The Peach-Pounding Peters of Peterson Hall, #2 [Wattpad Edition]

Chapter 5: A Deflowering Ritual for the Deflowered

We nodded, stroking our dicks while watching the scene, except I still wasn't hard yet.

Fabio looked at Hush and made a horny smile. "Go ahead and do the honors, Chosen One. The virgin is all yours until he receives your seed. Give him that big Black cock and show him that you own him tonight."

Hush opened the can of boy butter, then got on his knees behind Jeremy to lube him up.

"I assume you still need help?" Fabio asked Hush while jerking himself. For a strict, play-by-the-rules leader with firm commands, he was both fair and considerate. So far, he hadn't treated anyone like shit the way Buff had apparently done. Though, for some reason, Buff was nice to me, since he really liked me, so who knew?

Hush nodded while gripping Jeremy's waist.

Twunky rushed to grab a phone and played a lesbian porn video. Then, he got down on his knees and held the phone in front of Hush. Asian twin sisters? Kinky!

After getting hard, Hush glided his dick inside Jeremy's secretly used hole.

Jeremy looked tense, and his face was tight like he was trying to take it like a champ. Maybe five times wasn't quite enough to be pain-free.

I played with my big balls, hoping I could get horny again. I wished I wasn't so wiped from all the hot sex Jeremy and I had had. It was the downfall of having helped him loosen up.

Hush slowly started fucking Jeremy, which filled me with relief for Jeremy's sake because it wasn't rough.

Jeremy looked pained in the face while suppressing whatever sounds he probably wanted to make. Was he faking it, or did it really hurt? Hush had the biggest size, after all, so it wouldn't be a stretch, so to speak.

Hush sighed and rolled his eyes. "Damn it," he muttered. His shriveled dick slipped out of Jeremy's hole and hung flaccid.

Twunky gave Hush's shoulder a supportive squeeze, smiling. "It's okay, Chosen One, no rush. And remember, we should all be honest here."

"Sorry, but I'm not turned on at all," Hush said. "I keep getting soft, and that hot video isn't working. I'm not trying to hurt sub's feelings."

If anything, Jeremy was probably relieved. Though, he still had more dicks to take.

Fabio also gave Hush a supportive squeeze on the shoulder. "I know it's challenging because you're straight, but you must come inside sub if you don't want to face the consequences. Chosen Ones who are fallen face harsher punishments because of their elevated status. You know I take this club seriously, and I will not even attempt to fool the higher-ups, not that it's in my nature to do so."

"But I don't think I can," Hush said with a frown. "And it definitely has nothing to do with the video because you already know I love Asian girls. I don't know. Even though I'm straight, I guess some guys are just easier to have sex with than others. Sub's not one of them."

I was stunned because of how much of a hot twink Jeremy was, the typical blue-eyed blond type common in this area, but I realized beauty was in the eye of the beholder.

Fabio now looked annoyed, clearly too impatient for this. "Chosen One, I don't care how you do it, but you find a way to stay hard and come inside sub, or else. Please don't put me in a position to have you punished. We've ever had a fallen Chosen One before. It would be unfortunate if you became the first."

Hush frowned again. "Honestly? I kind of miss Pete for a situation like this, even though he was a disloyal jerk with how he agreed to be kicked out of the Peters. But it was easy with him because he knew how to talk dirty to me and make up a hot fantasy based on the video I watched."

Twunky chuckled. "Sorry if I suck at that."

"It's okay. Pete was also attractive. Him, Twunky..." Hush looked at me and lifted just one corner of his mouth for a weak smile. "And Rock. For being guys, you're attractive."

Himbo grinned. "I'm a guy!" Yeah...he didn't quite get the point. He was actually pretty hot to me, but he was probably not Hush's type for a guy, assuming he even had one for being straight.

"I don't understand," Fabio said, growing firmer but not exactly mean. "You come all the time with us. Well, I don't usually see you come, but you certainly have shot loads in Twunky's mouth multiple times, and I assume when you top, too."

Hush paused, looking like he was guilty. "I...don't...most of the time. When I top, I...fake it."

Fabio lifted his eyebrows and didn't say a word for a moment. "So, you lied to us?"

"Not maliciously!" Hush said in a pleading tone. "Fabio, come on, I'm straight! You have to understand how hard it is for me. It's like you with a woman, same concept."

"I understand, and it's exactly why I resented Buff for having you in the club. No offense. I just never understood why straight guys are even allowed if they can't perform well. But it is what it is." Fabio sighed, shaking his head. "I like you, Chosen One, I do. But I'm starting to realize your sexuality is a big inconvenience to your important role in the Peters club."

This drama was getting awkward and uncomfortable. It was unreal how serious the club rules were. Fabio especially took them to heart, refusing to bend them a bit.

Twunky kissed Fabio's cheek, probably still romantically involved with him. "I mean, sub is technically no longer a virgin since Chosen One did deflower him."

"But he didn't come inside him," Fabio grumbled, his face getting red.

Hush drew a big breath and got up. "I don't want to leave the Peters, but I can't fully come. It could take all night. Can't there be another solution?"

Fabio shook his head again, pursing his lips while his face was redder. He walked to where the camera was and looked straight at it. "I understand all the higher-ups will be watching this soon. To all of you, please know that I will do anything and everything to prove my loyalty to the Peters club. If Chosen One must be punished, I will see to it that it happens. As the leader, I am deeply sorry for this possible failed ritual."

What...?

Fabio glanced at the rest of us, looking very disappointed. "I told you I don't play games. I told you I take my leadership seriously. This club means more to me than you'll ever know." He shifted his focus back to Hush. "This is your last chance, Chosen One. Will you or will you not give your seed to the virgin sacrifice?"

Hush formed the saddest face I'd ever seen. "How severe is the punishment?"

"Wait, Peters, look!" Twunk pointed at Jeremy's butthole. "There's some cum dripping out of Jeremy's hole!"

Oh, shit...that was my leftover cum! Had he not washed well before we'd left?

Fabio lifted his eyebrows at the sight, and the rest of the Peters looked shocked, too. I was convinced Hush knew it wasn't his, which made my heart beat faster than ever.

Would they find out the truth?