Jack Frost has always longed for romance. But since he had turned into a frost spirit, the guardian of fun and joy, he didn't seem to have time to go on dates, and there wasn't exactly a Tinder for magical spirits. His dreams of love just weren't possible anymore. Or, that's what he thought. Before Hiccup, Pitch Black, and the Tooth Fairy all came forward with their feelings for him. Now, before Jack was even ready, it seems he's surrounded with people who all want to have a future with him, and he's not sure who to choose. He doesn't want to upset anyone, but his happiness is important too, right? Among the four, secrets are revealed and hidden wounds shown. When the dust settles, how many hearts will be frozen, broken, and lost, and dark?