You're a Nightmare ⋆ Ticci To...

By LovingMe232

8.6K 283 82

Unfortunately Tobias Rogers needs help, and your the only one who can help him. But that doesn't mean either... More

Prologue
Something Bad is About to Happen to Me.
Never Ever Getting Rid of Me.
Sad Girl.
Lotta True Crime.
Hit and Run.
Wildest Dreams.
Lost Cause.
Devil in Disguise.
If I Killed Someone for You.
Lacy.
American Idiot.
Daddy Issues.
I Knew You Were Trouble.
Can't Help Falling in Love.
Fuck Up the Friendship.
Sex, Drugs, Exc.
What Was I Made For?
Dead to Me.
Escapism.
No body, no crime.
End of a Beginning.
Love Story (Taylor's Version).
Save Your Tears.
Kiss Or Kill.
Getaway Car.

You Get Me So High.

205 7 1
By LovingMe232


Chapter 20

"You Get Me So High."

I jolted up awake. A book, my mothers book, jumped with me, and landed on the floor. I wiped my face, a line of drool ran down my face. Gross, I thought. I looked around, and saw Toby passed out next to me, our notes crammed between him and the couch.

I stood up and rubbed my face. When did we fall asleep? I looked around, hoping to find some clues. I tugged on our notebook, and freed it from the couch and Toby. I flipped to the last page Toby had written on, February 3erd was scribbled on top. We almost finished the book.

I looked back over to Toby, contemplating shaking him awake. I shook my head, grabbed my mother's journal, and went to my dining room.

In the kitchen my coffee pot dinged, signaling the coffee was done. That was weird. I walked over to it and picked it up, swishing it around. It looked normal, and it smelt normal. Toby must have made it. How long was he awake?

It was too early for this many questions. I poured myself a steaming cup of coffee, and dressed it up to my liking.


I sat down with my cup of coffee, and the two books. I flipped through my mothers book to February 3erd, then I flipped to the next page. February 14th, valentines day.

Happy Valentines. Was written on the top of the page.

Today was amazing. My baby was able to get the full valentines experience! I bought her chocolate covered strawberries, she couldn't figure out how to eat them at first. But when she finally figured it out she loved them.

I squinted my eyes at the next few words. Confused to say the least.

Scott came over today. He brought some take out, and we had a nice little family dinner. Scotts the guy that I wish was little Y/N's father. He's perfect, sometimes I think he's too perfect, but then I remember who he is, and I remember he's just the one for me!

I remembered Scott. He was far from perfect. I didn't remember him coming around until I was about seven or eight. Guess she waited a while before she let us meet, and for good reason.

Anyways. I thought I wouldn't see it today, but like always I was wrong. After Scott had left I was setting Y/N down to go to sleep, and he was just standing outside of her bedroom. All I could see were his legs. He was just waiting for me to leave. I didn't know what to do, but I had to keep her safe. I sat and prayed for 15 minutes, and when I opened my eyes he had moved about 5 feet away. I could see his emotionless face. I don't think praying is the best solution. I read that salt could help, and I'm waiting on the incense that I ordered. I hope that I can solve this before Y/N gets older.

I looked around the page as if I expected something else to appear but nothing did. I groaned, and wrote down the important stuff.

I flipped to the next page, and as I saw it my stomach flipped. The whole page was blacked out with pen. I brushed my hand over it, and felt every indent the pen had made.

The next page looked the same. And the next page, and the one after that. Finally the page flipped to show a drawing. My eyes shot to each point of it. It looked just like the creature, the operator. It had long dangly arms, and stick thin legs. It had things poking out of its back, like tentacles.

I felt nauseous as I looked at it. I couldn't explain it, it just made me feel sick.

I shot up, knocking the chair over with me. I looked away gagging. My knees buckled and I had to hold onto the table for support. My gagging quickly turned into a violent coughing fit. I heard loud footsteps rushing towards me. My eyes blurred with tears, and before I knew it I felt Tobys hand on my shoulder, as he held me up.

I took one final deep breath, and suddenly the coughing stopped. I looked at Toby with wide eyes as I gasped for air. Toby pulled me away from the table, he knew what caused the whole thing.

"What-." I stopped for another gasp of air. "What was that?" Toby looked at the book with shock filling his face. "The operator's making you sick." He mumbled. "He does it to all his victims." I looked up to him saying, are you kidding me, with my eyes. His eyes met mine, they looked slightly apologetic.

"Well then, I guess we have to get this figured out sooner than later." I shoved myself away from him, when I realized his arms were hugged around me. "We have to go to my mom's house, she'll have the other notebooks." He looked at me like I was joking.

Finally he spoke up. "Are you kidding? You need to get out of here." I shook my head. "I'm finishing this, I told you I would help you." I shut my mom's book without looking at it. I could hear Toby step closer to me. "He's going to kill you, you have to get somewhere he won't be able to reach for you." I stayed silent as I stuffed the notebook under my arm. "Since when do you care?" The room went dead quite, all you could hear was our breathing. I turned around, Toby looked at me with an intense stare.

