Girls:
Aries: The Expressionless
Taurus: Pinkamena
Gemini: Lyra
Cancer: Zero
Leo: Judge Angels
Virgo: Jane the Killer
Libra: Kate the Chaser
Scorpio: Killing Kate
Sagittarius: Sally
Capricorn: Nina the Killer
Aquarius: Laughing Jill
Pisces: Rouge
Guys:
Aries: Zalgo
Taurus: The Pianist
Gemini: no one
Cancer: The Puppeteer
Leo: Bloody Painter
Virgo: Trenderman
Libra: Eyeless Jack
Scorpio: Homicidal Liu
Sagittarius: Laughing Jack
Capricorn: Ticci Toby
Aquarius: Ben Drowned
Pisces: Jeff the Killer