Does Something Perverted
Playing Truth Or Dare
When He Gets Bullied
He "Tries" Flirting Over Text
Taggy Thingy [Not An Update]
You Catch/See Him "Relieving Tension"
~Christmas Special~
~Christmas Special: Creepypasta Style!~
He "Tries" To Fix Something
Call Of Creepypasta: Tickle War!
You Get Excited
He Catches You Drawing Him/You Draw Him
Another Taggy Thing [Also Not An Update]
~You "Celebrate" Your Anniversary~
He Does Something "Questionable"
You Give Him A Fright!
When You're On Your Monthly
He Tries To Do Something Romantic (Again)
He Encounters (A Lot Of) Fangirls
His Counterpart Pays A Visit
He Experiences A Bad Nightmare (Warning: A Little Sad)
/Hang In There, Folks!/
Even More Fun Facts!
Special Chapter: Milestone Mayhem! (Part Apple)
Special Chapter: Milestone Mayhem! (Part Lemming)
Special Chapter: Milestone Mayhem! (Part Dachshund)
He Takes Care Of You
He "Tries To" Cook For You
He Takes A Bizarre College Class
You Both Encounter A Mary Sue
He Hurts Himself (Accidentally)
He (Tries To) Train For... "Something"
You Celebrate Christmas With Him
A Small Bite Of Entertaining Factual Information
(A/N: An Explanation For My Upcoming Absence)
(A/N: An Explanation For My Upcoming Absence - Part Two)
Checkpoint! (Suggestions Go Here!)
~A Note From Phantom~

You Do Something Romantic Together

3K 125 129
By TheNightPhantom

[Or try to. I'm elated at the turnout of the special chapter, and you guys were too! Here's to many more moments of laugher~! *clinks a glass of apple juice*]

Jeff the Kipper

Deep down in the dark depths of your brain, you were happy to have Jeff back.

High in the other part of your brain, you were fuming at him.

It was a bickering match between the little chibi demon Y/N, and the little chibi angel Y/N, sitting astride on your shoulders. They both had a pretty solid argument.

He deserves a nice kick in the Nutella for taking advantage of being shrunk!
Fumed the devil, steam pouring out of her ears.

No, no, no! Be creative; put laxatives in his coffee!
Advised the angel with a wise nod.

Did we forget to mention? They weren't bickering about whether or not to punish Jeffy boy. They were arguing about the best way to do it.

*^*

Holding a lovely bouquet of velvety black roses by their necks, and sporting a devious smile your face, you turned up at the creepypasta mansion's doorstep.

Smiley answered the doorbell with a yawn, rubbing his sleepy-looking scarlet eyes, scrunching up his lids to shield them from the morning light.

"Hello?"

"Visitor for Jeffy... Jeffy-boo."

"Oh, good morning Y/N." The not-so-good doctor stepped aside and tiredly gestured inside. "Come right in - he's upstairs taking a nap."

You chuckled and stepped into the mansion of serial killers galore. Then, as you went upstairs, Smiley trailed behind, shuffling his feet. A friendly conversation struck up.

"Had a long night?"

"Slenderman burst into my room in the middle of the night to give me a lecture."

"About what?" You blinked.

He covered his mouth (despite already wearing a mask) and yawned again. "Trendorman visited in my absence yesterday and took it upon himself to... redecorate... his wardrobe."

"Yikes. How long did that lecture go on for, exactly?"

Smiley cringed meekly. "Um... well you see-"

On cue, a rather angry-sounding voice boomed from the surgery, reverberating off the walls for all to hear.

"DOCTOR DEVIN SMILEY: COME BACK HERE THIS INSTANT! I'M NOT DONE YET!"

You offered him a sympathetic pat on the disheveled head. "It won't get any better. Toodles~!"

And with that, you left the not-so-good doctor to his fate, and strode into Jeff's room without knocking.

The pyjama-clad crazy killer jumped about a foot off his bed, hiding two Barbie dolls behind his back.

"Y-Y/N! Didn't expect you so early!" He laughed nervously. "I-I can explain, if you want me to!"

You held up your hand dismissively. "Don't wanna know."

"Phew. Okay, good." He stuffed the Barbie dolls under his pillow and sat up straight, swinging his legs over the edge of his bed. "So what's up?"

Grinning broadly, you produced the black roses with a flourish. "I thought I'd get you a gift, Jeffy-boo. It must've been so hard for you, keeping up the spoilt brat act and all that."

Jeff, a little wary from hearing the unusual nickname, hesitantly took hold of his gift.

At once, he shrieked like a little girl and tried to drop them. "They- They're all sticky!"

But they wouldn't come off. His hand was stuck clutching the flowers, even as he desperately shook his fist in a panicked frenzy. Then it got stuck to his hair.

"What is this witchcraft!?"

"Revenge is a dish best served with duct tape and super glue, Jeffy boy," you deadpanned.

BEN Drowned... In warm buttery scones?

You were nursing BEN's bruised ego.

No, really. He'd called you up, to sit next to him on the couch and dish out compliments like candy on Halloween, to build up his pride again.

The little elf grumpily played his video game, button mashing the controller, slouched in a bent posture that rivalled L's. You fed him snacks, trying not to laugh.

He looked cute.

And he'd also noticed your amusement, and was now glaring up at you.

"It's not funny, Y/N! My respectable public image has been tarnished!"