I waited for him to say, 'fine, get yourself killed,' after all were we actually friends? We were just two people in the wrong place, at the wrong time. As Toby's eyes gazed around the room looking for words a realization hit me. Our arguments gave me a thrill, a high. That never happened before. Was I going crazy? Probably.

"You know." I snapped out of my thoughts and looked back to Toby. "You can be a real pain in the ass." My eyes widened. "Excuse you?" My laugh came out harsh. "You heard me." He leaned back, and I scoffed. "You're one to talk! Look at you, you're the definition of an ass!" We both paused as we tried to make sense of my words.

"You're horrible at trash talk." Toby said, crossing his arms. My heart raced in my chest, maybe this did always happen. "You're.." My words drew out when I couldn't come up with anything to say. I could already feel the cockyness radiating from Toby and his 'win'. "You're impossible." I threw my hands in the air, and broke eye contact, as I walked past him.

I stopped walking in the doorway, I flipped back around to face Toby. "Either you come with me, or I'm going alone." I threw my hands around, as I talked with them. Toby's mouth was plastered in a disappointed frown. "Fine." He finally spat out. I smiled, happy with my win. "Good. Come on, puppet boy." I could feel Toby tense under my words, even though I wasn't looking at him. "Don't push it." He snarled.

After what felt like an eternity, we made it to my mothers house. The car ride actually wasn't that bad. Even though Toby and I had bickered that morning, the car ride was comfortable. I was always comfortable with Toby. I guess that's what happens when you make a life altering decision with someone.

We stood in front of the front door, as I fumbled through my bag, trying to find my moms keys. Finally I pulled them out, with an 'ah hah,' following close behind. The door swung open, and we stepped inside.

"Where are they?" Toby stood next to me. I turned to look up at him. "I don't know, her room?" He again gave me a look. "Let's just slip up, we'll find them faster that way." My heart skipped as he talked. "No way! Are you trying to get us killed? That's like the number one thing not to do in a horror movie." He softly laughed. "You'll be fine." I looked at him like he was an alien. "Have you ever seen a horror movie? Honestly, stuff like this is what makes me remember why I don't like you." I waited for him to argue, to give me the same thrill as this morning. "I've watched plenty of horror movies, I used to watch them with my-." He stopped himself, and stayed quiet for a while. "Actually." He spoke again. "I think you like me a little too much."

My mouth fell open, as I remembered the dream. Oh God the dream. My eyes flicked between his eyes, as I tried to speak, but I couldn't. He smirked in his arrogant way, and walked away, disappearing through a doorway. "You'll be fine!" He yelled in a mocking way.

I snapped out of it, and started slapping my cheeks to get them to return to their normal color.

When I had calmed down, I started walking down the hallway, Toby didn't go down. I went into my moms room. Flashbacks flooded over me. She was dead. I kept forgetting about that. How could I be happy when she was dead? Toby was there. That's why.

I shook my head, and made my way to my moms closet. I think I remember my mom putting them in there when I was younger. I swung the closet doors open, only to see clothes and a bunch of machines.

My hands rested on the handles, as disappointment settled in my stomach. I let go, and started walking out of the room.

Five steps later a crash came from the kitchen. I froze. It was just Toby. I relaxed a little, then immediately tensed up again. There was only one way into the kitchen. My way. Toby couldn't be in the kitchen, I didn't hear him walking into the kitchen, I didn't even hear him walk past me.

I slowly walked out into the hallway. In front of me was the kitchen. It seemed like an impossible task to get my feet to move, and walk into the kitchen. Finally my feet started moving again. I walked towards the kitchen at a painfully slow rate.

Finally I walked through the doorway. I turned right, only to be met with a face. I screamed. A blood curdling scream left my body. The person in front of me did the same. Our high pitched screams filled the room, hurting my ears, and I would assume every living thing in the near radius.

My eyes were squeezed shut. Before I knew it I was tugged away into a protective embrace. "Who are you?" I only stopped screaming when I heard Toby's stern voice. I opened my eyes, and saw.. Mary? My mothers journals were scattered around her, she must have dropped them when we ran into each other.

I looked up to her, and she looked back at me sheepishly. My hands tightly wrapped around Toby's arm. We needed answers, now.

Hello everyone, happy chapter 20, and happy 1K reads! Thank you so much, this has been so much fun.

Anyways, as always, if you enjoyed please, vote, comment, and follow <3.

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

793K 15.5K 44
Because psycho murderers would make great parents, don't ya think?! This isn't just for a female reader, but He/She. Here are the Creepypastas I've w...
19.5K 510 17
No matter where you tried to run, hide- no matter where you turned- that boy was there. From the familiar T shirts to the hoodies- to the manic grin...
1.5K 40 16
Ticci Toby x Reader I do not own most of these characters. Hoodie and Masky (Brian and Tim) belong to Marble Hornets. The rest of the Pastas belong t...
259 16 9
: this story is simply one written for my creepypasta/slenderverse oc. there's not necessarily any romance , but more so traces of it. it's not my ma...