American Horror Story imagines

Your Song ° The Evans

A/N these are kinda old songs 😂 from 50's to 70s.

Jimmy - You're more than a number in my little red book by The Drifters

Jimmy never wanted you to think you were just another girl to him no matter how long you'd been together. It didn't become your song when you first started dating because it hadn't come out yet but as soon as you heard it it was like it was written for just the two of you. "You're more than a number in my little red book. You're more than a one night stand."

Tate - My girl by Otis Redding

Yes be suprised that it isn't Nirvana. While Tate was a die hard Kurt Cobain fan he appreciated most music especially if the lyrics spoke to him. He'd visited you one day and being nosey like he is decided to look through your vinyl collection only to come across this. As soon as the needle played the familiar music a smile appeared on your features, so Tate paid attention to each softly sung lyric to the point he felt like it was his own heart speaking after all you were his girl.

James - Avenues and Alleyways by Tony Christie

James didn't really listen to music anymore as nobody sound like he remembered, it was all far to fake at least to him anyway. After returning to your shared hotel room stained in blood James' eyes fell upon you in the bathtub humming along Christies song as you relaxed. James' watched as you mouthed each word with such care as he fell eve deeper in love with you (not that he would admit that.)

Kit - Saturday night at the movies by The Drifters

It reminded you of your first date and every time it came on the radio you fell in love all over again. It was like as soon as the first note played you were those shy 17 year olds again sneaking away to the drive in just to spend time together. It didn't matter if you were 17 or 38 your love for Kit never dwindled.

Kyle - What a wonderful world by Louis Armstrong

You both originally fell in love with it because of the line "I see friends shaking hands saying how do you do. They're really saying I love you." Kyle and you had been friends since 1st grade both too scared to say anything til graduation in high school when the thought of leaving each other terrified the shit out of both of you (however turns out you both got into the same Uni). When Kyle returns from the dead thanks to Zoe and Madison he loves the song for other reasons 1.) Because it reminded him of life before and 2.) It was a simple love song compared to others and he could see the perfect scene Armstrong was describing.