Dark Link, who happened to overhear him as he passed by, choked on some coffee and burst out laughing.

"R-Respectable public image? You never had one to begin with!"

Then he went off on his merry way.

"... Waaah!" He threw the controller down and clambered into your arms. "Hold me!"

You cradled BEN like a baby as he threw a miniature hissy fit, wailing about how it 'wasn't fair' and that 'people just don't understand my unique talents!', while sucking his cheesy dust-covered thumb.

This wasn't exactly the prime idea of a romantic way to spend the day bonding, but was the closest thing you two managed to do.

Dark Link~

Darkness got down on one knee, and kissed your hand in greeting, speaking in a silvery purr. "Good afternoon, milady." He looked up with mischief in his eyes. "Are we going somewhere today?"

You leant in close, and bopped him on the nose. "Movies. My treat."

The devilish twinkling faded, replaced with a look of somewhat horror. "M-Movies?"

"Yup. Why, what's the problem? You're going a bit... pale."

"W-With all that buttery popcorn, and creamy cheesy snacks, and fountains and fountains worth of fizzy canned drinks?" He gripped your hand urgently, as though about to faint.

"In fact, the theatre's having a sale; buy something from the food menu and get thirty percent off, because it's a viewing of 'Cloudy With A Chance Of Meatballs'," you continued without thinking.

Flashbacks to the previous chapter ran through his mind. With a strange raspy wheeze, Dark Link's eyes rolled to the back of his head, and he fainted.

Worriedly, you prodded him with a toe. "Darkness? Darkness? Are you still breathing? Huh. I guess he's not hungry..."

Laughing Hokey-Pokey

L.J burrowed into your bed like an invasive clawed teddy bear during the night, and refused to leave. He snuggled up to your pillow, and left you sitting bemusedly in the cold corner.

You weren't going to let him get away with it, this time. You were going to be strict. Or so you told yourself.

"Laughing Jack, go somewhere else or I'll confiscate your secret stock of candy!"

Unfortunately, this just caused him to get up, pick up the bed, and carry it off downstairs, with you still on it. He set it down in the kitchen, right next to a cookie jar. Then crawled back in.

Left with no choice, and stunned by his sheer cheek, you admitted defeat.

The monochrome clown settled down with a peaceful look. His eyes snapped open wide in surprise, feeling you climb over him to hug the pillow from the other side.

He smiled, and pulled both you and the plump fluffy thing, a little bit closer. And reached up to include the cookie jar too.

Unbeknownst to the fact that the ghost of C/N was squashed up inside it, unsuccessfully trying to munch his way to Narnia. He just got fat and couldn't get out.

Meanwhile, at the Creepypasta Mansion...

In the shower, Zalgo was cheerfully scrubbing his horns with a loofah, using three types of demonic polishing formula. His tail curled around the bottles and threw them to his hand.

He was so engrossed in his humming and grooming, that he didn't notice the door creaking open. Nor the waddle of webbed feet, or the flower-print shower curtain rustling.

The next thing his tail curled around and bounced up wasn't a polish bottle. He realized that, when something sharp bit his hand, honking loudly.

"What the- A-Ah-Achoou!"

He looked down. His pupils shrank in horror. Another kitten-like sneeze caused him to fall over, dropping the penguin like hot butter.

Zalgo kicked the wet floor, sloshing to a corner of the shower, water cascading down and crashing chaotically over his head. The penguin was sitting on the drain, looking cute.

"Nonono! Shoo! Stay away! Stay awa- Achoo!"

A few blinks later, every resident who happened to be wandering on that particular floor (including Slenderman and Smirky), bore witness to seeing the prince of darkness barrel out of the bathroom in a spray of water, a penguin locked in hot pursuit of him.

"GO AWA- ACHOO! ACHOO! LEAVE ME A- ACHOO! ALONE! I'M NOT YOUR MUMMY!"

Flying so erratically, it was no surprise that he careened into a wall and got knocked out cold. Slendy whipped out a camera and took pictures for blackmail purposes.

"It's useful to have the upper hand on your enemies!" he said defensively, in response to quite a few raised eyebrows.

_________________________

A/N: Funnily enough, the pictures disappeared from Slenderman's study a week later. On that day, Smirky went out on an unusual errand to scout out and explore the not-so-local volcanoes.
However, BEN insisted that he saw him coming out of a photocopy shop, stuffing an envelope into his pocket...

I may have been, and still be, half asleep while writing this.
It still all made perfect sense... riiiight? Another quality chapter?

Thank you for reading!
This chapter is hungry.
This chapter is also picky about its food.
This chapter would like to eat some yummy vote stars.
Take a few seconds to feed yours to it, won't ya? :)

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

99.1K 3.3K 22
COMPLETED | BOOK 2 COMPLETE/ You grew up with Zalgo. He taught you everything you ever knew and helped build up your hatred of Slenderman. After you...
6.4K 163 30
'"Jeff?" I ask. He didn't respond. I get up and walk to the door. He gets up and grabs his knife. "Jeff?!" I yell. "Shhhh no need to yell." He says...
698 41 7
A young, hot, but depressed collage girl who only wishes someone would put her out of her misery accidentally stumbles upon an ongoing murder. She do...
45.7K 847 22
All the stories are true. All of the sightings, the myths, the legends, the encounters. Deep inside the darkest forest, is a mansion full of killers...